News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by cultus on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:31PM (#18202571)
Objectivism really is a vacant and pretty incoherent "philosophy." It's no surprise she presented in in the form of tedious novels with wooden characters rather than engaging with actual philosphers.

I think its popularity is due to the fact that it tells people what they want to hear, and they can think of themselves as John Galt-esque ubermenschen.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by poulsbohemian on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:16PM (#18202956)
> they can think of themselves as John Galt-esque ubermenschen.

Of all the heroes we could encourage people to have, is John Galt really so awful? He's described as bright, hard-working, self-reliant, but also collaborative and supportive of the work of those around him. He's driven and entrepreneurial, but not anti-social. He doesn't come across as anti-government so much as desiring government that isn't kleptocratic or set on regulatory capture. So... is any of that so awful?

There's a spectrum here... those who praise Rand and Objectivism might do so with a bit too much fervor. But,I'm skeptical toward those who turn up their nose with disgust.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by dieterrams on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:29PM (#18203577)
The fundamental problem with Rand's ideology is her cartoonish categorization of everyone that isn't Galt-esque or an enthusiastic, hypercompetent support person as evil looters/parasites. Iirc, Galt is basically trying to collapse society for everyone but the former.

When you realize that you can't just write off people because they didn't turn out to be brilliant entrepreneurs or perky worker bees, and that the workings of government and justice are more complicated than Rand would allow, Atlas Shrugged does become pretty repugnant. Granted, she was reacting to her experiences with communism, so I don't totally blame her for going all the way to the other extreme.

But insofar as someone wants to invent great things and do well from them, I don't take issue with that.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by glalonde on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:20PM (#18204417)
Everyone was cartoonish, even the good guys. It was like a small army of glimmering MD PhD's with perfect physiques vs. the lazy bums.

It's a work of fantasy, why does anyone point to it and say "This is what I base my beliefs on."? That would be like using LotR as your moral compass. Except with worse plot holes like gross misrepresentations of how small mountain village economies could possibly function.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by stale2002 on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:16PM (#18205606)
Rands work was a direct criticism of communism.

Given that this is the topic that we are discussing, I do not find her ideas to be fantasy at all.

Stalin and Mao killed many millions of people, both intentionally, and through mere neglect. Probably more than the Nazis. So given that this is the topic, her criticism of a collapsing society doesn't seem that ridiculous.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by arkis22 on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:55PM (#18203776)
I disagree.

In the book society was already collapsing. Plenty of regular people in the novel realized something was wrong and removed themselves from the looters' economy to roam the country.

Galt simply refused to be the one to prop up the looters failing economy.

Interesting that you see Galt as the one collapsing society. Rand's point was that the looters collapsed society and that they were too ignorant to understand why or how.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by holtalanm on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:22PM (#18203986)
This.

Galt and the others that removed themselves from the collapsing society were not the ones that were collapsing society, nor was the collapse their end-goal.

In the story, the looters were causing the collapse, and were taking everything not nailed down in the process. Galt and the others simply decided to leave them to it.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by amptorn on Friday October 12, 2018 @06:54PM (#18205291)
So in the metaphor of the story's title, Atlas, whose shrugging caused the collapse of society, is the looters? Not the successful entrepeneurial giants, Galt et al., who in their collective departure from the world leave it, figuratively speaking, unsupported?
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by arkis22 on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:59PM (#18205542)
No, Atlas is people like Galt.

The point is that the looters pushed the weight of the world on to them, and that's the failure of their society.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by amptorn on Saturday October 13, 2018 @05:36AM (#18207207)
This is a terribly muddled metaphor.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by EdSharkey on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:29PM (#18204471)
Ayn Rand's characters and storytelling is crappy. The correct response when someone asks, "Who is John Galt?" is always "WHO THE #$%^&* CARES?!" That notwithstanding, Rand understood that one can moralize without limitation in our culture as long as one does it in narrative form, and she used her platform to the extreme.

The message and moral I took from her stories was essentially pro-human, where the archetypal good is that independent man who creates according to their own taste, without any overlords, and without the approval of others. The greater any effort is collectivized, the greater the sin.

Rand's is a hyper-optimistic view of the individual - it feels like an atheist's attempt to replace God with Man and then posit him as the highest virtue. And in the introduction to The Fountainhead, I believe Rand even said her philosophy was a form of worship of Man. It's foolish because life is much too brutal for man to ever truly ascend that way. In any case, her brand of optimism is so rare, and that sells.

It's so interesting to me that your critique went to group politics and identity, though. Rand was consistently negative about groups and big government cronyism. She treated her archetypes as equally noble whether they were breaking rocks in a quarry or engineering some new miracle metal. Do you view the world through such a group identity lens that you couldn't see that in her writing? It's absolutely plain.

The evil archetypes in the Randian universe are any nullifying spirit, destroyer, or parasite. Remember, these are archetypes, no-one in the real world is so black-and-white. It's not a bad characterization of evil, and has parallels in religion and literature.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by dieterrams on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:35PM (#18205445)
> It's so interesting to me that your critique went to group politics and identity, though. Rand was consistently negative about groups and big government cronyism. She treated her archetypes as equally noble whether they were breaking rocks in a quarry or engineering some new miracle metal. Do you view the world through such a group identity lens that you couldn't see that in her writing? It's absolutely plain.

I’m not really sure what you’re talking about. I do have thoughts on group and identity politics, but I certainly wasn’t referencing them in my post. Not consciously or in any way that is obvious to me, at least.

Re: her archetypes being treated as “equally noble”, I didn’t suggest they weren’t? Although she certainly presents a hierarchy of value that depends on what a given character is doing / capable of. Rearden is without question the lesser man in Rand's and Dagny Taggart's eyes, compared to Galt.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by EdSharkey on Sunday October 14, 2018 @07:22AM (#18212394)
It was two things you said which gave me some insight into your worldview:

> Galt is basically trying to collapse society for everyone but the former.

There is an interesting feature of the Christian bible where God starts out walking/talking directly with Man, and as the stories progress, God grows more and more distant. Eventually, God can only communicate with mankind via prophets and Jesus. I think the point of this storytelling device was to indicate the increasing sin divide between humanity and God. God, being incompatible with sin, simply could not approach us even though He wanted to.

I believe Rand uses this same 'disgusted separation' device in Atlas Shrugged to remove her heroes further and further away from the fallen world.

That you took Galt's exodus and luring of the most productive people from society as an offensive move to destabilize that society struck me immediately as a "class struggle" thought. You had formed Rand's productive archetypes as some kind of oppressive elite class, or some such.

I wish there was some gray in Rand's writing and thoughts to allow for that. In her philosophy, voluntary denial of one's productive capacity to others could never be considered terrorism.

I clearly see targeted terrorism in Galt's luring of key people out of society, regardless of when and why, because we all need one another, period. But Rand thought Galt was saving those people from an already too-far-gone, collapsing world, there to help rebuild after the old world finally bottomed out.

> When you realize that you can't just write off people because they didn't turn out to be brilliant entrepreneurs or perky worker bees

This felt to me like another oppressor/victim thought you had where the oppressor might be the employed and the victim might be the indigent or jobless. Life is more complicated than that, so those characterizations are only sometimes true (and perhaps not even mostly true in my personal, subjective experience.) Reducing the world down to too generic terms risks missing the truth of things, giving one false rationale for all kinds of mischief.

You make a good point about gradients in Riordan vs Galt. It's been a couple of years since I read AS, but I recall Riordan's "sin" was that he loved the work too much and gave in to the government cronies rather than just shrugging them off. Ugh, that book was a hot mess...

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by EdSharkey on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:09AM (#18213261)
> I wish there was some gray in Rand's writing and thoughts to allow for that. In her philosophy, voluntary denial of one's productive capacity to others could never be considered terrorism.

I said that, forgetting there was terrorism (hero blows up a building) in The Fountainhead. AS is definitely a more pure statement of Rand's philosophy, but I think she rationalized away too much in every case to cleanly make her point.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by poulsbohemian on Saturday October 13, 2018 @01:50PM (#18209129)
> it feels like an atheist's attempt to replace God with Man and then posit him as the highest virtue.

So same basic concept as nitschze espoused?

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by EdSharkey on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:06AM (#18212192)
Yeah, she cited Nitschze in the forward to The Fountainhead. I recall she said his ideas were 'underdeveloped', hahaha!
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by chimeracoder on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:03PM (#18205339)
> In any case, her brand of optimism is so rare, and that sells.

You're saying Ayn Rand is popular because of the optimism in her works?

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by EdSharkey on Sunday October 14, 2018 @06:03AM (#18212188)
Yes. It's fanciful about the heights to which the human spirit can reach. She's the ultimate optimist, in my opinion. Plenty of hero stories are set in ultra-negative backgrounds, just to set the contrast.

I hope to God Rand's writing isn't gobbled up for its sex scenes, yikers!

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by skookumchuck on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:27PM (#18204024)
It's hard to get more cartoonish than Star Trek's Ferengi, a left-wing caricature of capitalists, going so far as having pointed teeth.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by cultus on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:26PM (#18204457)
Star Trek is a tv show. Unlike Objectivism, it is not trying to be a philosophy.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by skookumchuck on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#18205380)
Are you sure about that? Most ST episodes have a pretty heavy-handed moral lesson on progressive philosophy.

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/06/new-star-trek-series-...

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by cultus on Friday October 12, 2018 @07:43PM (#18205475)
No one bases their lives around Star Trek moral messages besides a few nerds.

Also, you may want to read what I wrote again. I said "Star Trek is not pretending to be a moral philosophy." Ayn Rand claims that Objectivism is the basis for ethics, epistemology, metaphysics, etc. How on Earth does that compare to the Ferengi being greedy as a parable of capitalism?

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by skookumchuck on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:08PM (#18205576)
> "Star Trek is not pretending to be a moral philosophy."

I gave a link showing it was Roddenberry's directive. Also, what do you think of the Prime Directive? (Which, of course, is routinely violated if the aliens don't conform to progressive ideals.)

> besides a few nerds

I've read progressive newspaper columnists citing Star Trek as a model to emulate.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by dieterrams on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:07PM (#18205572)
I was saying her categorizations are cartoonish, as in overly simplistic morally and sociologically.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by mixmastamyk on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:44PM (#18203189)
Agreed. About five years ago I decided to investigate the subject, watched the recent movie and her interviews on the disc. Turns out her more subtle early novels weren't understood, so she increasingly wrote them bonking the reader over the head with the point, ala A.S. The reputation of simplistic paper-thin characters emerges from that. Meh.

Her experience was of the communists taking and breaking everything, one should keep that in mind. She's basically warning about government overreach, something we should all be able to get behind. It's a valid argument until you take it too far and use it as an excuse, like all political arguments.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by poulsbohemian on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:05PM (#18203367)
The interviews I've seen of her directly contradict some of the things I've heard her acolytes, including Leonard Peikoff, comment, especially in the area of foreign conflict. Like any complex person, some of what she said was brilliant and some of it didn't all add up. Thankfully as other complex people we can debate, engage, and take from it that which has merit.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by xenadu02 on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:46PM (#18204170)
The hero of that book is a woman who inherited a railroad and provides nothing of value to society. Why is she great? Because she is; no explanation is offered.

Even John Galt stands on the shoulders of giants. He had no resources to implement his ideas and stole from his employer. If she had something smart to say about misallocation of capital then Galt might be an interesting character.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by arkis22 on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:56PM (#18204252)
The value she provides is running the railroad well, unlike her brother. Are you making the case that a well run railroad does not provide value to society? Perhaps you don't remember the incident in the book of the train running through a tunnel without ventilation and killing all the passengers?

Can you list what Galt stole? I don't remember him stealing anything. He even leaves his greatest invention, his motor, to his old employers as he concedes it wasn't his because they paid for it.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by holtalanm on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:56PM (#18203781)
wholeheartedly agree.

I'm not an Ayn Rand sycophant by any means, but there _is_ some merit to her literature that doesn't discredit it entirely.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by stale2002 on Friday October 12, 2018 @08:01PM (#18205548)
Rand's works need to be read while knowing the context that it was written in.

Rand grew up in Russia, and her works were a direct criticism of the failures of the Soviet Union and communism.

For someone who was watching their former country being torn apart, by cartoon villians, it makes sense that she would write about the exact problems that she saw happening. IE, cartoon villians looting the country.

Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by conanbatt on Saturday October 13, 2018 @12:43AM (#18206471)
Back then people praised the soviet union, they feared their economic prowess. And while even some economists of name woudl say that communism was showing great results she claimed that it would collapse from within. That was a very public bet that she won and should get a lot of credit, to go against the world and standing by her ideas, and she was right.
Re:A Billionaire’s Sears Fiasco Is Finally Nearing Its End by AnimalMuppet on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:10PM (#18202915)
And enlightened. Better in thought and better in results. For those prone to pride as a motivator, it was a lovely philosophy.