Re:Why Italy Could Be the Epicenter of the Next Financial Cr...
by XorNot on Sunday October 14, 2018 @09:08AM
(#18212693)
Populism is an appeal to popular opinion without contributing any leadership IMO - i.e. you basically just send the broadest possible opinions of the population back at them, without attempting to shape or direct them into actionable strategies.
It always looks simplistic, because it is - there's no attempt to capture a defined, practical policy, just do whatever people will in general like as a sentiment.
Re:Why Italy Could Be the Epicenter of the Next Financial Cr...
by telchar on Sunday October 14, 2018 @02:27PM
(#18214297)
Populism is just the antipode to elitism. Too much elitism (e.g. pre-revolution France, gilded-age America or any kleptocracy of which there are numerous examples) is problematic too. A dose of populism can be a useful solution to that problem. For example, the New Deal seems to have worked out pretty well.
Just like anything else, populist policies need to be considered carefully and applied judiciously to work out well. To hold that all populist policies are simply to give out free money is a straw man argument.
A knee jerk response to any populist policy is a low-effort way to implicitly support elitist systems. These policies should at least be fairly considered on their own merits in the context of the actual economic system.
I'm not making an argument for any specific policy here, but I've seen far too many policy proposals waved away as "populist" and therefore not serious.
Socialism, communism, conservatism, liberalism, all the established political movements have a theory or philosophy of what goals they want to achieve, yes, but also what means they can use to achieve them. They have an economic or social theory.
Populism doesn’t, so all it tries to do is address the symptoms, not the causes. People are poor, let’s give them money. Problem solved! Foreign goods are cheaper than ours, let’s slap an import tax on them to make them more expensive. Problem solved!
The trouble is the reasons why people are trapped in poverty, or why local manufacturing isn’t competitive are not addressed, and populist tactics make those causes much harder to tackle.
The Italian governments policies will, if carried through, impoverish Italy for a generation. Just look at Greece to see what massive debt driven overspending can do to a country. The idea that growth will lift you out of the hole is a fantasy because the factors holding down growth aren’t being faced.