News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by rayiner on Friday November 02, 2018 @01:17AM (#18360862)
Is it? I would answer that question by asking whether it would've been great if Xerox hadn't patented the copier. I think the answer is no, because we probably wouldn't have gotten Xerox PARC and everything it invented if Xerox was immediately thrust into race-to-the-bottom competition with clone copiers. (Note: Xerox and PARC rapidly went downhill after a DOJ antitrust lawsuit forced Xerox to license its copier patents to Japanese competitors.)

What if Xerox had patented the GUI? Maybe Microsoft and Apple would've had to pay to license it instead of just stealing it from Xerox. What innovations did we miss out on because PARC never made any money off GUIs?

Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by EGreg on Friday November 02, 2018 @02:31AM (#18361059)
PARC never made any money not because Xerox didn’t patent things but because they didn’t value those things and shut it down.

In my opinion, patents slow down innovation in any fast moving field like software. This isn’t the 1800s. If we abolished patents in pharma, we could have cures developed for the long tail!

Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by rayiner on Friday November 02, 2018 @08:02AM (#18362361)
Xerox shut down PARC because it lost its patent monopoly and had to start competing with Japanese copier makers. Competition is awful for R&D-intensive innovation. (When was the last time Lenovo or HP invented something? Who does R&D now? It’s companies like Google that have moats in the form of network effects around their users and data.)

If we abolished patents in pharma we wouldn’t have cures for anything. Nobody will blow half a billion dollars on R&D for an easily copied drug without some sort of moat.

Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by EGreg on Friday November 02, 2018 @03:17PM (#18365867)
Exactly. We don’t need John Galts attracting a billion dollars when we have tons of small collaborators contributing far less than a billion dollars. And the results are freely available.

Isaac Newton said he stood on the shoulders of giants. What if had to rent those shoulders, or worse had no access?

If what you say is true (“why would anyone do anything big”) how was science done for years, in every field other than Pharma? How did Wikipedia beat Britannica and the Web beat AOL if capitalism is better?

Look up Clay Shirky’s ted talk Institutions vs Collaboration

Competition and moats are a nice system but in the long run collaboration is simply better!

Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by rayiner on Friday November 02, 2018 @05:20PM (#18366882)
Innovation is more expensive than ever. For example, each new generation of microprocessor costs exponentially more than it did back when Fairchild and Intel were starting out. Physics has morphed from something Isaac Newton could do with some relatively inexpensive tools to something that requires the financial resources of nation states with supercomputers and particle accelerators.

The things that make modern life, well modern: jet engines, AIDS cocktails, micro-processors, electric cars, satellites, nuclear reactors, omnipresent telecommunications, etc., are well outside the reach of "collaboration." Collaboration among amateurs doesn't even move the needle. Genuine useful progress is for the most part the province of big institutions with roomfuls of PhDs. And those require billions upon billions of dollars. And that money has to come from somewhere: defense contracts, irrational VCs, governments, and yes, patent monopolies.

Re:Notorious patent enforcement entity values its entire por... by EGreg on Friday November 02, 2018 @05:36PM (#18366971)
The more expensive it is, the more I'd like to socialize the costs instead of putting all the eggs in one basket and then having private ownership of something huge

See this: https://forum.intercoin.org/t/study-alaska-ubi-doesnt-increa...

I don't think roomful of PhDs always beats the a motivated crowd. Not even a roomful of seasoned intelligence analysts (https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/04/02/297839429/...)

Did a top-down Britannica being sold door to door, the pinnacle of capitalism applied to encyclopedias, beat Wikipedia? Did encarta? Why did Wikipedia win?