(Paid by oracle) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120419070127103
(Paid by microsoft) http://techrights.org/2012/08/18/vile-lobbyist/
(Paid by apple? I can't find other/primary sources to back up this claim though it does seem likely.) https://mrpogson.com/2012/08/21/apples-paid-shillconsultant-...
(More examples of him being wrong) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120820111527257
Refuting legal arguments takes time and expertise I don't have. He's good at his job, and I have no knowledge about this case. So while I put no faith whatsoever in his analysis I can't tell you how it is wrong, and yes this is an ad hominem.
He was right, and even if at time everybody was mad because it hurt Android. I think this ruling was ultimately a good thing for FOSS.
He was also one of the first to criticize half-FOSS approach of Android. Whereas today everybody seems to regret that we still lack a popular real FOSS OS for smartphone.
One can only wonder now if Firefox OS or another could have superseeded Android should Google reinterpretation of Java copyright had been deemed unfair sooner.
PS: sorry for this long rant about your ad-hominem. Next time I’d better simply downvote.
You have to remember that Oracle mostly lost that case, and he was consistently predicting they would win. The copyright portion was a sideshow to the patent portion (originally) and only became a focus when they lost the patent side of things.
Either way, I appreciate the reply.
For those interested, there is still a possible supreme court appeal pending for the copyright side of the case. I'm not too familiar with supreme court scheduling but I think we should find out if cert is granted (the supreme court will hear the case) in March or April. Google files by January 25th, Oracle briefs in February (30 days after Google, though it's possible they will get an extension), Google files a reply brief (~10 days), then Cert review occurs. https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/do...
The supreme court only grants cert in ~1% of cases, so assuming they deny cert this then goes back to the district judge for yet another trial on damages and probably new motions for attorney's fees. It wouldn't surprise me to find that one (or both) parties find something to appeal about that damages trial too.
This case started way back in 2010, the justice system moves very slowly...
Groklaw was not paid by IBM, court filing by IBM: http://www.groklaw.net/pdf/IBM-621-E19.pdf
Groklaw was run by Pamela Jones, a paralegal. This can be verified by checking the footer on every page on Groklaw, or alternatively the above IBM court filing.
You will have to be more specific about your techrights complaints. I'm not aware of any issues with the site, but I admit that unlike Groklaw I do not have much knowledge about their integrity.
You can find many alternative sources saying that Mueller was paid by Microsoft (and also that Mueller was paid by Oracle), here is one: https://gigaom.com/2011/10/18/419-is-patent-expertblogger-fl...
However, unless my searching capabilities are failing (sorry, it's 170 pages), they nowhere claim that intel is paying qualcomm.
Instead, the only viable claim for exhaustion they really make is around exhaustion of patents in qualcomm chipsets bought by apple.
That is probably right. But not a significant amount of this money (if any, i didn't look what qualcomm claimed hard enough. I wouldn't put it past them but it would be stupid of them)
The majority of money is precisely about modems they buy from intel.
If intel was paying qualcomm, it would definitely appear in the response as an exhaustion argument I can't find it.
This is probably why bloomberg doesn't cite it - the exhaustion issues they do cite are a complete sideshow.
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/bloomberg-reporters-compensa...
The businessinsider article dates from 2013 and I can't find a source discussing their current practices.
http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/QCOM/6406790406x0x982...
Beginning in the third quarter of fiscal 2017, GAAP and Non-GAAP results have been negatively impacted by our dispute with Apple and its contract manufacturers (who are Qualcomm licensees). We did not record any QTL revenues in the first nine months of fiscal 2018 or the third or fourth quarter of fiscal 2017 for royalties due on sales of Apple’s products. We expect the actions taken by these companies will continue until these disputes are resolved. QTL revenues in the third quarter of fiscal 2018 included $500 million paid under an interim agreement with the other licensee in dispute (which dispute was previously disclosed). This represents a partial payment for royalties due after the second quarter of fiscal 2017 by that other licensee while negotiations continue. This payment does not reflect the full amount of royalties due under the underlying license agreement. We did not record any revenues from the third quarter of fiscal 2017 through the second quarter of fiscal 2018 for royalties due on the sales of the other licensee’s products. If we do not reach a final agreement with the other licensee, it may not make any other payments or may not make full payments under the underlying license agreement, which may result in increased legal costs and will negatively impact our GAAP and Non-GAAP results.
If Intel is manufacturing an Apple design as a contractor, Intel’s licenses don’t matter and it’s Apple who’s on the hook to pay royalties. If Apple is buying an off-the-shelf Intel product, it’s Intel’s licence terms that matter.
Otherwise would be like paying a sales tax at each transaction through the chain.
They are seeking a judgement based on the legal concept of patent exhaustion.
https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaustion_doctrine_under_U.S...
If Apple buys a cellular modem from Intel, for instance, and Intel has already paid Qualcomm to use their standards essential parents to manufacture those cell phone modems, then patent exhaustion holds that Qualcomm cannot force Intel's customers to pay to license those patents all over again.
Until a judge rules on this, you really can't say that Apple owes Qualcomm anywhere near that figure.
There is more information on the FOSS patent blog:
http://www.fosspatents.com/2018/10/patent-exhaustion-keeps-q...
Edit: I think this FOSS patent blog entry from last month does a better job of laying out the basic issues.
http://www.fosspatents.com/2018/09/apple-foxconn-et-al-want-...