University is definitely useful for at least some subset of the population.
Most people with a math degree don't use even a small fraction of their training. I do, but I'm in the minority. (Also worth noting that most of what I use I didn't learn in school.)
I'm interpreting "mathematician" to mean "math Ph.D." or
"person who does/did research in math", which is typically
the way the term is used.
Ahh, okay then. I just thought it meant someone with a bachelor degree in mathematics.Are you saying moving into academia isn't a good career move? Because that's probably true with every technical profession.
How tiny is the fraction?
This was Rutgers - at Princeton, the ratio would be a bit better, at NJIT it would be worse. Don't even ask about podunk state.
It's a shitty career path. Unless you are fantastically good, don't waste your time.
[1] My adviser told me I could have been on the tenure track if I wanted to. Since I didn't put it to the test by applying for such jobs, I won't claim it as true.
Every other course will just give you a better chance of getting a job, and help you perform better once you get there. A math grad can solve all kinds of problems that other people will just shrug their shoulders at. That's always useful.
Academia in general is a dangerous career path though. Too many people on the ground floor (i.e. every undergrad who can't think of a better thing than grad school), too much glamor keeping them there, very bureaucratic organizations, and a complete mismatch between work (research) and funding (students).
I don't suppose physics would be any better?
Putnam is less relevant than original research.
Or do you include the much larger set of mathematicians who couldn't find a job as mathematicians, and now work as high school math teachers, community college adjuncts or business analysts?
I'm a member of the former set. Most of the people I went to school with are members of the latter. School was fun, but no one is under the illusion it was a good career move.