News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by reaperducer on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:16PM (#18340354)
you literally don't need at all

Unless you live in a place without broadcast television, or little broadcast television, and with little to no internet service.

So pretty much 20% of the United States. The nation is much larger than the east and west coasts.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by bunderbunder on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:49PM (#18340655)
You still literally don't need it. Which isn't to say that most people don't want it really really bad, but still, it's different, and words matter.

Moreover, unless you're an extreme binge watcher, I'm guessing you could still consume more than you can eat of video entertainment for less money than the cable companies charge by buying DVDs. Let alone Netflix's DVD service.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @05:56PM (#18341607)
> You still literally don't need it. Which isn't to say that most people don't want it really really bad, but still, it's different, and words matter.

In the economic sense of “need”, it isn't different at all.

Outside of the economic sense, generally “need” is meaningless unless qualified with a purpose.

> Moreover, unless you're an extreme binge watcher, I'm guessing you could still consume more than you can eat of video entertainment for less money than the cable companies charge by buying DVDs.

Buying DVDs is not effective for getting current news, sports, etc., however, whether direct coverage or timely commentary.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by gruez on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @07:24PM (#18342096)
>I'm guessing you could still consume more than you can eat of video entertainment for less money than the cable companies charge by buying DVDs.

how? let's say you're on some expensive cable plan, $120/mo and DVDs cost $15. that works out to 8 movies a month, which might cut it if you only watch a couple of hours of TV on the weekends, but is nowhere enough if you watch daily.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @07:31PM (#18342141)
> let's say you're on some expensive cable plan, $120/mo and DVDs cost $15. that works out to 8 movies a month, which might cut it if you only watch a couple of hours of TV on the weekends, but is nowhere enough if you watch daily.

DVDs are cheaper per hour if you get less-current movies or, even better, less-current TV collections (e.g., the Friends complete series is currently $70 on Amazon, for 80+ hours.)

So, if you are concerned merely with quantity of video content, it may be true that DVDs are cheaper than cable.

If you have concerns about the specific content, then the claim becomes harder to defend.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by diogenescynic on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @11:24PM (#18343110)
A generation of consumers have been raised to rent their content. I have DirecTV now, bundled with my cell plan so I pay like $15 a month. I have an MLB.tv subscription and I buy most of the rest of my media on iTunes. When movies are on sale they are like $6 and tv seasons for $10. I bought the entire Seinfeld catalog for like $60–easily worth the price and not to have to watch reruns with commercials. Generally, I spend $30 a month, so after a few years I have hundreds of movies and a dozens of TV shows. So most of the time I watch news on DirecTV, MLB.tv, or a movie in my iTunes library. I literally don’t understand Netflix and most of the shows on there haven’t been worth it for me to subscribe yet. But I definitely wouldn’t pay for a monthly streaming subscription. Maybe if I had kids.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by astura on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @01:24AM (#18343540)
DVDs can be borrowed from the library or rented from RedBox. You can buy whole seasons of TV shows for like ~$10. DVDs can also be sold when you're done and reduce your expenses further.

It depends on what you want to watch.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by tomjakubowski on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:29PM (#18340479)
Most of the people living in the US between the coasts still live in urban areas. Only a few states have a minority of urban dwellers: Maine, West Virginia, Mississippi, Vermont. Many large interior states have overwhelmingly urban populations: Arizona (90%), Colorado (86%), Illinois (89%), Michigan (75%), Ohio (78%), Nevada (94%), Texas (85%), Utah (90%).

https://www.icip.iastate.edu/tables/population/urban-pct-sta...

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by reaperducer on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:45PM (#18340627)
So if you're not in the "most" category, then what? You don't count? You're not a citizen?

And anecdotally, I know several people who live in urban places who still don't have access to cable television.

Back to the topic, though — the OP stated, "you literally don't need at all." My point is that his postulation is invalid for millions of people.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by na85 on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @08:44PM (#18342512)
Do they actually need television?
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by swsieber on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:43PM (#18340609)
There's still about 20% who live in rural areas. 1 in 5 people:

https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2016/cb16-210...

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @07:37PM (#18342162)
Note that census “urban” is extremely broad, and basically includes what in common discussion would be all suburban and some rural communities, as well as conventional urban ones.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by TylerE on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @06:21PM (#18341765)
I live in a decent sized college town on the East Coast, pop of about 120k.

My options for broadband are cable, or.... nothing.

I mean, I guess technically I can get DSL for $40 more a month than my whole cable bill for 1/10th the bandwidth.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by mikeash on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:33PM (#18340515)
Are there still places with cable TV but not cable internet?
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:38PM (#18340571)
> Are there still places with cable TV but not cable internet?

Cable internet plus OTT live TV service is probably more expensive in most markets than Cable internet plus Cable TV with equivalent channel lineup, you still have to deal with the cable provider, and the OTT TV counts against your internet data cap, if (as is likely without a same-provider TV plan or an extra payment for uncapped data) you have one.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by reaperducer on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:55PM (#18340720)
There are places where cable TV is so sparse that the local electric company runs FTTH.

http://valleycom.com/

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by cimmanom on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @07:29PM (#18342131)
No, food is something you need. A cellphone plan is something you need to function in modern society without an enormous handicap. Television is not something you need.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dpeck on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @04:22PM (#18340945)
cable tv without broadcast... does that combination exist anywhere?
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by mark-r on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @05:33PM (#18341462)
When cable TV was new, that was its entire reason for existing. Not sure about the present landscape but I'm sure it happens somewhere.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by reaperducer on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @06:57PM (#18341954)
Actually cable's origin was to bring broadcast television to areas with poor or no reception. Cable systems were often started by neighborhood groups and local small businesses, which is why "cable" is sometimes called "CATV" — Community Access Television.

Later, satellite-carried "Superstations" were added like WPIX, WTBS, WGN, etc...

Later still, pay television services like HBO and Cinemax were added.

Even later, we ended up with what we have today.

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by astura on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @01:34AM (#18343576)
Yes... Cable is widely available here, yet I live too far away from any broadcast stations to pick them up.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dpeck on Wednesday October 31, 2018 @10:04AM (#18345772)
thanks sibling responders, I learned something new.

I grew up in rural southeast US and I've always associated cable with cities/suburbs and had broadcast/satellite (old giant ones most until middle school).

Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dublinben on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:28PM (#18340461)
Satellite television has been an option for decades, and serves these markets better than cable anyway.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by josefresco on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:36PM (#18340544)
To be fair, Satellite television providers offer the same "boxes" at inflated prices, complete with multi-year contracts.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by reaperducer on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:42PM (#18340596)
FWIW, my Dish network satellite box is half the monthly rate of my old Comcast cable box, and has twice as many features.
Re:How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:42PM (#18340602)
Plus, of the two major satellite providers, one is also a cable company.