Where is the statistical evidence that Ubercab and AirBnB are actually less safe than the alternative? Moreover, we let people choose to use motorbikes OR cars; why should the "less safe" alternative always be illegal? Sometimes other attributes (convenience, speed, price) mean that you'll settle for three rather than four nines in safety.
I think it's a bit premature to ask for this kind of statistical evidence no? Are these companies old enough to have any useful, relevant statistics?
If only that were true. Taxi drivers are among the most reckless drivers in my city, and pretty well every other major city in North America that I've visited. If there is any training, it is not taken too seriously.
BUT: The only good thing about taxis in London is that they need to pass a test called The Knowledge (refs below) which means they are able to figure out the best route to anywhere in London on the fly. And if you think this is easy, it's not: the structure of the brains of taxi drivers is actually bigger in the part responsible for spacial memory, the discovery of which led the researchers winning the Ig Nobel prize.
Refs:
http://www.tfl.gov.uk/businessandpartners/taxisandprivatehir...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom#...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/677048.stm
Instead of using a 200$ GPS, they are required to spend a long time studying a body of knowledge superseded by technology.
And this translates to higher costs for the casual cab-rider.
There's a marked difference in quality of service between minicab drivers who use GPS units and black cab drivers who don't need them. They both exist in London, and given the choice, I'll go with a black cab every time.
Then there's the social aspect: by being more strict and maintaining an image of quality, you can attract better, nicer drivers.
The other points just shows that GPS have a bit to go yet, and they are going there. There are quite a lot of GPS solutions who get real-time traffic updates, construction, etc (look at waze.com)
The second point is true, wonder if there is a better way to solve it tho
And frankly, given how rubbish a lot of those devices are, a human's intimate knowledge of the side roads is a very good thing; for example when you hit unexpected traffic and the device's service hasn't updated yet and you're in a hurry.
HNers who are into Sci-Fi ought to check out Will Self's "The Book of Dave", which is funny, brilliant, and (in large part) about a future post-apocalyptic society which makes a religion of "The Knowledge."
http://everything2.com/title/Mutant+brains+of+London+cabbies
I'm not sure if per minute/mile pricing is necessary or just a creature of regulation. I certainly don't encounter it any other time I travel with someone else driving. It certainly ruins the cab experience for me. Can't they properly estimate time and distance now with the mapping and traffic apps we have today?
But hell, I've stayed in shitty motels where the only thing keeping the carpets glued to the floor was the roach shit.
I'm not a poweruser of the system, but it seems like it's fairly easy to figure out what's legit and what's not - look at reviews and photos.
I guess I don't really know what I would do if I arrived and the place was completely not as advertised. Probably hop on my iPhone, figure out who to call at AirBNB, and see about getting my money refunded and their account shut down.
The review system does weed out some of them. If you look for rooms in NYC, there's a lot with negative reviews along the lines of, "thought this was a spare room, but turned out to be a hostel". I don't have much confidence that the reviews have caught all of them, though.
And it seems that all it would take is one negative review. If I see a "bait and switch" type of commentary, I'll avoid that place for sure.
I suppose people could game this - mutually book each other's place, eat AirBNB's take as cost of business, and just vote each other up.
The best argument I've heard is the liability issue. Americans are sue-happy. One slip in the shower or bad car accident and then what?
Are AirBnB and UberCab totally immune from litigation?
Among all the posturing essentially meant to protect their existing businesses, I do think they have one valid point - that they both skirt around laws and regs in place. Though a lot of these laws and regulations are outdated/driven by special interests, some of them are in place for a reason. For example, not having hotels in residential areas so that neighbors aren't disturbed. Or having safety training for drivers of cabs.
I do worry about the risk that UberCab/AirBnb could cause to its users (or others indirectly impacted).
In both cases, the existing industries aren't doing themselves any favors. The argument around existing dispatchers maybe not making a living anymore - if someone else provides a better service than I do, it isn't their fault if I can't make money anymore. Reading the comments on the cab drivers' blog [1] is a bit sad. One of the commenters recognizes how good Ubercab is but uses that as an argument on why they should be shut down, instead of going "Hey, what if we started doing some of the things they do and improve?"
http://phantomcabdriverphites.blogspot.com/2010/09/tac-iii-p...