Taxi service in SF is truly horrible and is ripe for disruption. I hope these guys win. Go UberCab!
While you may technically be right, it may not matter in your PR battle.
As to the logic of "we are not a taxi service, we just make money putting customers into taxis", I really can't comment on how the law views this.
If the SF Metro Transit Authority withdraws the cease and desist order then please accept my apologies for making bad assumptions, but given the law enforcers say what you are doing is not allowed, I can only assume that it is, indeed, not allowed, regardless of how you word what exactly you do.
Either way, I hope you get it resolved (whether that means them backing down, or you agreeing to whatever they're wanting of you), other than this current situation your service looks pretty great, and I'm sure I'll use you some day when I'm on your side of the pond.
The law enforcers so often wrong about what the law does and does not allow that somebody had the foresight leave that judgement up to another branch of government entirely.
I'm sorry but you're arguing that SF MTA is infallible and you are wrong.
Maybe I should have been more specific before: I'll also apologise if the MTA don't withdraw, but are instead shown to be in the wrong.
It's hard to read that and think of you as anything other than a liar (or perhaps an obnoxious pedant).
That's truly meant as constructive feedback.
edit: seriously. I figured it'd be better somebody tell him that on HN before he says it to a media personality without thinking of how it will be perceived by some.
"The cab stand in your hand". Tags of "taxi", "cab" and "taxi stand". A name that includes the word "cab".
They're clearly positioning themselves as a taxi company, then saying "oh, but we are not a taxi company!" when called on it. The whole thing reminds me of Napster when they tried to claim they had nothing to do with all the pirated music available via Napster.
Other apps, like taximagic, avoid the trouble by simply dispatching a taxi instead of playing this limo / taxi licensing game.
I find it fairly offensive that they're trying to complain that they're just too innovative, when the reality is that they entered a heavily regulated market and made a conscious decision to ignore the regulation. Too bad, so sad, deal with it.
Mobile taxi hailing is obviously coming, but I'd back the horse that is smart enough not to piss off the taxi and limousine commissions in the launch city. That seems like an action that's likely to get them extra governmental attention in every new market they address.
You could argue that then they are fooling the public, and I'd certainly give you that point, by saying this is a cab service. I understand the reasons for it though, people are used to the idea that limo service is for the rich and famous, when it's not much more expensive in contrast to a cab.
So now how exactly does Taximagic avoid anything by dispatching a taxi? I'll tell you how, by sharing profit with established taxi companies. Both Taximagic and Ubercab do the exact same thing, the difference is Ubercab simply does not want to use taxi companies, and instead use limo services exclusively, not breaking any regulations by doing so.
You know what I find offensive? That the medallion industry is going after Ubercab because they want to get a piece of the pie. It's a perfect way to show the world that this is really a mob in all its glory. It's in a slightly twisted way no different than a mobster sending a payment collector to every store in the neighborhood to get protection money or drive them out of business if they don't pay up. If Ubercab doesn't win this, it's an example of how rottenly corrupt the system is.
PD: Napster and music piracy is no way similar to Ubercab and taxicabs. Pirated music did pass through Napster, but I see no taxi cabs being used by Ubercab.
And while they're cheaper than black cabs, they're more expensive than minicabs (for non-londoners: Black Cabs can be hailed off the street, minicabs you have to call) which is a closer comparison.
What UberCab seem to be doing (I may be wrong as I've never used their service) is aggregating drivers from multiple limo services into an on-demand system. It seems that in SF that limo services have to be pre-booked an hour in advanced, which suggests that UberCab would firstly have to get a taxi service licence and secondly get all of their limo drivers licensed and insured as taxi drivers (as opposed to limo drivers). I imagine the later is the bigger problem than the first.
Actually, did you notice the finesse in the (unattributed but blockquoted) objections TC provides from the 'incumbent taxi industry'? They say, "Limos in U.S. cities usually have to prebook an hour in advance". They don't say "SF requires limos to prebook an hour in advance". Maybe SF hasn't quite locked-out competition as strictly as elsewhere -- perhaps even by mistake. (Industries protected by political favors can get lazy and sloppy, though they're nasty when awoken.)
That argument sounds semi-reasonable when coming from a teenager downloading films illegaly, not from a serious company avoiding paying for a license it needs.
No, it's the law that is wrong. It is corrupt, it is repressive, it is evil.
First of all, you can't just "pay for a license" to operate a taxi in S.F., because competition is illegal. The industry is a closed, city-enforced cartel, and the taxi "licenses" -- "medallions" -- first of all, have a mandatory cap of 1,400 taxis, secondly, are "allocated to individual drivers on the basis of seniority on a waiting list":
http://www.sfbg.com/politics/2010/02/24/feb-26-cab-industry-...
Your standard labor cartel.
Even better. They are piloting a program to "liberalize" the "licensing" (that SFBG news story), which mean under certain conditions you can actually "pay for a license" -- at a cost of $250,000 apiece. Although, naturally, the government quotas are still in effect, and you have to be a S.F. taxi union member to begin with, and who gets to buy the licenses is in order of seniority, etc., etc.:
>Under the pilot program, only certain medallions can be sold: those held by individuals 70 years old or older or who are permanently disabled and cannot fulfill the driving requirement. While no medallion holder is required to sell, only those who elect to participate in the pilot program have the option to sell at this time. The other set of medallions being sold are those in the possession of the SFMTA due to the death of a medallion holder or through revocation proceedings. The price for a medallion is $250,000.
>The medallion buyers are subject to the same rules as other current medallion holders, such as the full-time driving requirement and driving a San Francisco taxi for at least four of the past five years. Under the pilot program, available medallions are offered to qualified buyers in the order of seniority on the waiting list and after that in order of the driver A-Card permit seniority. The decision to buy is voluntary, but interested buyers had to notify the SFMTA of their interest in participating in the pilot.
http://www.sfmta.com/cms/apress/SFMTAAnnouncesFirstTaxiMedal...
More about S.F. taxi licenses, from the cartel's own webpage:
http://www.medallionholders.com/medallions.html
Many other union-infected city governments do the same thing. NYC stands out: its taxi "licenses" now cost $825,000 each:
http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-08-06/nyc-taxi-medalli...
Disclaimer: IANAL, all I know is what I read in news articles.
There's a taxi company I use whenever I'm in London called Addison Lee, and they've done the same as UberCab - using nice technology to know where you are, where the nearest available cars are, how long it will take for a car to get to you... In actual fact, at least based on http://www.ubercab.com/learn, AdLee is better: it has all the benefits of UberCab, plus they tell you the price of the journey before you book the car (it won't become more expensive if you get stuck in traffic, or if the driver takes a longer route), which always works out cheaper than a black cab, in my experience. Oh, and in adition to letting you pay with the credit card on your account, you can chose to pay by cash if you so wish.
Anyway, my point? Seems that Addison Lee have been (albeit in a different city/country) doing what UberCab is doing, slightly better, and for quite a bit longer: and they actually bothered to pay to be a licensed taxi provider, meaning that the London officials don't have a problem with them.