News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Short sellers are good for markets by aaavl2821 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:12PM (#18208955)
This article doesn't mention this, but short selling is a fundamental piece upon which many other financial instruments are built, because it allows hedging

If you take away short selling, you take away many other healthy components of functioning markets. You won't have functioning options markets for example, because market makers can't hedge their positions

I'd actually like to see more short selling. Especially in small biotech companies. It is either impossible or expensive to short these shares, so no one does it. Valuations can therefore be sustainably too high -- it's as if these stocks live in a world of lower gravity

Having an active short market would also enable all kinds of interesting options trading strategies, and I think smart math-minded people would have a field day

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by totalZero on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:46PM (#18209111)
> If you take away short selling, you take away many other healthy components of functioning markets. You won't have functioning options markets for example, because market makers can't hedge their positions

I'd say this isn't actually true. You'd hedge your short deltas and let the long deltas ride, prefer to sell delta to flatten risk (in other words charge more when selling puts and pay less when buying calls to compensate for P&L variance), and expect put-call disparities to level out in a slightly different manner. You could also sell well-correlated futures to hedge, or just trade combos and pass the risk off to someone else.

Empirically, many of the hard to borrow names are the most well-traded in the options world. When people can't sell short, they buy puts and pass the risk off to a market-maker.

Specifically about what I said about put-call parity: In the status quo, if puts are more expensive than stocks, you generally sell a put, sell 100 shares of stock, and buy a call. In the hypothetical world where you can't sell short, if you don't already have long shares then you can't take advantage of the inefficiency. So, put implied vol would trade over, and large banks and other dealers who are already long stock would have an advantage over small shops that don't already have a long shares position.

The only real difference is that options markets would be less liquid, wider and less efficient.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by aaavl2821 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @02:27PM (#18209302)
I think my statement about not having functioning options markets was stronger than I intended. I just meant you'd have way less liquidity, sometimes so little liquidity that you might as well not have a market

Could you elaborate on your point about hard to borrow options being the most widely traded? I'm not a derivatives person but was at a biotech fund and briefly looked at those options markets, and the bid ask spreads were ridiculous for many names to the point where it was almost pointless to even put in an order. Liquidity was super light as well

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by totalZero on Saturday October 13, 2018 @02:44PM (#18209376)
I've seen this many times as an options market-maker: A short-seller fund can't get borrow (which is a requirement for short selling) on a name it's already short, so it can't add to the short position. Thus, they call a bank and buy put options. The bank makes a price that incorporates (charges for) the borrow risk, usually because (A) the bank has an easier time locating borrow and gets a better price, (B) the bank trader/desk has a larger tolerance for P&L swings and can thus take the other side of the trade and hedge the position slowly or not at all, or (C) the bank has better market access and can trade combos (synthetic shares) against a different institution that has stock or a better borrow rate.

As a general rule, there's options activity for names that are very volatile. This doesn't always show up on the open interest count, because many firms trade OTC contracts that don't have the same clearinghouse protections as exchange-listed option contracts.

Option bid/ask spread being wide don't necessarily mean that volatility itself is illiquid. There could be large size on both bid and offer, with every dealer under the sun making a market, but the carry rate spread is wide, and that widens the option price. For example, the put offer will be based on the short rate, and the put bid will be based on the long rate, so if these two rates are divergent (as is the case when a name is hard to borrow), then the spread will be wide even if both sides are priced with the same implied volatility.

BTW even if screens show little more than a 100-lot, a bank will make a price on a much larger block of options. You won't know where liquidity is without quoting dealers. An option market could show a bid/ask that's 2 dollars wide with 200 contracts on either side, but a market maker may make you a two-way price that's 30 cents wide for 10,000 contracts. Depends on a lot of factors (who's the client, what's the position, does the market maker know the name and have a view, what are the catalysts, why is the screen market so wide, etc)

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by aaavl2821 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @03:03PM (#18209478)
Thanks, that makes sense

Do you have any experience with pre commercial biotech option markets, like making markets around binary events like Phase 2 trial results? I feel like the pricing of that volatility is quite inefficient but don't know enough about options math or market structure to really test that hypothesis

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 13, 2018 @02:04PM (#18209200)
> The only real difference is that options markets would be less liquid, wider and less efficient

Which raises costs for new share issuances (by making underwriting riskier), convertible debt (by making it more expensive to hedge the stock component), certain other flavours of debt, acquisitions, et cetera.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by totalZero on Saturday October 13, 2018 @02:57PM (#18209440)
And yet you'd still have a functioning option market, which is the point in question.

You don't have to hedge delta in short shares of the underlier in order to deal options. You can hedge out using your long shares, and then do the remainder in a correlated instrument or leave it without a hedge. For a pure market maker who simply buys and sells to earn spread, hedging is a means of managing P&L variance and protecting oneself against negative selection bias.

Similarly, you also don't have to hedge converts in options.

I'm not sure I understand your point about underwriting. Due to regulations, options don't start trading until several days after an IPO. Options on spinoffs tend to list more quickly, but are delayed as well. Secondary issuances have the advantage of already seeing where the market priced the stock, and are generally small, so there's no need to have a tight options market to hedge them.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 13, 2018 @03:35PM (#18209603)
> you'd still have a functioning option market

Most of the time. Professional options market makers would be degraded.

(As an aside, you'd also spawn systemic risks. Increased market-making risk favors small shops; access to inventory large. To bridge the gap, shorting would be replicated–more expensively, less transparently, and more riskily–through banks swapping their inventory to funds writing options. Add in your suggestion that hedging rely on historical correlations and you have a recipe for a preventable crisis.)

On underwriting, secondary issuances for seasoned issuers don't require options markets. But it reduces risk. That, in turn, reduces the cost of market access.

Australia's short-seeing ban "reduced trading activity, increased bid and ask spreads and increased intraday volatility" while providing "no evidence for lasting price support from the restrictions" [1]. It's a stupid idea that raises costs for everyone while sounding cute to the naive.

[1] https://epublications.bond.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?refere...

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by tim333 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:27PM (#18209011)
Nothing against shorting but you can write puts and calls without being needing short selling. Calls are naturally written by people holding a stock who don't mind selling some and puts by people with cash who don't mind buying some stock.
Re:Short sellers are good for markets by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:40PM (#18209077)
> you can write puts and calls without being needing short selling

Put-call parity [1] makes option markets work. It lets anyone to manufacture a put from a call and a short, or a call from a put and a long. This ability to spin up options on demand is critical to options market making. (Source: former options market maker.)

Take away shorting and you vastly increase the risk of correcting option mispricing. Given how fundamental options are to other instruments, e.g. convertible debt, this would directly decrease funding options (and increase funding costs) to companies.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Put–call_parity

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by nemo44x on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:50PM (#18209128)
Shorting a stock doesn't include the time element of options not to mention the relative lack of liquidity in derivatives as opposed to the equity.

Saying that, for most amateurs I'd recommend selling puts than shorting since shorting has unlimited downside risk.

Sometimes shorting against the box makes sense if you have the asset in another account and can't sell it there. You could short it in your primary account and then move the shares over which make take a few days locking in a sell price. When the shares arrive in your primary account it covers the short position.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by dm3 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @03:47AM (#18211829)
Should be "buying puts" if you replicate a short.

It's not a clear-cut situation - in times of turmoil, when many traders are considering a short, the price of options will rise. If the situation then calms down and the price of the underlying decreases steadily, the drop in the option price due to lower volatility will offset a lot of the potential gain.

When expressing a trade using options one has a lot more parameters to deal with in order to formulate the risk-reward properly. I'd say it's exactly the sort of thing most amateurs shouldn't be doing.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by nemo44x on Monday October 15, 2018 @12:45PM (#18221293)
Yeah, meant to say buying a put - thanks!

My biggest caution against shorting a stock VS a put is the potential loss. At least with a put your loss is capped.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by aaavl2821 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @02:32PM (#18209331)
Yes but you won't have those options markets unless market makers can hedge. You need a market maker to be on the other end of those trades, and from what I can tell, if market makers can't hedge then they either won't show up or will demand super wide bid ask spreads to make up for the delta risk

I'm not a derivatives trader but have explored investing in options when I was at a fund, and that was my experience looking at options for hard to borrow stocks. For market makers out there -- is that a fair assessment?

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by andrewtbham on Saturday October 13, 2018 @03:08PM (#18209499)
Betting against a team is different from trying to rig the game. An unfortunate side effect is that it incentives hedge funds to discredit legitimate companies.
Re:Short sellers are good for markets by aaavl2821 on Saturday October 13, 2018 @03:22PM (#18209547)
that goes both ways though, hedge funds talk their book on the long and short side

The difference is that it is generally much easier to make money on the long rather than short side. Stocks generally tend to rise in value, which acts to passively eat away at the returns to shorting. And with shorting you have unlimited downside while your loss is capped with a long position

So if you are shorting you are fighting gravity and have to sometimes be more vocal to compensate for that. If it were easier to short stocks, maybe people could make money without being as vocally critical

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by andrewtbham on Monday October 15, 2018 @06:10PM (#18224315)
Most hedge funds don't pump up their long positions... I'm not sure why, but they just don't.

Also if you buy puts you can limit your down side.