News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by joshmn on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:27PM (#18313154)
That's not how you get to the top of HN.
Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by omarchowdhury on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:37PM (#18313215)
But being contrarian to anything to do with blockchain/crypto is definitely a way to get comment upvotes on HN.
Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by pavlov on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:47PM (#18313262)
“Contrarian” implies there’s some kind of consensus that blockchain projects are useful. They’re not, as evidenced by the minuscule numbers of actual users. All the talk of “crypto Web 3.0” is total bullshit with no plausible path to executing on any of the promises made.

But of course there’s thousands of people who still hope to make rich like the 2017 ICO scammers, so the hype train rolls on with these pointless expensive conferences around the world where the faithful console themselves that another boom is surely coming. The crypto-faithful are the contrarians.

Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by codyb on Friday October 26, 2018 @07:06PM (#18313343)
I'm not particularly pro blockchain although I think the tech is pretty neat. The only example of a blockchain being useful I've seen was Estonia's cross roads. They use it for their citizens, so things like medical records are stored on there somehow, and then every view of them is recorded. This way you can see who is looking at your info, and punish bad actors for doing so.

I think they use it for other aspects too, maybe voting? Not sure.

But of course that's totally centralized.

No idea what the hell web 3.0 is or how that'd work.

Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by pavlov on Friday October 26, 2018 @07:31PM (#18313434)
Storing medical records on an immutable multi-party blockchain is not only a terrible idea but also clearly illegal in the EU (of which Estonia is a member).

So most likely it's a regular database -- and then we're back to my original comment: where's the use case for "custom blockchain" over PostgreSQL?

Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by phillux on Saturday October 27, 2018 @04:11PM (#18317450)
use cases that require the functionality of reaching distributed consensus on what should be added, removed, stored on that DB.

in blockchains, how consensus is reached is also formalized so that there is a verifiable and distributed audit trail for every user. blockchains also automatically backup everything in a more distributed fashion, allow for higher participation, enable incentive mechanism experimentation, tokenization, useful ZK-proofs... all without the NEED to trust trust a centralized DB.

if it doesn't have any of the above features, then a reason for using a centralized, private blockchain is to more easily distribute/decentralize that consensus-reaching DB in the future.

... also, blockchains aren't immutable if the consensus agrees to change something inherent in the protocol. this happens with every hard fork.

Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by arcticbull on Saturday October 27, 2018 @02:28PM (#18316998)
I can't think of a single reason why a MySQL instance couldn't do the same thing. If you can trust a single entity, in this case the Estonian government, a blockchain is just a database but harder.
Re:Parity founder demos Substrate, live launches a blockchai... by dang on Friday October 26, 2018 @07:05PM (#18313342)
The HN community has become pretty thoroughly cynical about blockchain stories.