News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:18AM (#18255016)
I have a hard time imagining how somebody could be opposed to this and pretend they have anything but selfish motivations.

Emissions kill people. They kill the elderly. They kill people with asthma. They give people cancer. Your car is an instrument of death even if you don't hit anyone. Parts of the UK have appallingly bad air quality (by regional standards; obviously it's not Beijing).

People are dying en masse but because you can't see it and say "my car was the one that killed them" most people just. don't. care.

Also the majority of trips are short enough to be done via bike or ebike if you give people safe routes to do so, something the UK has been completely unwilling to do.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:53AM (#18255209)
Aside from emissions, if you drive a car you are making public spaces more dangerous even of you follow the rules perfectly. Our cities and public spaces are extremely hostile to pedestrians especially kids. Its drilled in to everyone that you have to have a constant grip of your child's hand when walking outside because they could be instantly killed for stepping in the wrong spot at the wrong time.

It also takes forever to walk anywhere because pedestrian crossings are programmed to be extremely slow as to not disrupt drivers as well as intersections often requiring 2 crossings to get to the desired location vs just one when driving.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by KozmoNau7 on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:06AM (#18255770)
The sheer amount of space that was forcefully taken from pedestrians and cyclists, in order to make room for cars is absolutely astounding once you take a critical look at it.

Those 4-lane boulevards though city centers could fit generously-proportioned sidewalks and bike paths and greenery, food stalls, cafés and dedicated bus lanes (or you could move public transit underground for better space utilization).

Instead they're full of gridlocked traffic, made up of countless ~1.5t lumps of steel and plastic, transporting a single occupant each.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:43AM (#18256638)
When people complain about cyclists on footpaths, I agree wholeheartedly. Yet, when I point out that drivers did EXACTLY this and killed everyone in their way, it's like I'm speaking Martian. Streets are for people. At least they were for all of human history until ~100 years ago.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ddorian43 on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:20AM (#18255033)
You fix things by working from the top of highest offenders. Something tells me it's not the average people.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:49AM (#18255452)
Indeed - so focusing on large companies selling devices causing massive destruction makes perfect sense.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by mtgx on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:41AM (#18255130)
Fixing the climate change problem should have always involved systemic solutions - i.e. bans on diesel vehicles, high carbon prices, etc, not stuff like "use less water in your home."

But since most governments are corrupt/can get paid by those rich companies they are trying to regulate, the former has also been the most difficult to implement.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by KozmoNau7 on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:01AM (#18255748)
Oil companies are the biggest polluters and contributors to climate change. By severely reducing the amount of fossil fuel vehicles on the roads, we lessen the demand for fossil fuels, and reduce pollution.

Big cargo ships should also be targeted, they burn significantly worse grades of fuel, and pollute a lot more.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:58AM (#18255244)
As a population car users represent a massive amount of emmisions. Removing that would be one of the highest offenders.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by jfk13 on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:00AM (#18255256)
> Also the majority of trips are short enough to be done via bike or ebike if you give people safe routes to do so, something the UK has been completely unwilling to do.

Just because a trip is short enough doesn't necessarily mean it's actually practical to make via (e)bike. People often need to take more than a backpack's- or pannier's-worth of stuff with them.

I love my bike, and use it when appropriate, but it doesn't come close to replacing a car.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:39AM (#18255660)
Often? I'm a developer like most people here and I have to carry less than a backpacks worth on almost all of my trips. On the times I do need to carry more it could fit on one of those bike trailers I see around.

Of course if you are are a tradie or something and you need to carry around ladders and pipes than a bike isn't ideal but for almost everyone it is for almost all of our trips.

Taking a car to work for most of us is using a sledge hammer to push in a thumb tack.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by jfk13 on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:54AM (#18255720)
I wasn't thinking in terms of a developer getting to the office. Personally, I don't think I've driven my car to work for at least the past ten years. Many days it doesn't leave the driveway. But there aren't adequate alternatives that would allow me to get rid of it altogether.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:44AM (#18256650)
Which is why that seems like a strawman. The article is not proposing banning all automobiles. Just ICE ones.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:53AM (#18255469)
Which is about as relevant as saying "sometimes I have to cross a river so a car doesn't come close to replacing a boat". This strawman argument is trotted out every time someone suggests an alternative to cars for normal getting around.

I'm not suggesting a human-powered piano delivery service. I'm not proposing we replace logging trucks with cargo bikes.

I am saying that a large number of trips can be taken by modes other than car when doing so becomes a safe and pleasant option. We have proven examples of this (DK, NL) and they are really nice places to walk, cycle, and perhaps paradoxically, drive, as a result.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by knorker on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:09AM (#18255292)
Yeah, so since it'd only get us 99.99% of the way there let's not do it. :-P
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by lixtra on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:06AM (#18255526)
The very computer you are typing on and throw away in a few years poisoned people in its production and operation.

We are all alive for selfish reasons and compete for resources with others, including clean air.

An absolute standpoint does not help. We have to aim to improve and optimize.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by Symbiote on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:21AM (#18255582)
These MPs have made their proposal for a way to improve and optimize: use zero-emissions cars instead of petrol/diesel.

CalRobert has made their proposal: the same, but also reduce the number of car trips by improving cycling infrastructure.

Neither proposal is absolute, though they exist: ban all [private] cars [from cities].

What's yours?

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by lixtra on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:29AM (#18255604)
>> People are dying en masse but because you can't see it and say "my car was the one that killed them" most people just. don't. care.

People are dying en masse, because people read forums like HN. His argument is poor.

Wheter building cycling lanes is a net improvement can be discussed. It will depend on the details.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by KozmoNau7 on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:12AM (#18255800)
>"The very computer you are typing on and throw away in a few years poisoned people in its production and operation."

Which is why we must Reduce, Reuse, Recycle.

My main PC is from 2011, still going strong with only minor upgrades (RAM, SSD, new GPU). My laptop is of a similar age. I don't foresee replacing either anytime soon.

We need to stop the ridiculous gadget race.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by skocznymroczny on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:41AM (#18255131)
Not everyone can afford electric cars.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by incangold on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:57AM (#18255235)
It doesn’t matter. Literally nobody can afford climate failure.

Once you’ve got a realistic threat of civilisational collapse on one side of the equation, things look different. Not everyone being able to afford a car, or having to eat veggie burgers... These aren’t real problems in comparison.

Quite apart from the fact that we shouldn’t all need cars in the first place. I live in Europe, with kids, and I’ve never felt the need to even get a license. Trains are far more convenient.

Cars being a luxury means public transport will need to improve everywhere. Which is great for everyone, and for the economy.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by roenxi on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:33AM (#18255402)
> It doesn’t matter. Literally nobody can afford climate failure.

That is a sweeping overgeneralisation and literally false. There are going to be large communities of people who will suffer more from giving up cars than from climate change.

Maybe you don't have an poor people living in your part of the world, but wishing a peasant lifestyle on the poor because you don't want to engage with their problems is neither constructive nor pleasant.

What people can afford does matter, and it is worth considering how much the poor are being asked to give up versus how much we expect their sacrifice to help.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by incangold on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:26AM (#18255594)
It’s fair to point out that I was being hyperbolic.

Depending on exactly where we fall in the range of bad to catastrophic possible futures ahead of us, it may be hard to find too many people who would be more affected by giving up cars than climate change.

I am clearly not wishing a peasant lifestyle on the poor, that is a straw man. I am wishing working public transport on everyone.

Your final paragraph I absolutely agree with. I over-egged my comment for effect. The general lack of alarm and urgency surrounding climate change is frustrating.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by calv on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:55AM (#18255218)
Those people are likely the people who can't afford a new car too "A ban on sales of NEW petrol and diesel cars" is literally written in the article.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:46AM (#18255158)
Anyone who can afford a car can afford a bike/ebike or a public transport ticket. Electric cars are not a solution to our problems.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by makomk on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:53AM (#18255205)
As it currently stands, being forced to rely on public transport takes years off people's lives - not in one clear-cut chunk, but in hours stolen here and there.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by Symbiote on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:26AM (#18255595)
Living in a town or city takes years of people's lives, both gradually as an effect of air pollution, or suddenly through a collision.

Public transport causes far less of both problems, and where problems remain (e.g. a town with old buses) they are much more easily solved (buy 200 electric buses).

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by maccard on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:11AM (#18255303)
I've definitely spent more time sitting in traffic (as a very infrequent driver) than I have waiting on public transport in my life. Try driving across london vs getting the tube.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by makomk on Friday October 19, 2018 @12:56PM (#18258070)
London is the one place in the UK where public transport isn't terrible. It's also the place where the MPs who're proposing this live most of the time, which may explain a lot. Unfortunately, it's also overcrowded and too expensive for almost everyone.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by maccard on Sunday October 21, 2018 @06:19PM (#18270685)
Apologies I missed this a few days ago. Transport in Glasgow is also far more efficient than driving. Similarly Birmingham, hull, Manchester are all much easier handled by their transport systems.

If you live outside the cities though, you better own a car.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:54AM (#18255215)
That time spent on public transport can be used to get work done vs sitting in a car doing nothing else. Also having a decent public transport system is much much faster than sitting in traffic for hours. The american audience has probably never experienced a good public transport system so they assume its just slow by design.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by steve_taylor on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:02AM (#18255269)
Trains always seem to lack the capacity for people to sit down during typical commuting hours. Even when you can get a seat, there’s no space to use your laptop because people occupy the space where your elbows need to be.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:43AM (#18255677)
So the train you use is bad that means trains in general are bad? The solution is to put more resources in to the public transport system.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by incangold on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:08AM (#18255533)
As it currently stands, the trajectory of our carbon footprint will take years off people’s lives- in one clear-cut chunk.

Besides which, cars aren’t faster than trains.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:54AM (#18255472)
Can you elaborate?
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:39AM (#18255124)
I don't like the idea of the government banning stuff.

I'm a lifelong cyclist, ex-bike courier. Cars don't offend me. Bad drivers do. I always loved the freedom of cycling. The lack of regulation and traffic stops is one of my favorite points. Never enjoyed 'cycling routes' or special bike lanes. They always seem to box me in. I feel less safe in these areas.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:57AM (#18255486)
So don't use them. They're not mandatory and the open road remains yours for the taking, aside from motorways.

But just as not all people are track runners, not all people are ex-bike-couriers, and it would be nice if they could ride a bike in something other than abject terror.

Also, I actually don't favour a total ban for the most part, just pricing in the externalities. Which would make petrol and diesel powered cars astonishingly expensive. Removing a liter's worth of CO2 from the air would have to be priced in to the cost of a liter of fuel. Paying for your dead neighbour's funeral would need to be covered too (though insurance is meant to cover this, drivers who kill people walking or cycling are rarely found at fault, because it's legal to kill people with your car if they're in the street). Meanwhile, you'd still let the odd hot rod or classic car enthusiast have a project car to wrench on during the weekends, and honestly, I think that's great. They're a key part of our cultural history and great fun.

But right now we still pay for all of those things! We just make _everyone else_ pay for them, which is very unfair. My taxes pay for the street where people drive too quickly to stop before killing my child if she slips from the pavement, and where they emit pollution that has rendered her less intelligent than she might be otherwise, though it's impossible to say by how much.

I don't even own a car. So that seems unjust.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @10:06PM (#18261311)
We might have some common ground here. I don't drive and I don't want to pay for it either.

For me the bigger negative externality is in foreign policy. I don't want any part of overseas adventures for oil. The financial costs alone are astronomical.

At the same time, I do benefit from transportation infrastructure in terms of shipping and purchasing goods which are transported. But if it were my decision I'd say just privatize the whole thing.

If a private road pollutes or otherwise harms anyone, then they should be liable. Problem solved. Lawyers have every incentive to claim damages.

About the abject terror, just build your way up. You can do it. Once you try it you'll see that it truly is as easy as riding a bike.

Back to your main point - it is not selfish to not want to ban petrol/diesel vehicles. I am ready to share the road with anyone.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:57AM (#18267115)
I am a confident cyclist. I used to commute 4400 mi per year from Santa Monica to Marina Del Rey via Lincoln blvd on a recumbent, if that tells you anything. Check out street view - it's hell for the most part.

But most people are not me, and we definitely don't demand new drivers live in utter terror until they get numb to it.

Nevermind survival bias. Dead ex-bike-couriers aren't here to give their view.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by Heliosmaster on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:42AM (#18255135)
The government is banning stuff all the time. You are not allowed to do a plethora of things that harm other people or society (stealing? murder? destroying public property?). A ban on petrol/diesel car is nothing special.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by ndnxhs on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:45AM (#18255150)
Its more of a revocation of the privilege to use destructive vehicles on public land. I'm sure after the ban your cars will still be legal to use on private property.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:50AM (#18255190)
Controlling violence is one of the primary justifications for government. You're comparing apples and oranges - Violent acts and prohibition of inanimate objects don't fit in the same scope.

Prohibition of alcohol would be a more apt comparison.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by knorker on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:11AM (#18255306)
You are not allowed to possess a knife in public (without good reason), nor are you allowed to own guns.

Cars physically hurt people even when they aren't hitting people.

I think your rule about possession being different from action doesn't hold water at all.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:19AM (#18255347)
Books are also inanimate and have been banned throughout history. Cannabis is another interesting one. Lots of data and settled science about how terrible it was... Lately western nations have been walking that one back.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by knorker on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:51PM (#18260665)
You are comparing books and the right to poison the air, not paying for the HUGE externalities it causes?

If you're an ultra-libertarian I think you need to get your externality philosophy straightened out first in your model of utopia.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Monday October 22, 2018 @05:32AM (#18273291)
As opposed to a centrally planned model of utopia?
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by knorker on Thursday October 25, 2018 @01:45PM (#18302826)
Sorry, I didn't realise I was standing next to a straw man who you must have mistaken me for.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by viraptor on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:51AM (#18255194)
Bike lanes are what cities make them. A lane in Amsterdam is not the same as a lane... pretty much anywhere else I've seen.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:13AM (#18255317)
Competence builds confidence.

Seems like most of the safety complainers don't want to cycle and are looking for excuses.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by CalRobert on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:56AM (#18255480)
There is no way in hell I would let my kid cycle on the vast majority of "cycle lanes", and suggesting that I should let her wobble around until she builds competence or dies is ridiculous.

Vehicular cycling has set back actual progress in safe infrastructure by decades and is woefully ill-informed about the needs of anyone other than fit, adult, experienced cyclists with excellent vision, hearing, and reflexes.

If you wouldn't let your 8 or 80 year old relative use it, it's crap bike infrastructure.

Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by provolone on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:09AM (#18255537)
Seems like we went everywhere from age 8 via bicycle. No supervision, just be back for dinner. Worked out fine and there were no designated bicycle lanes.
Re:Diesel and petrol ban should come much faster, say MPs by Symbiote on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:41AM (#18255663)
Without saying when and where you lived at age 8, this is a pretty useless comment.

Aged 8, I was in the UK in the 1990s.

- Most children went to the nearest school (no longer the case with increased choice from parents)

- The tabloid "paedo-fear" thing hadn't really set in, so more children were allowed outside unsupervised.

- There were fewer people, and fewer working people [1]

- The number of car trips has gone up (although not much), and the number of walking trips has gone down massively [1]

- The number of children being driven to school (on a parent's way to work) has increased massively [1]. That presumably adds traffic at the worst possible place and time for children who could otherwise walk or cycle to school.

[1] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...