Re:Short sellers are good for markets
by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 13, 2018 @03:35PM
(#18209603)
> you'd still have a functioning option market
Most of the time. Professional options market makers would be degraded.
(As an aside, you'd also spawn systemic risks. Increased market-making risk favors small shops; access to inventory large. To bridge the gap, shorting would be replicated–more expensively, less transparently, and more riskily–through banks swapping their inventory to funds writing options. Add in your suggestion that hedging rely on historical correlations and you have a recipe for a preventable crisis.)
On underwriting, secondary issuances for seasoned issuers don't require options markets. But it reduces risk. That, in turn, reduces the cost of market access.
Australia's short-seeing ban "reduced trading activity, increased bid and ask spreads and increased intraday volatility" while providing "no evidence for lasting price support from the restrictions" [1]. It's a stupid idea that raises costs for everyone while sounding cute to the naive.
Most of the time. Professional options market makers would be degraded.
(As an aside, you'd also spawn systemic risks. Increased market-making risk favors small shops; access to inventory large. To bridge the gap, shorting would be replicated–more expensively, less transparently, and more riskily–through banks swapping their inventory to funds writing options. Add in your suggestion that hedging rely on historical correlations and you have a recipe for a preventable crisis.)
On underwriting, secondary issuances for seasoned issuers don't require options markets. But it reduces risk. That, in turn, reduces the cost of market access.
Australia's short-seeing ban "reduced trading activity, increased bid and ask spreads and increased intraday volatility" while providing "no evidence for lasting price support from the restrictions" [1]. It's a stupid idea that raises costs for everyone while sounding cute to the naive.
[1] https://epublications.bond.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?refere...