The things that make modern life, well modern: jet engines, AIDS cocktails, micro-processors, electric cars, satellites, nuclear reactors, omnipresent telecommunications, etc., are well outside the reach of "collaboration." Collaboration among amateurs doesn't even move the needle. Genuine useful progress is for the most part the province of big institutions with roomfuls of PhDs. And those require billions upon billions of dollars. And that money has to come from somewhere: defense contracts, irrational VCs, governments, and yes, patent monopolies.
See this: https://forum.intercoin.org/t/study-alaska-ubi-doesnt-increa...
I don't think roomful of PhDs always beats the a motivated crowd. Not even a roomful of seasoned intelligence analysts (https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/04/02/297839429/...)
Did a top-down Britannica being sold door to door, the pinnacle of capitalism applied to encyclopedias, beat Wikipedia? Did encarta? Why did Wikipedia win?
Isaac Newton said he stood on the shoulders of giants. What if had to rent those shoulders, or worse had no access?
If what you say is true (“why would anyone do anything big”) how was science done for years, in every field other than Pharma? How did Wikipedia beat Britannica and the Web beat AOL if capitalism is better?
Look up Clay Shirky’s ted talk Institutions vs Collaboration
Competition and moats are a nice system but in the long run collaboration is simply better!