How much of this is regulation thats around to protect the society that the hotel is operating in? Changing those sheets everyday isn't just for having clean smelling sheets, but to prevent pests such as bed bugs in some localities. For instance there's probably tons of people whod jump on doctors/dentists who lower the price by not cleaning all their tools properly, but we have regulations requiring it because it can create an epidemic that causes negative externalities to the wider community.
I think I'd have less of a problem with Airbnb if there was any sort of enforcement of health laws or putting effort into not supporting people who sign leases saying they won't do Airbnb but do it anyway.
Having a lower price just shows that is the most efficient use of scarce resources in that specific situation, it does not show that it's good for society.
No, it's not 'specific'. The 'rent' marketing clearing price for a locale is a function of a vast array of economic inputs. That's the whole point of free markets, and why it's difficult to dictate terms around it.
The fact that there is a vast influx of AirBnBers in so many areas is not a small things, it's really quite apparent that the artificial controls set by zoning are far more constrictive than we ever thought - and they should be loosened. There are all sorts of external surpluses lost when markets are not efficient.
Also - I fundamentally doubt that people are just 'getting sick' because of AirBnB and 'not having their sheets changed every day'. I just don't believe it's an issue. FYI hotels have stopped changing sheets every day as well, they usually say 'to preserve water' which is BS - it's cost - but they generally do make the bed and clean every day which is unnecessary.
I would probably ban AirBnB for anything but special kinds of places, and maybe not allow it in residential buildings, at least allow building owners/coops to enforce it.
And then also be far more lax with hotel zoning and regulations as well.
Every city wants more 'tourism' until they get tourists and they get pissed off. Well, those tourists bring in tons of cash.
Every city wants business to invest and 'high tech' jobs until the locals complain about 'Google values' and 'home prices'.
The market for both hotels and taxis is just too vastly distorted - and we all lose - especially consumers who would only be able to afford 1/2 as much travel otherwise.
There should be a lot more hotels and taxis.
The other part of your comment that I can identify with is the “save the environment” signs you see at hotels. It’s completely disingenuous and it’s one of the rare small things that irrationally infuriates me. Every time I read one of those signs I think something along the lines of “if this didn’t save you money you wouldn’t care”. I inevitably end up pondering the decisions that the hotel could make that would help save the environment many times more than a few wash cycles. Decisions that the hotel obviously wouldn’t take because it would cost the hotel money instead of saving them money. Perhaps my disaffection is mostly because the signs are a perfect example of corporate bullshit; the exact sort of facade you would expect from a faceless corporation that will say anything to get your money.
If this actually was true, wouldn't there be regulations for changing sheets daily in every home as well?
AirBnB is aggressively strict about reviews. Too many 4 star reviews and you get “punished.” One of my listings in France got suspended for a week because it had an average review of 4.4 stars! Yet a French hotel that gets a slew of 2 star reviews on TripAdvisor or similar doesn’t get touched. AirBnB reviews are far more effective than regulation in weeding out “bad” places. I have stayed in plenty of shithole hotels across Europe despite “regulation.” Some hostels are downright poisonous. I have stayed in a few rat-hotels in the Bowery in New York and those places are still around. I have gotten sick more times at US restaurants than in years of eating street food in East Asia. AirBnB isn’t a health risk of any significance; I would invite data to the contrary. Besides, even if it were a health risk, nobody forces you to stay in one. In this era of nonsense warnings such as “don’t use a hairdryer in the shower” or coffee cups warning that coffee is hot, I have become quite sick of well-meaning people who seek to infantilize grown adults and protect them from various boogeymen that could be avoided with simple common sense: rats in the dining room? Don’t eat there. Dirty sheets or fire hazards? Don’t sleep there. A place selling for $10 per night when everywhere else is $100? Use your brain, do your homework, be a responsible grown up and stop expecting government to protect you from bedbugs.
This is regulatory arbitrage for sure by AirBNB and hosts. The answer (theoretically) would be to more granularly undersrand the costs and benefits to all parties and redistribute appropriately. Unfortunately, neither the public or private sector is incentivized to solve this fairly - “competition” won’t solve it. Seems like a case where regulation would be the answer - it’s just unlikely any single city will solve it well, much less all of them.
I think it's 80% an issue of artificial market distortion due to limitation.
Cities need to rethink this. There is zero negative burden to my neighbourhood if the building I live in happened to be a hotel.
It's time for a rethink.
For every 'noisey airbnb' you hear about, there are 1000x regular noisy neighours.
The most obvious being the length of their stay. People only staying in a place for a week or less tend to not care about the neighborhood, because it's not their neighborhood. They don't have to rub shoulders with the neighbors for years, they don't have to keep a reasonably friendly relationship with them. They're probably never going to meet those people ever again.
Plus these are people on vacation and often on a budget, so a younger demographic, in the attractive part of a city. It can get rowdy.
Of course there are nice short-term renters as well. I go to a 3-day festival at the other end of the country every year, with 5 of my friends. We book with the same person every year, and Airbnb cuts our accomodation costs to less than a third, compared to even the cheapest hotel rooms. But we're all in our 30s and out of the "party until 4 in the morning" phase. We just need a decent place to sleep and eat breakfast.
And we certainly faced scrutiny the first time. 6 people, going to a beer-drinking headbanging metal festival? Yeah, that sounds sketchy and I absolutely understand their initial skepticism. But we had a personal connection who could vouch for us. This is also an apartment where the guy actually lives, he just stays over at his girlfriend's place whenever he rents it out. It wasn't bought specifically to rent it out.
And I've heard some real horror stories from friends, who did rent out through Airbnb and they all say "never again!". As do everyone in the condo building I live in, we've banned all short-term rental after a few nasty experiences.
E: Actually a law just passed here, limiting short-term rentals to 70 days per year maximum. I think that's a decent way to do it.
That's not obvious at all. It's a hint but not evidence.
Why do you think a hotel would be worse quality than residential?
I live in a mixed neighbourhood and many of my neighbours are already roach motels.
Franky, in all my travels I've never come across the proverbial roach motel, or anything totally run down.
My concern would not be the business or people - just parking. As long as there isn't a big parking lot, there's no reason why I couldn't be next to a short term residential unit, I don't think many people would have any problems at all.
There's nary a difference between a hotel of a certain type, and residences. There are people living there.
'Parking lots' are massively different than any other kinds of space.
As long as the hotel fits the local aesthetic, i.e. only 5 stories high if the other buildings are, 1 story high if the others are ... then there's nothing wrong with them at all.
Those decisions already have to be made. 'Regulations' already have to start and stop somewhere.
There are restaurants all up and down my street and people seem to get along fine.
What ABnB has demonstrated is that there is a vastly underserved market for regular travellers, who have no interest in 'having their sheets changed every day' - rather, they just want a decent and convenient space - and they can't afford the $250/night for a boring room 'corporate' rate.
If hotels and their regulations were efficient - then AirBnB would only be used what is was kind of meant for: either sharing/hosting - or - renting out fairly 'special' places that just don't fit regular criteria.
Most AirBnB stays are a matter of price and convenience.
The fact that I can stay in cities, in a decent place for less than 1/2 the cost of a hotel is what makes me hate AirBnB less than hotels and city regulators.
Something is deeply wrong with the hotel and regulatory areas there or else AirBnB wouldn't be a huge-huge thing.
A commenter below about a building that seemed to be AirBnBers ... think for a moment how even more efficient it would be if the whole dam thing were just a hotel, with a maid staff that only cleaned and changed the sheets between stays and could provide keys/keycodes. As it stands, even AirBnB is not near real 'cost efficiency' because there's so much 'little overhead' with each rental.
Not only should that building be a hotel but it should be cheaper than AirBnB! In fact, if markets were reasonably competitive AirBnB should generally be more expensive.
I understand that individual patrons don't have nearly the safety and regulatory expenses ... but it doesn't add up.
City regulators and hotel operators need to figure out a slightly different model.