News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by chicken_littl2 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @04:59PM (#18270216)
Completely glosses over the fact that whatever subsidiary they run their life insurance and annuities out of is going to have to hold a statutory reserve for liabilities like this that would fall under their "assets under management". It also glosses over the fact that they are state regulated by all states they run business out of, not just NJ. I'm sure they issue policies in NY, the NY insurance commissioner typically will oversee their valuation methods for stat reserves to make sure they meet industry standards. I would be very surprised if they took a loss on their life line of business that puts them out of business, statutory reserves are a very conservative valuation method, where you use NAIC prescribed mortality tables, so there's no fudging around the numbers very much.

Long story short, this is really sensationalist back of napkin math from a reporter talking about a very regulated and complicated industry that they seem to know nothing about. No wonder is such garbage.

Edit: Upon further reflection, this doesn't even cover reinsurance that they might have that cover abnormal losses across individual, blocks of business, and across the entire company.

Even in the event they didn't have the capital to pay off their life insurance liabilities due to loss, they would probably liquidate their inforce blocks of business by auctioning them off to other insurance companies to cover their remaining losses.

There's just so much ignorance and sensationalism here, it's hard to comprehend.

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by jshaqaw on Sunday October 21, 2018 @07:42PM (#18271027)
It is hard to believe that an adverse mortality shock big enough to rock Pru could be absorbed by reinsurance capital. The story is a bit sensational but as an investor in both banks and insurance companies it is stark how regulated (post 08) banks are and how little serious regulation there is on the insurance side. A lot of it is how state level insurance is regulated which allows states to shop themselves (ie race to the bottom) as the loosest regulator.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by sfifs on Sunday October 21, 2018 @08:44PM (#18271289)
> It is hard to believe that an adverse mortality shock big enough to rock Pru could be absorbed by reinsurance capital.

If you have an adverse mortality rate problem big enough to shake a highly regulated industry like life insurance (there's no reason to believe mortality would be selective by insurance company), you probably have far bigger problems in your country than insurance - war, mega natural disaster, mega epidemic and the like.

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by paganel on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:51AM (#18272664)
> war, mega natural disaster, mega epidemic and the like.

It's mentioned in the article, but AIG's fall in October 2008 was as dangerous and big as Lehman's, and afaik none of the conditions mentioned in your comment were in place.

Like the OP says, there have been regulations put in place to try to avoid a similar thing happening in the banking sector but the same thing hasn't happened with the big insurance companies in a consistent manner. Again, afaik the US putting some big insurance companies on this "too big to fail" list was the only such measure taken to avoid a new AIG, but with them now being off the list I see no such strong checks in place. And this should be done at the federal level, you can't expect state legislations (even if applied in the majority of the states) to put a check on an entity that has ~USD 1.4 trillion under quite active management.

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by sfifs on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @04:29AM (#18281717)
AIG's collapse had nothing to do with life insurance. It was driven by a division called AIG Financial Products which wrote the infamous credit default swaps together with equity based lending. Arguably it reinforces the learning that integrated financial giants shouldn't be allowed

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/american-...

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by paganel on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @04:00AM (#18290477)
I know it had nothing to do with life insurance and I also think that the article is wrong when focusing on that part of the business, but it is correct when saying that a company like Prudential should have remained on that too-big-to-fail list. When you’re handling ~USD 1.4 trillion you are at the center of the financial system.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by Retric on Sunday October 21, 2018 @09:43PM (#18271551)
This assumes the companies are all equally competent. It’s easy for a company to misprice a segment and then gain over exposure as they are the cheapest option for that segment.

On it’s own that’s not a big deal, but if something like a slightly unusual seasonal flu happens to hit that segment unusually hard and suddenly they have a huge liability.

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by nradov on Sunday October 21, 2018 @11:29PM (#18271994)
Most life insurance policies have exceptions for war.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by TuringNYC on Sunday October 21, 2018 @08:00PM (#18271127)
>> It also glosses over the fact that they are state regulated by all states they run business out of, not just NJ. I'm sure they issue policies in NY, the NY insurance commissioner typically will oversee their valuation methods for stat reserves to make sure they meet industry standards. I would be very surprised if they took a loss on their life line of business that puts them out of business

Honest question -- has this changed since 2008? If not, how is this different from AIG in 2008? Because putting aside AIG's sensational Credit Default Swap issues, the bigger story was AIG Investments' Securities Lending fiasco where huge portions of the reserves were lent out (short term) and the funds were used to buy illiquid mortgage backed securities which went down in value precipitously. https://www.americanbanker.com/opinion/aigs-collapse-the-par...

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by sagichmal on Sunday October 21, 2018 @08:48PM (#18271319)
Felix Salmon unquestionably knows what he's talking about.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by gimmeThaBeet on Monday October 22, 2018 @01:33AM (#18272416)
I'm not going to make a snap judgment based on one article but his last line:

>Prudential could be forced to start liquidating its assets at fire-sale prices, which could set off a chain reaction in the rest of the financial markets and even the economy as a whole.

Makes me question that. He gets through all of his scenario without once mentioning the Orderly Liquidation Authority, which despite the Dodd-Frank rollback is still in the toolbox, and is this is basically exactly what it was made for. So to be blunt, imo best case he's made a critical error of omission, unintentional or otherwise.

And this is not to say it's a sure thing. It's the government. It would be far from perfect, it would be far from clean, but most everyone involved is on the same page in terms of what we don't want happening, which is more than I can say about most things.

Of all the things that the crisis taught us and we have in fact learned from, is that failure of a large financial institution is terrible; an uncontrolled liquidation of a failed financial institution is way worse.

Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by CPLX on Sunday October 21, 2018 @10:22PM (#18271697)
This comment should be higher. Felix is arguably the most respected and level headed financial reporter in the country.
Re:The Looming Danger of Non-Banks by johnwyles on Sunday October 21, 2018 @11:50PM (#18272056)
I clicked to the comments to find this very explanation. Albeit I know next to zero of the industry or complicated financial structures surrounding the topic that even I as a layman felt it grossly sensationalist.