Not once does he mention of any correction for the obvious bias that people make different amounts at different points in their careers.
Using his exact same process, you could also show that the average height of Americans has increased significantly in the past thirty years, possibly up to a foot! Because, duh, people are shorter when they're kids.
If you're trying to measure how the economy is doing over time, you don't want panels, you want to compare equivalent people at different points in time. Comparing a 20 year old in 1980 to a 50 year old in 2010 confounds the differences between 1980 and 2010 with the differences between being 20 and being 50.
There are reasonable criticisms that identifying representative "equal" people over time is hard, but the author's solution seems dramatically worse than all of them.
The article is very poorly framed and argued.
You can still have regression to the mean among individuals while society itself is becoming horrifyingly unequal.
But doesn't this claim in itself refute the thesis that all the income gains are going to the top? If we find people at the bottom gaining income far faster than people at the top, which is what my quote claims, isn't that evidence that we live in a just society, not an unjust one?
Even just from the numbers presented imagine the lower percentile person who was making say 10k in constant dollars in the 80s. They're making 20k (100% increase) in same dollars in 2014.
Imagining the person in top was making 1,000,000 dollars in constant dollars they dropped 29% so they're now "only" making 750kish.
I know which group I'd rather be in.
> society itself is becoming horrifyingly unequal
Edit:
I was really hopeful for this Stanford resource, but I'm not even sure these "are facts that everyone should know".
> 10. Residential Segregation
tldr: Rich people and poor people don't live in the same areas.
> 13. Bad Jobs
tldr: Some people have bad jobs, and if you don't work full-time somewhere you're more likely to have a bad job.
This just seems like common sense. Was anyone surprised by this?
Certainly not horrified.
Horrifying: When you misplace a $20 bill and now you can't pay your rent.
It's really simple to understand.
Take an extreme example - out of a population of 1000 people you have 1 person owning 99% of the wealth, with the other 1% distributed to the other 999. Does that seem like an efficient, properly operating economy to you?
Obviously there is some balancing needs to happen, the trick is figuring out where the fulcrum should sit for the most efficiency.
Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity
Well this is an important part of his argument. The people's wages are not stagnant, but rather they went up an 30K (including inflation). That fact this their wages went up is not trivial.
By analogy, if you're trying to choose effective dietary policy, a study that shows people got taller over the past twenty years isn't helpful if you measure the same people. All it shows you is that children grow larger as they become adults.
I wouldn't take it for granted that the older you are the more you make.
Imagine this: at one high school, there's a 80% literacy rate in the 2008 class. Then it drops to a 60% rate for the 2018 class.
Even if the 2008 cohort may now have a 90% literacy rate, that doesn't change the fact that the school is declining in literacy, and trying to argue otherwise verges on duplicitous.
Here's bernie sanders talking about how open boarders is pushed by the koch brothers to give them cheap labor
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf-k6qOfXz0
We're rapidly heading towards feudalism 2.0. You can already see it in the Bay Area(and essentially any major urban area) where only the wealthy can afford a home. The majority pay a large chunk of their income to their landlord
Immigration is hardly the issue. Low-wage jobs exist because of the lack of labor protections for workers resulting in companies looking for the cheapest and most efficient labor they can, even if it means tapping desperate people who have no other options.
If you want to fix the problem, you start by increasing the minimum wage and having proper healthcare. Any other complaints about illegal immigration driving down wages is in my opinion deflection. Because if you remove illegal immigration, they'll just move to exploiting the next most vulnerable population (prison labor, people with disabilities etc)
You're making a claim in face of evidence. YOU back it up.
Choose an urban area at random... https://www.payscale.com/cost-of-living-calculator/Washingto... https://www.payscale.com/cost-of-living-calculator/New-York-...
etc - Go wild.
Also effectively telling people to just find the results themselves is not an argument either.
Saying you believe something in spite of the data, isn't how arguments work. You have the burden. I await your next deflection.
If it was actually about getting talent and not driving down wages we would be giving these people citizenship.
I think Roberts has a lot of interesting podcasts but he’s flat wrong on this one. I think Piketty, Saez, Zucman, Krugman, DeLong, Stiglitz, etc. are the people to read on wealth inequality and concentration.
Oh, and on that line- this recent series from TPM is great on wealth concentration and how it leads to uncertainty and unhappiness. https://talkingpointsmemo.com/feature/what-is-social-insuran...
And this older series from TPM on the same topic. (Brad DeLong)
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/features/marchtoinequality/four...
Hasn't the standard of living risen for the working class over the 30 years?
This is an absolute position, has it ever been better the case in the past?
When you actually follow the same people, the poor see the greater increase in income than the most wealthy. You may poo-poo a $30K inflation-adjusted increase in pay, but that moves someone from the lower class to the middle class.
Isn't that the goal?
It's akin to arguing that wage growth is looking at income of a person that was flipping burgers while in school 10 years ago now leads an engineering team.
It's not the same job, not the adequate comparison.
I presume you work in IT related field, so imagine you decided to take a break and be a parking lot attendant... You cannot then quote your own example as an instance of falling wages for IT workers.
And it doesn't matter if it's not the same job. The argument has always been about opportunity and the key point of this article is for people who start out in the lowest income quintile, the average wages doubles over time.
That's opportunity.
Except that wage growth debate isn't about opportunity. He's trying to argue about oranges, when the initial issue is about apples.
Arguments about wage growth are about costs, productivity and compensation.
As in - if you're 2x more productive at doing the same job, then the gains are deposited somewhere.
The argument in the end is that productivity gains are not distributed at a fair level. Equal isn't ever a requirement for a stable society, fair is enough.
And the folks tracked in this study were from 40 to retirement, so I don't see a change in career being a major driver for the income growth.
And even though the median income of the top 1% went from $189,000 to $843,000 in that sime timeframe, that's not important because in our sample, the average income of those in the top QUINTILE actually FELL $7k. Guess you couldn't find any 1%ers for your study?
Bottom line - if the economy can't support a living wage for the working class, it's not doing all that great.
[1] https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2000/1*Z5rBoco1CtNVHYZdh...