Re:Why almost everyone was wrong about Tesla’s cash flow sit...
by calabin on Friday October 26, 2018 @03:34PM
(#18312148)
1) I agree that there are certain instances, especially in startup-land, where we have to bet the company. Lord knows I've had to do it with the company I'm a part of. That said, I don't think that this was one of those moments.
2) I've worked intimately with both buy and sell side clients, so I have pretty good first-hand knowledge of analysts on "the street". I can confirm to you that they are as irrational and misinformed as much of the general public. Bringing attention to themselves and their firms plays a big role in what they say/do. I agree that there has been a ton of irrational work done on Tesla, but I think that a reduction in target prices to reflect the company's financial state was reasonable.
3) I think we both just see this very differently.
I agree on Mulally, that would be great. Thanks for the detailed responses and thoughtful back-and-forth.
2) I've never thought that anything the street did around Tesla was rational. I just watched Mark Speigal still hold on to his position that Tesla is doomed.
3) I agree it was irresponsible - but I also disagree with your thesis that it was manipulation. Elon had access to the sales number, and the ramp. He didn't need tweet to inflate the stock - that would have happened (with a much larger market cap then today) at the end of the quarter. That just puts it back to twitter induced stupidity.
Thanks for the well-reasoned response here. I think we are agreed on Tesla governance going forward. I am really praying that the Mullally runner is correct. That would make me a very happy camper.