2) I've never thought that anything the street did around Tesla was rational. I just watched Mark Speigal still hold on to his position that Tesla is doomed.
3) I agree it was irresponsible - but I also disagree with your thesis that it was manipulation. Elon had access to the sales number, and the ramp. He didn't need tweet to inflate the stock - that would have happened (with a much larger market cap then today) at the end of the quarter. That just puts it back to twitter induced stupidity.
Thanks for the well-reasoned response here. I think we are agreed on Tesla governance going forward. I am really praying that the Mullally runner is correct. That would make me a very happy camper.
2) I've worked intimately with both buy and sell side clients, so I have pretty good first-hand knowledge of analysts on "the street". I can confirm to you that they are as irrational and misinformed as much of the general public. Bringing attention to themselves and their firms plays a big role in what they say/do. I agree that there has been a ton of irrational work done on Tesla, but I think that a reduction in target prices to reflect the company's financial state was reasonable.
3) I think we both just see this very differently.
I agree on Mulally, that would be great. Thanks for the detailed responses and thoughtful back-and-forth.
2) You're right, by car manufacturer standards the company is trading at an incredible premium, I should have been more clear. I meant discounted in the sense that "the street" marked their targets on Tesla down from where they had been as a result of these financial concerns.
3) The term "discussions" may even be too strong for the few conversations that occurred prior to the tweet. It was incredibly irresponsible, and it's somewhat difficult to interpret his intent as anything but to manipulate the stock price and punish short sellers.
The author did not debunk the claim that cash management was a problem. Cash management was a problem and may continue to be a problem in the future. Rapid cost-cutting and non-payment to vendors seems indicative of poor cash management to me. Anytime that a company's runway becomes a relevant part of an objective analysis, there are cash issues. Tesla did not need to give cause for investors to call into question its financial stability in order to make the Model 3.
Don't get me wrong, I want Tesla to thrive. It just seems as though many of these issues of financial stability need not have occurred. I agree that better governance is in order and that Tesla and many other organizations can benefit from a greater degree of independent oversight.