Re:Blood money
by dawhizkid on Monday October 22, 2018 @11:15AM
(#18275299)
If you had an offer from Slack, would you seriously turn it down because they have Saudi money via Softbank if it was otherwise your top choice?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I’m in the late stages of the interview process for a heavily SoftBank-funded company that would otherwise be my top choice, and I’m strongly considering turning them down because of that. So if you want a definitive answer, ask me again in a week.
If you turn them down for that reason, will you state is as the reason? Otherwise, it doesn't seem nearly as effective.
I agree, and yes I would.
I'm not passing judgment but I think it depends on the market. If there was a recession and tech jobs were harder to find and at a lower rate, then people would take jobs with more questionable funding/mission. Part of the reason we are seeing more people mic drop is because they can walk away to something just as good.
This is why all effort needs to move toward automizing as much as we can, while passing on as much value as possible back to society - so then people don't have to work in order to have more than basic needs along with a high quality of life. This would give people time to educate themselves, to build relationship with others (community), among other things - and to support the people and mechanisms who provide and improve this function and quality of life.
Yes. These things matter.
I am all for standing up for your beliefs with your actions, I just hope we all realize this is a privileged position.
Re:Blood money
by realbarack on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:03PM
(#18275811)
Which is why these choices should be fairly simple, if you're confident of your own ethical stance. Most tech people's moral sacrifices are made for convenience/a few thousand dollars, not to put food on the table.
If you work for a high-status SV company and you have a lot of moral qualms, you should leave your job and find one you feel better about.
It's a modern disease to confuse integrity with privilege.
Sure, but the reason for that privilege is also the reason it matters so much. If you're considering whether to take a menial job in a warehouse or call center or something for a SoftBank-funded company, you're probably in a less privileged position in terms of your ability to turn down the best available job offer. But the ceiling on the value that you can create for those investors is much lower, which IMO significantly reduces the moral imperative to look elsewhere. Conversely, if you're an engineer for a SoftBank-funded startup, it's fairly likely that your contributions will create many millions of dollars' worth of wealth for Saudi investors.
If you are in a position to do so, then what does it matter? Given the ability to pick between two things that are identical bar some moral aspect, it seems logically consistent to pick the option that aligns more with your morals.
So if we do nothing we are bad people and if we do the right thing we are still not good people, because "privilege"?
That kinda trap sure doesn't make me more likely to give a shit about ethics.
Re:Blood money
by erikpukinskis on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:34PM
(#18277070)
Honestly, doing the right thing is pretty low on the list privileged people should be worrying about.
But yes, we should be careful passing judgement on people.
Care to elaborate?
Re:Blood money
by erikpukinskis on Saturday October 27, 2018 @03:14PM
(#18317242)
I mean, doing the right thing, and then worrying that you’re doing the right thing because you have privilege... not a thing I think people need to worry about.
If they’re judging others for not pitching in, that’s a concern.
No, of course not. I'd do what's best for me, my family, and my finances. As a conservative individual, there are BOATLOADS of mainstream organizations that make "moral choices" I don't agree with and I don't hesitate for a second to work for them or give them my all.
Re:Blood money
by erikpukinskis on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:15PM
(#18276929)
Yes. I've quit jobs over far less.
The thing that influences your values more than anything else is who you spend time in close proximity with.
If you spend all your time around people who look the other way when their compatriots do terrible things, you'll slowly bend that direction over time too.
The essence of Slack is to solve the problem “IRC is broken because my company doesn’t own it.” Slack’s only value prop is to its shareholders and no one should bother to use it.
Re:Blood money
by compcoffee on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:05PM
(#18275830)
>If you had an offer from Slack, would you seriously turn it down because they have Saudi money via Softbank if it was otherwise your top choice?
Of course not. The Valley runs on greed.
Re:Blood money
by justaguyhere on Monday October 22, 2018 @11:58AM
(#18275750)
How many of us even know (or take the time to find out) the investors of the companies we are interested in working for? And if we take a high moral stance, there wouldn't be many companies left - Amazon for its bad treatment of workforce, Google for privacy concerns, Facebook for its .. where do we even start, Oracle for its nastiness and so on.