News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by s3r3nity on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:50PM (#18232087)
> Perhaps it is paid for by things like Maps and YouTube.

This is why monopoly rules exist, and why it's not quite so simple. Leveraging strong market position in one market, say search/advertising, to undercut prices in a completely different market is clear-cut anti-competitive behavior.

My retort to your argument would be: why even do hardware / Android at all? Because it's a distribution mechanism for _their_ services. If you leverage market dominance to expand that distribution network with fewer / no alternatives for consumers, that's like anti-trust 101.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by fixermark on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:02PM (#18232166)
> Leveraging strong market position in one market, say search/advertising, to undercut prices in a completely different market is clear-cut anti-competitive behavior.

Is it less clear how monopoly rules work if the price is "free?" If a company can offer a service for free by supplementing the cost with bundling (in a market where the going rate is "free") vs. not offering it at all, I'm not sure that's considered the same by US monopoly law (I have no idea of EU monopoly law).

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by s3r3nity on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:12PM (#18232262)
It's a reasonable question - but the price can never be truly "free," because there's a cost to investment / build that product - meaning costs are non-zero. Therefore the negative profit in the short-term due to pricing is called "undercutting," as other companies (generally) don't have that luxury in the long run.

You have to ask: why is it free?

- A thousand engineers working on a non-revenue product for Google is like "pennies," when it might be a whole company anywhere else.

- How are you funding that negative profit? Using leverage and profit from strong market position elsewhere. Therefore: anti-competitive, as other companies in the space don't have similar leverage.

Now, a startup can, say, operate at negative profit and not count as "anti-competitive," because a startup most likely has fractional market share. But imagine you're building a startup in a brand new space, and Google decides to also enter that space. If you price your product at $10, and Google says "we're pricing at $0," you can imagine how no one could compete with that for the long-term. Hence why monopoly / anti-competitive rules are important.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:00AM (#18236466)
> It's a reasonable question - but the price can never be truly "free," because there's a cost to investment / build that product - meaning costs are non-zero.

Those are fixed costs which can be amortized in other ways.

For example, Google could make both the OS and the hardware to sell together, like Apple. In fact, they do, with the Nexus/Pixel devices. Once they've done that, the OS development is a sunk cost. Giving it away to others or not has no effect on cost, or has negative cost if some of the others make contributions that you can use on your own devices without paying to develop them internally. And it grows the ecosystem your products are a part of, which is a valuable service the other vendors are providing for which some remuneration is appropriate, which could offset some or all of the cost of the software.

Moreover, software costs money to develop, but how much of the development cost should be apportioned to each unit? That depends how many units there will be. Not have been -- will ever be. This value is not known and can be arbitrarily large. For something like Android it is very large. If you amortize the development cost over the number of devices there are/will be, the cost per device is negligible -- small enough it would be eaten by transaction costs if you tried to collect it.

And claiming that companies can't give away software because they're large is clearly bad policy. It would imply that e.g. they can't contribute to Linux.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by fixermark on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:37PM (#18232472)
If we're talking app stores, I think it's free because no consumer would pay for it. F-Droid is also free.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by shock on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:46PM (#18232560)
I don't think this argument holds generally. For example people used to pay for GPS apps (iGO, TomTom, etc.) before Google Maps/other navi apps were available for "free" on smartphones. Google, in fact, might have destroyed a market by making Google Maps "free".
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by orangecat on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:12PM (#18234730)
Google, in fact, might have destroyed a market by making Google Maps "free".

Which is a good thing if it results in more people getting quality services. gcc and Apache destroyed the market for commercial compilers and web servers; should they have been prohibited?

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by themihai on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @10:20PM (#18235510)
>> gcc and Apache destroyed the market for commercial compilers and web servers; should they have been prohibited?

The difference here is that Apache didn't shove you a PlayStore, maps app and a browser in order to use their libraries. I want the products to "win" on merit not on reach. You also forget that Apache is open source which is not the case with Maps/youtube where your access can be denied at any time.

>> Which is a good thing if it results in more people getting quality services.

This gives no guarantee that Google won't start to charge its users for these services at some point in time. And there really won't be any competition as all the competitors have been killed by the "free" price.

Actually it seems they already set the price. You may argue that the end user doesn't pay for Playstore etc but we both know they pay...just like they paid for Windows. "Google said it would sell a license for a package including its Google Play...."

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:09AM (#18236501)
> The difference here is that Apache didn't shove you a PlayStore, maps app and a browser in order to use their libraries.

That's a completely independent complaint that has nothing to do with Android being available for free. You would have the same tying objection if Android cost money, right?

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by josefx on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:38AM (#18236662)
Quality? I spend two hours in the english countryside trying to find my goal and google kept routing me over a road that was removed years ago. I could mention other cases were google maps was worse than useless, but it boils down to a single issue: With commercial products you could pay and have some quality guaranteed. Google gives the average users the same quality guarantees they pay for: none.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by Tsubasachan on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @07:13AM (#18237939)
Strange, Maps is the only Google service I like. I'm in the Netherlands right now and their traffic data is always spot on. Literally updated by the minute.

I think that densely populated areas and countries with public up to date cartography are easier to serve.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by petre on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:58PM (#18233209)
> Google, in fact, might have destroyed a market by making Google Maps "free".

Might is an understatement. Google destroyed the market leading to Navteq and Tele Atlas being aquired by Nokia and TomTom.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by s3r3nity on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:41PM (#18234251)
Well that, AND prioritizing their Maps product above better offerings in the marketplace in search results early on in its lifecycle, when it was trying to get scale and data to improve while hurting competitors.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by fixermark on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:58PM (#18235287)
I don't remember the existence of better offerings early in the Maps lifecycle that Google search prioritized Maps results over. Maybe I'm too young?

There was Mapquest, and to my memory, Google came out of the starting gate with something close to feature parity with them.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by s3r3nity on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @12:59AM (#18236238)
Mapquest and Yahoo Maps were the dominant mapping platforms until Google Maps removed competitor links in the search results. [1] Google during this time was pushing for "universal search," which would break away from vertical search paradigms into a single blended set of results.

This was also when traffic spiked to Google Maps and away from MapQuest / other competitors. And when you look at the data, the change in traffic is not due to users searching for "Google Maps" in the query more - but rather Google just linking to its own results more. [2]

It was when I knew the whole "Don't be evil" motto was bullshit.

[1] https://searchengineland.com/google-no-longer-linking-to-yah...

[2] https://searchengineland.com/comscore-to-report-google-maps-...

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by warbaker on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @02:25PM (#18242012)
Maps was always a better product, though...
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by rayiner on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:15PM (#18232288)
The going rate in the smartphone OS market doesn't have to be "free." Symbian charged a license fee. Microsoft charged a license fee. Google decided to release Android for free, because they could make more money using Android as a vehicle for the rest of its platform. Having done that, and pushed all the competitors out of the market by giving Android away for nothing, Google can hardly argue that it should be allowed to bundle because the "going rate" for a smartphone OS is now free.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by gowld on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:15PM (#18232294)
Remember when giving away a web browser was illegal? Is giving away open source software and selling consulting services an anti-competitive abuse in the software services market?
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by GeekyBear on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:28PM (#18232407)
Giving away a web browser was not what was found to be illegal.

Using a large market share in one area (personal computer operating systems) as a weapon against competitors in another area (web browsers) was found to be illegal.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by scarface74 on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:46PM (#18232561)
Microsoft didn’t just “give away” the browser. It also forced OEMs not to bundle a competing browser.

Much like Google would not allow OEMs to both build Google Android devices and non Google Android devices based solely on AOSP.