News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by tlrobinson on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:11PM (#1827125)
This sounds familiar:

    "Ubercab threatens dispatchers’ way of earning a living"
Oh, yeah:

    "[TECHNOLOGY] threatens [PROFESSION]s' way of earning a living"
Not a valid argument.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by eli on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:21PM (#1827145)
Yeah, but neither is ignoring the law because you disagree with it.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by anigbrowl on Sunday October 24, 2010 @06:30PM (#1827530)
Not a lawyer, but after a quick look at the regulations as they currently stand, I don't think they are breaking the law. They are offering an alternative to taxi service, and the service they provide doesn't appear to require the kind of permits or satisfy the conditions the SFMTA sets. Of course, I'm guessing since I haven't seen a copy of the order, and there's no record of the administrative proceedings on the public website, apart from a question at a meeting of the Taxi commission in September about whether or not the service is legal.

In any case, you shouldn't assume they've 'ignored' regulations simply because an agency has declared them not to be in compliance. Regulations are often poorly drafted or subject to conflicting interpretations; the applicability of a given regulation can also change over time because of court decisions or changes in other legislation which. Administrative orders are subject to an appeals process and judicial review, and initial determinations about what is or is not legal often turn out to have been made in error; generally, orders that mandate or forbid a given activity are placed on hold during the appeals process. It's unfair to respond as if they had simply thumbed their noses at the law just because proceedings have been initiated.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by ataggart on Sunday October 24, 2010 @11:36PM (#1828402)
"One has not only a legal but a moral responsibility to obey just laws. Conversely, one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws. I would agree with St. Augustine that 'an unjust law is no law at all'."

Using threats of violence against otherwise peaceful adults for engaging in consensual acts -- acts which do not violate the rights of others -- is unjust.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by AngryParsley on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:42PM (#1827215)
I think "ignoring the law because you disagree with it" is called civil disobedience. Although the term usually means individuals breaking laws for moral reasons, not companies doing it for efficiency and profit.

Edit: I just wanted to point out that it is sometimes valid to ignore a law because you disagree with it. I'm not saying Ubercab is in the right.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by gloob on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:53PM (#1827245)
Perhaps I'm just old-fashioned, but the argument "Companies have the right to ignore the law if doing so increases profits" seems rather...unconventional.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by AngryParsley on Sunday October 24, 2010 @06:06PM (#1827454)
That is twisting my words beyond even the most uncharitable reading.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by gloob on Sunday October 24, 2010 @06:09PM (#1827460)
The charitable reading of your words, if I didn't misunderstand, is "many people think that people are sometimes justified in ignoring the law, depending on the situation." That's more or less a truism.

Edit: Upvoted you back to 1.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by potatolicious on Sunday October 24, 2010 @07:35PM (#1827701)
I don't think anyone is arguing that - the argument I see is whether or not it is justified to flout the law if the law is unjust, and the flouting thereof is to the benefit of the public.

Which is to say in this case, more convenient, cheaper, easier and more payment options, etc etc.

Assuming that Ubercab's claims of requiring equivalent licensing and insurance from their drivers is true, it seems like the only complaint here is that they're taking business from traditional cab businesses; my only response to this would be "well, tough".

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by qq66 on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:53PM (#1827248)
If Ubercab is civil disobedience, taxi drivers can drive without licenses and claim that they are participating in civil disobedience. The medallion cost is a huge component of the cost of a taxi (a NYC medallion is worth over $300K) so this is a big fairness-of-competition issue which needs to be addressed.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by uvdiv on Sunday October 24, 2010 @05:21PM (#1827333)
>(a NYC medallion is worth over $300K)

$607,000 for individuals, $825,000 for corporate owners.

http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-08-06/nyc-taxi-medalli...

>a big fairness-of-competition issue which needs to be addressed.

I think it's transparently obvious that the sole purpose of these regulations is to prevent fairness of competition, to enforce an artificial scarcity that inflates the revenue of cartel members.

>If Ubercab is civil disobedience, taxi drivers can drive without licenses and claim that they are participating in civil disobedience.

Dare I ask, why not?

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by _delirium on Sunday October 24, 2010 @05:59PM (#1827440)
> Dare I ask, why not?

If you'd like to try this out, you can approach one of the many unlicensed civil-disobedience taxis that hang out around NYC airports, instead of going with a licensed one. The quality and honesty of service is quite spotty though.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by uvdiv on Sunday October 24, 2010 @07:11PM (#1827643)
To be pedantic, it's not civil disobedience if it's not openly defiant. It's one thing to evade a law, another to defy a law with publicity and challenge the government to prosecute you. Or as Wikipedia defines it: "Civil disobedience is the active, professed refusal to obey certain laws..."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_disobedience

Evading a law is a selfish act; civil disobedience is going to jail out of principle, which is selfless.

Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by eli on Sunday October 24, 2010 @04:48PM (#1827230)
And they people who do it usually plan to be arrested. Not sure that makes for a great business plan, but I'd be happy to be proven wrong.