News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by greyman on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:22AM (#1833879)
> the "just works" experience of Linux

I am sorry to say that, but I never had such an experience (and i had to use Linux quite a lot in the past).

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by jgrahamc on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:34AM (#1833904)
I've been carrying around laptop machines since just after the Osborne 1 and in more modern times I've had a succession of Thinkpads running DOS/Windows etc., other laptops running Linux (starting with SuSE and later using Ubuntu) and now I have a variety of MacBooks.

The overall experience on laptops with Linux was horrid. Constant problems with drivers, upgrades and miscellaneous crap. The only truly good experience has been on the Mac with OS X.

I have no trouble using all my familiar unixy tools and installing packages, but I do not spend my time with time wasting activities (oh, why doesn't the network driver work right now?(1)) and spend more on development.

Overall, the Macs have been the most efficient machines I've used.

Here's the thing: I'm not an Apple fan boy, I'm an effectiveness fan boy. The Macs win. Just last night I was programming a GSM/GPS module connected to my MacBook Pro via USB emulating a serial port. Module had to be programmed in Python and communicated with using AT commands. No problem at all using EMACS, Python, Tcl/Expect, make, etc. to get things working.

(1) The usual response to that criticism is that its the hardware manufacturer's fault if there aren't open drivers for their device. As a user who needs to get stuff done, I simply don't care. The machine needs to work. Macs do.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by drats on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:47AM (#1833947)
Can you put a date on your Thinkpads? Have you used one with Linux in the last 5 or even 10 years? I am comparing my last OS X experience 10.4/2007 macbook to a X200 Thinkpad with Ubuntu 10.10 (along with the Ubuntu desktop versions for the last 5 or so years... pretty simple to just pick a motherboard with supported chipsets), it's like night and day on the software side and the hardware specs are amazing compared to what you can buy with the same cash in Apple's walled garden.

edit: You don't say anything about a thinkpad in your reply, so I guess you haven't used Linux on a quality laptop in some time. Even at 5 years, that's still quite a way out. I am open to criticism that things have changed since my 2007 experience too, please point anything out.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by AlisdairO on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @11:06AM (#1834473)
I installed fedora on a W510 a few weeks ago. It wouldn't suspend, because the kernel USB3 driver has no support for suspending. Having blacklisted the driver, I find that I can now suspend, but USB doesn't move back to the USB2 driver, it just doesn't work. Still working on that one. Fortunately, when attached to a base station the USB2 only ports on that work fine.

Your other point that I take issue with is that you can get substantially better hardware outside of apple for the same price. In my experience, a laptop with similar power, battery life, weight, size, and build quality is not a great deal cheaper.

Please note that I say this as a lover of linux in many ways. It's a fantastic desktop/server OS, and I think apple's desktop offerings are poor value in comparison, but I can't say I've ever had a good experience with linux on a laptop.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by jgrahamc on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:50AM (#1833957)
The last laptop I installed Ubuntu on was in 2005. I still have that machine and use it occasionally.

edit: The machine I installed it on was a Fujitsu Lifebook. I don't recall the actual model number but it was absolute top of the line machine when I bought it. In recent years (2009, 2010) I've used Linux on a couple of Acer machines which we have in the office. The user experience does not appear to have improved when it comes to dealing with annoying problems.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by grammaton on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:16AM (#1834239)
Couldn't agree with you more. A few months back when my previous macbook had an unfortunate meeting with some stray beer, I was in the market for a new laptop, and I couldn't even bring myself to consider anything else - it just felt painful to even think about it. There are some very nice PC laptops out there - the Dell Adamo series, the HP Envy, and the IdeaPad immediately come to mind - but they're all more expensive than a comparable Apple laptop - and they don't run my OS of choice! Sure, you can try that shady hackintosh noise, but for the most part, that puts you right back in the endless tinkering camp with the Linux on laptops crowd. Apple makes great laptops that just work, they deserve the praise they get for them.

(1) Couldn't agree more here. This "manufacturers need to make open drivers" is just a bunch of whiny noise. Grownups who have things to do don't have time to worry about that crap.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by robin_reala on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:32AM (#1834313)
(1) Luckily the Linux Driver Project agrees with you, and will make the drivers for manufacturers if they ask: http://www.linuxdriverproject.org/foswiki/bin/view/Main/WebH...
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by mkr-hn on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:53AM (#1834414)
People have offered to write the drivers, and even agreed to sign NDAs. What more is the Linux side expected to do?
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by ericd on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @11:27AM (#1834566)
Maybe they could target a few specific machines, making sure those work perfectly, and then use those as reference machines that people can buy if they want a no-hassle experience.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by grammaton on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @11:29AM (#1834577)
No one is questioning the community's dedication in this regard. It's just that, if the manufacturer nixes the idea, for whatever reason - from the users standpoint it just doesn't matter, the software doesn't work with their hardware. When it comes to devices working there's no such thing as an A for effort.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by gamble on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @12:30PM (#1834851)
Indemnify them against lawsuits? I understand that a large part of the reason hardware manufacturers don't want open or third-party drivers is that they could be used as an excuse to troll through their product looking for potential IP violations that could fuel a patent infringement lawsuit.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by drats on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:36AM (#1833914)
I used to have problems in the late 1990s and early 2000s, but then I did what Apple does with OS X and paid a little attention to the hardware and all the problems went away. Most Linux problems are people fighting against hardware, if you just pick your chipsets sensibly it all works out of the box. Beyond hardware I was simply staggered at how quickly I was up and running with a fresh install of Ubuntu 10.10. Everything was in the repository, Flash, Chrome, Gnome-do, codecs... I'd have been running around for an hour or two extra trying to get the same stuff for OS X. And then on the server-side you go to just about any software project and they have the recommended ways to install "sudo apt-get install oursoftware" there, as are copious post-install setup guides. Can't say I found the same experience on OS X (10.4) when I used it for a year and a bit, it was always a clunky struggle to get things installed.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by demallien on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @09:04AM (#1833999)
Most Linux problems are people fighting against hardware, if you just pick your chipsets sensibly it all works out of the box

You see, right there is the problem. I don't have to think about that when using a Mac. The drivers are always there, and they always work.

Despite your claims, Ubuntu and the other linuxes out there do not "just work". I have not yet met a linux laptop that didn't do weird things when I close then reopen the lid. I have yet to meet a linux laptop that deals with finding itself on different networks in an elegant manner.

To put my comments into perspective, for my day job I write userland applications for a Gentoo-derived system, and I do my dev work on a Fedora laptop. At home, I develop for my own company on a Mac, targeting Mac applications. I like to think that I have a reasonable handle on the pros and cons of the two environments. About the only time I find linux compelling is when I want to use an open source package that isn't available on MacPorts. But then, I usually just go and grab a gentoo ebuild for configuring the package in question, create a ruby script to replicate the ebuild, and then install from tarball... It's not a big enough pain to justify sacrificing all of those yummy Apple APIs. If you're an app writer, Cocoa blows GTK out of the water.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by jbm on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:26AM (#1834287)
It seems to be a bit disingenuous to contend that a small amount of research before making a 1400-1500$ investment is too much to think about.

I had a problem with sound with Ubuntu 7.10 on my laptop (It came with Vista which was slowing it down). When 8.04 came out, the problem vanished. I haven't had any hardware issues since then. Ubuntu has also worked flawlessly on the 3 or 4 machines I've installed it on since then.

I can come up with 3 or 4 reasons why Ubuntu is irritating to use, but "headache with drivers" really comes near the bottom of the pile nowadays. Certainly, the ability to install it on any piece of hardware and put in nearly any peripherals and see it work is a huge bonus.

Your second point (about building software on Mac) seems to be from an entirely Ruby-based perspective. I work with a mac server at work, and it was an insane adventure to get Django functional for a web project; as opposed to the 5 minutes (apt-get + config apache) it took to get it functioning on Ubuntu.

(The problem was mostly around installing python-mysql on a Mac Server; the solution was on Apple's site and involved downloading an additional set of header files, in case you ever run into that)

I'm glad that you enjoy the Mac platform; but I don't think the cost-benefit ratio is quite there for me. (It won't be until I'm making 3 or 4 times my current salary.)

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by scott_s on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:53AM (#1834410)
It seems to be a bit disingenuous to contend that a small amount of research before making a 1400-1500$ investment is too much to think about.

It is when I have no way of testing what I've researched, and no guarantee that I made the correct choices. I'm willing to pay a little more for such a guarantee.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by mkr-hn on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:59AM (#1834445)
How much work is it to compare a feature list to the HCL on your distro of choice? Hardware either works or it doesn't, and problems are rarely unique to a given unit in a line of hardware.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by calloc on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @12:37PM (#1834882)
My chipset is fully supported, until it comes time to switch modes using the nouveau driver for my Nvidia graphics card causing Ubuntu 10.10 to throw a black screen instead of showing me X11.

I then had to add an extra parameter to my kernel boot line according to some forum posts to make sure it would let me get the installer (nomodeset or some shit like that), after that it installed correctly but Ubuntu 10.10 does away with Grub in any way shape or form so the next time it booted after install I couldn't change that line so I had to boot into a live CD.

Then changing /mnt/etc/default/grub.cfg doesn't let me write that out to disk since update-grub tries to look for the currently mounted partition you want to modify in mount and won't find one with a LiveCD it can modify and as such that goes out of the window. You have to modify /mnt/boot/grub/grub.cfg and they have made an ungodly mess out of that file.

After I finally figured that out the system still didn't work correctly, so I install the proprietary nvidia driver using their tool, and yet at boot it still does the wrong thing because the nouveau driver is still installed. Finally remove that and Pulseaudio causes my kernel to crash randomly, especially when watching Flash video content. At least I assume it is Pulseaudio, it is the last thing mentioned in /var/log/messages EACH and EVERY time.

Since I needed an OS that could run Boxee (it really is too bad it doesn't work on FreeBSD) and didn't cost me any money I finally just grabbed Arch, installed X11 with the nvidia driver, installed Boxee and it works. It hasn't crashed at all since install.

Linux doesn't just work, and ultimately I was getting really frustrated with the whole thing. I own multiple Windows machines (two Lenovo's, absolutely fantastic), I run FreeBSD as a gateway machine (and have used it for years as a Desktop machine), OpenSolaris as a server and xVM machine, and own one MacBook Pro. I can clearly say that Linux still has a long WAY to go before it is as easy as Mac OS X, and has the same "just works" features. I've had less issues using PC-BSD on the same hardware as Linux, and FreeBSD the underlying OS generally doesn't have the support from vendors for hardware drivers as Linux does.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by anamax on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:50AM (#1834397)
> Most Linux problems are people fighting against hardware, if you just pick your chipsets sensibly it all works out of the box.

True, but easier said than done.

First you have to find out what chipset a given laptop has. The salescritter won't know, the advert doesn't say. The manufacturer's website might have the info, but it won't be easy to find.

Now you have to figure out if the chipset is supported. That's non-trivial because the "supported" lists don't necessarily use the same chipset names as the manufacturer. Sometimes minor variations don't matter but sometimes they do.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:49AM (#1833954)
Some of the bundling of stuff with Linux is nice as a time saver on initial install. Having recently spent two days rebuilding a Windows machine (of which a large chunk was just tedious fetching and installing chrome, flash, shockwave, air, acrobat type stuff) this sort of thing is significant. I've never found OS X to be problematic for installs but the basic act of gathering stuff up to put on the machine is basically dead time.

But the comment "if you pick your chipsets sensibly" - frankly most people don't want to have to do that sort of research. There are enough variables in the basic specification / vendor decisions without having to drop down to this level.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by grammaton on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:23AM (#1834277)
The chipset is just one variable when choosing a laptop. If a laptop has a great chipset for Linux but looks like a pile of ass and weighs five pounds, who cares what the chipset is? What about usability? For the average (non Linux zealot) user, they'll pick their laptop on the basis of portability and yes, to some degree, aesthetics. If Linux doesn't work on that laptop - and quite often, it won't - then as far as they're concerned, it doesn't work well on laptops, and they're right.

Disclaimer: I am a big fan of FreeBSD - if you think linux is bad on laptops.....

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by bilban on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @10:53AM (#1834411)
Apple hardware isn't as diverse I'd wager, and as such it's more likely that an Apple OS will be more tailored to work with Apple hardware. That and the quality build, make up the premium.

Some laptops are stamped with Linux support - something like Suse professional and they are more likely to work.

It's a bit of a gamble at the end of the day, and I'd say the same for Windows running on a laptop. If every thing just works, praise the lamas - keep it. A bit of homework certainly helps before going out and buying something.

I have OSX Tiger on an old power book. Free quality apps are few and far between. Though I like the OS. Loads of apps on Windows, but I don't like the UI.

OSX and W7 users can always just place Linux in a VM if they wanted to and have the best of both worlds. Ideology and small touches in Gnome keep me wedded to Linux.

I still blame the hardware vendors...

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by grammaton on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @11:33AM (#1834587)
You're quite correct, it's a known fact that Apple hardware is not nearly as diverse. This is a valid point in the carping about Windows stability in many cases - Windows has to deal with orders of magnitude more hardware than Apple does, and the difference is one of the big reasons for OS X's stability (along with the Unix underpinnings). As for the hardware vendors, it may well be their "fault" but the average user won't care - as far as they're concerned it either works or it doesn't, and at the end of the day, they're right.
Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by bilban on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @11:55AM (#1834673)
Agree. Users really aren't that bothered as long as it works.

There are certainly faults with my aging Powerbook both with the hardware and software.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by calloc on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @12:40PM (#1834900)
FreeBSD on laptops works just fine, if you don't mind not having resume/suspend or battery control, or anything along those lines :P

Yes, I run FreeBSD on various laptops I own...

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by calloc on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @12:25PM (#1834820)
I was installing Ubuntu Linux on a older machine but with a new Nvidia graphics card and Ubuntu because of the new nouveau driver showed me a black screen while installing. I had to find a forum post on the issue only to find out that I had to edit the kernel boot parameters by adding something to the end of the boot line.

That pretty much ended that little escapade into trying to get that working... I don't want to tinker with my machines. I want to set them up and have them go for months if not years. Just set up Boxee on ArchLinux, don't plan on touching that for a long time. It does what it is supposed to do (play movies and tv shows) and that is that.

Re:Goodbye, MacBook Pro. The New MacBook Air Is That Good. by JofArnold on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:35AM (#1833910)
+1 and I've used Linux for about 5 years (as my main OS until when I switched to OSX last year)