Re:Cracking the code
by mrcharles on Monday October 25, 2010 @01:49PM
(#1830778)
It seems to me that some of what WSJ shows here goes against RapLeaf's privacy policy.
Specifically:
"We don't collect or work with sensitive data on children, health or medical conditions, sexual preferences, financial account information, or religious beliefs."
The WSJ article shows that they are collecting religious beliefs, income, children, and detailed data on how you spend your money.
Seems to me that they are violating this both in spirit and in specific wording.
Re:Cracking the code
by jasonlotito on Monday October 25, 2010 @03:08PM
(#1831128)
Your confusing interest with actual data. For example, they don't collect religious beliefs. However, they can collect your interest in Christianity. They don't collect health information, but they can collect your interest in Healthy Eating. They don't collect financial account information, but they do collect general financial information (for example, they don't collect CC data, but do know your general pay grade.
Finally, they qualify everything by saying they don't collect sensitive data, and from the information provided, they don't.
Re:Cracking the code
by evgen on Monday October 25, 2010 @03:24PM
(#1831219)
Spliting semantic hairs it seems... Rapleaf is not collecting "interest" data just because they are curious; they are collecting it because the claim they make to their customers is that you interests define you and your intents better than explicitly stated preferences.
Re:Cracking the code
by joelhooks on Monday October 25, 2010 @03:46PM
(#1831307)
I don't believe in a God, but am interested in religion and how it affects the world I live in. I see a definite separation between interest and belief.
Re:Cracking the code
by mrcharles on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:06PM
(#1831387)
Sure but you are sticking your head in the sand if you think that that doesn't accurately represent the religious angle of people. If their data says they are interested in the bible, christianity, prayer groups, or whatever, what's more likely, that they are intellectually curious and just doing research? Or that they are just christian?
Re:Cracking the code
by jasonlotito on Monday October 25, 2010 @08:40PM
(#1832332)
That's like newspapers running articles saying so-and-so is charged with the rape of whats-her-name. Even if he's later found innocent, he still felt the repercussions. So, where do you draw the line?
More importantly: what's the problem with the data they are presenting? I see no problem ethically or legally, though I'm sure some might feel uncomfortable with the amount of information they've willingly, if unknowingly, shared.
Re:Cracking the code
by sportsTAKES on Monday October 25, 2010 @10:12PM
(#1832603)
I might be missing the point but I think the issue is that the WSJ (and others) are able to extract 'sensitive data' from sites like Rapleaf.
So that might be contrary to Rapleaf's policy but in reality their business model enables the dissemination of so-called sensitive data.
I read another blog post on Rapleaf's site about how they are solving the problem of personal information being moved around the internet mistakenly. Are they not simply devising a solution for a problem they are helping to create?
Re:Cracking the code
by nlco on Monday October 25, 2010 @07:39PM
(#1832142)
it appears they dont have anything on me (no cookie/javascript blocking, just vanilla chrome) and I do browse extensively. Anyone know why this might be happening?
Re:Cracking the code
by nohat on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:37PM
(#1831498)
At least RapLeaf is open enough to show this chart. You can edit your data, and opt out. Far from a perfect system, but let's be practical: nearly every other advertising system is doing exactly the same thing, just without telling you what they have. Some sort of an open advertising cookie seems like a good idea to me. Something that people can customise so that they'll see advertisements somewhat interesting to them.
Specifically: "We don't collect or work with sensitive data on children, health or medical conditions, sexual preferences, financial account information, or religious beliefs."
The WSJ article shows that they are collecting religious beliefs, income, children, and detailed data on how you spend your money.
Seems to me that they are violating this both in spirit and in specific wording.
Finally, they qualify everything by saying they don't collect sensitive data, and from the information provided, they don't.
More importantly: what's the problem with the data they are presenting? I see no problem ethically or legally, though I'm sure some might feel uncomfortable with the amount of information they've willingly, if unknowingly, shared.
So that might be contrary to Rapleaf's policy but in reality their business model enables the dissemination of so-called sensitive data.
I read another blog post on Rapleaf's site about how they are solving the problem of personal information being moved around the internet mistakenly. Are they not simply devising a solution for a problem they are helping to create?
Again, I might be missing the point...?
The chart does not reflect the currently used of attributes.
It's not like it's a secret or anything. They act like this chart is something they've discovered.
I'm amazed, but not necessarily surprised, that they could pin down my income level, location, age, etc. from just my email address.
Some interesting blog entries by rapleaf.com