News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Short sellers are good for markets by simonh on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:12PM (#18208951)
I think this view is very naive because it doesn't take into account the perverse incentives legalising insider trading could create.

Insiders often also have power over the behaviour of a company, so for example a corporate leader might short his company's stock and then take actions to ruin the business. Or they might release plans for some action that would be seen negatively in the market, depress the stock price, buy, and then change the plans to ones that will attract investors and pocket the difference when the price goes back up. This doesn't improve market information, in fact it's disinformation because those selling on the first announcement were deceived, but how could you prove it?

Maybe they would get caught, maybe not, but legalising insider trading creates an incentive for these sorts of behaviour that would not exist otherwise.

Re:Short sellers are good for markets by logicchains on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:51AM (#18211426)
>Insiders often also have power over the behaviour of a company, so for example a corporate leader might short his company's stock and then take actions to ruin the business. Or they might release plans for some action that would be seen negatively in the market, depress the stock price, buy, and then change the plans to ones that will attract investors and pocket the difference when the price goes back up.

Legalising insider trading wouldn't legalise such behaviour per se, as such behaviour would still constitute a breach of the leader's fiduciary duties. Look for instance at how Musk was prosecuted for doing that kind of thing; such prosecution was unrelated to insider trading laws, and could still occur without them.