We were usually given resources to help and were more or less usually supported by those above us. We did the best with what we were given. I kept in touch with some of the students for a while and most of them did ok (not great, mostly just ok) and were at least working in something close to what they wanted. Overall, back then, it was mostly positive. I've since worked at a couple of large public institutions and I can't say it was all that different. People on the front lines were mostly trying to help when they could. Totally different scale though, hard to even compare the two environments.
Basically, they target vulnerable people who have an earnest desire to approve themselves or access to someone else’s money. They advertise outcomes — “wouldn’t you like to be a respitory therapist making $75k” vs. courses of study and admit people to programs they are unqualified for. Then they pump you dry.
As a middle class person, it’s difficult to appreciate the mysterious nature of things without trustworthy advisors. A close friend came from a blue collar background and didn’t get good counsel. Her parents were thrilled that she got into college, which had been seemingly impossible for them.
She ended up getting a package of loans and scholarships that ran short at the end of her studies. Fortunately, in the 90s these predatory student loans weren’t as common, and she ended up putting $50k on credit cards to pay for her last 3 semesters, and was able to go bankrupt after a few years.
But the overall theme was exactly what you said:
1. Kid has no guidance / reference point / doesn't realize it's a scam.
2. Promised amazing education and career.
3. Takes on 50-100k of debt in 2 years.
4. Get "placed" in $12/hr job with random hours and the college marks their placement rate as 99%.
Most schools, public and private, moved to the model of charging as much as the family can afford (i.e., putting a huge sticker price and refunding the "unaffordable" portion for each family via a much-touted scholarship).
Some are 17-18 year old kids when they make the decision, with parents who don't even know better. Others are older but don't have the critical thinking skills that you and I have, or even a high school diploma. They're desperate to get out of awful minimum wage jobs and make something for themselves, but don't have many successful peers who can give them good advice. The schools have aggressive salespeople who lie through their teeth about outcomes.
It's crazy that we give people 5, 6 figures of loans when they aren't even mature enough to plan a few years in the future. If they don't get a career out of it, we're punishing them for decades for someone else taking advantage of them.
It's easy to blame people for this, but if I had no opportunities and no education, I could see myself taking a risk in the hopes that things will work out and I'd improve my life. The schools themselves are the ones who know better and are milking people for all they're worth. We should be stopping them from doing this, and the previous administration took good steps towards this.
Something I learned from the book Weapons of Math Destruction: there's an entire industry around skimming contact information from poor people to target for certain products. People will spend heavily on AdWords advertising for terms like "apply for food stamps," and have a web page that offers the service of expediting your food stamp application for free. Of course, this website is just a form that takes your info and forwards it to the regular online food stamp application. Maybe it's got better UX, but it's not expediting anything.
As part of handling the application, the website operator can save the name, address, and phone number of someone who is highly likely to be poor and desperate. They sell this information to certain companies, predominantly diploma mills and payday loan companies, who will then call these people directly to aggressively market their services.
I don't have the book at my fingertips, but if my memory is right, the contact details for one qualified lead sells for like $75.
If the Federal Government would limit loans to a set amount per course credit you can rest assure schools would scramble to have offerings that fit within the guidelines.
there seems to be little issue with forcing health care prices upon those who provide the services so the same should be done for education. simply weight the course and apply costs appropriate. this could be used to encourage certain skill sets over others.
The truth is, it was known the debt crisis was going to explode once the Federal Government got involved. Same happened to education as a whole let alone health care
I’d suggest going back to the 90s model of having rate capped subsidized and partially subsidized loans, and eliminating the bankruptcy exclusion for student debt outside of that framework. If the law makes a debt non-dischargable, the risk premium should be very low.
The problem is that reducing the firehose of capital would drive many universities out of business. They have 30 year bonds for luxury dorms and fitness centers to pay off.
I know a few people who attended a for-profit college. What “fooled” them was that they essentially had little lose: stay in a dead end job or take an expensive risk with a greater than 0 chance for ending up better than they were before.
The increase in price and loans at real colleges is a relatively minor (but important) problem, and one that could get proper attention if the massive dreck of the for-profit college industry was cleared away.
Do you know anyone who attended a for-profit college in the past 10 years? What fooled them into attending?