News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UberCab Ordered to Cease And Desist by anigbrowl on Sunday October 24, 2010 @06:30PM (#1827530)
Not a lawyer, but after a quick look at the regulations as they currently stand, I don't think they are breaking the law. They are offering an alternative to taxi service, and the service they provide doesn't appear to require the kind of permits or satisfy the conditions the SFMTA sets. Of course, I'm guessing since I haven't seen a copy of the order, and there's no record of the administrative proceedings on the public website, apart from a question at a meeting of the Taxi commission in September about whether or not the service is legal.

In any case, you shouldn't assume they've 'ignored' regulations simply because an agency has declared them not to be in compliance. Regulations are often poorly drafted or subject to conflicting interpretations; the applicability of a given regulation can also change over time because of court decisions or changes in other legislation which. Administrative orders are subject to an appeals process and judicial review, and initial determinations about what is or is not legal often turn out to have been made in error; generally, orders that mandate or forbid a given activity are placed on hold during the appeals process. It's unfair to respond as if they had simply thumbed their noses at the law just because proceedings have been initiated.

There are no comments on this comment yet.