Re:What's the Use of a Horse's Tail?
by lovemenot on Thursday October 18, 2018 @07:31AM
(#18247417)
Can we call a greyhound's tail natural, if it has been bred for purpose by people?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I would as they where bread for speed not looks, with the tail evolving based on selection pressure.
Can you call any domesticated animal natural?
Sure, it's not a terrible stretch. An external force (us) encouraged their shaping through selective pressure. We are from the environment, the same as a rift valley or other long term environmental impact, for domesticated animals. As far as I know little to none current domestication uses fully manipulative method like CRISPR.
That we semantically look at our own involvement as somehow different on outcome isn't really the intent of artifice, I think. Rather that humans, individually and collectively, modify the environment to suit their needs.
I'm not really looking to argue the point, but interested in hearing other's thoughts on this.
Re:What's the Use of a Horse's Tail?
by headShrinker on Thursday October 18, 2018 @08:26AM
(#18247682)
It’s a legitimate question but it's a slippery slope. A wild horse can be domesticated, is it natural? Donkeys, and camels too, even birds like parrots and raptors can be trained to do work and be subservient to humans.
If the question is learned behavioral domestication vs bred genetic domestication... Is a banana natural? Apples oranges grains, virtually every verity of produce at the store has been ’domesticated’. Are they natural?
Humans have been bred for group behavior, language and manual (slave) labor by means of evolutionary pressure and natural selection. Are we unnatural?
Pretty sure ‘natural’ is not the delineation we want to use