Some people sign contracts, and then do not fulfill the terms, betting that the other party will not take them to court.
I was once asked to sign a non-compete when my employer was going out of business. I had to sign it to get the severance package. It was quite broadly worded, and could have been interpreted as preventing me from doing any software development for a period of two years. I did sign, because who was ever going to enforce it?
Hmm, interesting. I know of a recent case in New York State where one company acquired another, but selectively retained its employees. The acquiring company thought that it was simply not hiring everyone, rather than firing anyone. One of those people sued for unemployment, and the court found that the acquiring company did in fact have to pay unemployment for the employees it "did not hire".
That isn't necessary. The old company could legally just cease to exist, with its assets transferred over to another entity.
Do you know if that's been tested in court? Seems like such an obvious violation of the spirit of the law that it wouldn't (one hopes) hold up in appeal.
I signed it ‘Juul E. Nissen’ (the equivalent of S. Anta Claus’)
Nobody bothered to verify the signature. I wonder how that would have held up in court.
Did they ask you to sign this contract after you had accepted their offer, or after you had already started working for them? Or was it provided as part of the job offer? Did you receive any additional compensation (consideration) for signing this contract?
(Their) problem in court would have been that such contracts are not enforceable in my jurisdiction; however, my colleagues and I would rather not start off the new business relationship by dragging them to court, so we duly signed (of sorts).
Seems a bit odd to expect a business partner to "verify your signature". How could they do that anyway? Compare it to previous documents? You could have changed your signature.
Not saying they should get away with draconian agreements, but the "right" thing to do would be to not sign it.
Im curious how this would actually go, considering it must have happened before.
I'm also curious about what has happened when people tried this before.
there is a trick under UCC, which is technical, but totally enforceable in court that does something similar.
no, I'm not going to mention it.
If you're ever told "sign this or be fired", even if there is consideration (ex: a severance) w/o being given the chance to have a lawyer review it, there's a strong chance it will be thrown out.
As with all things legal, this depends on the jurisdiction (in this case, meaning the state since we're talking about US law). The general rule in most states is that continued employment is not sufficient consideration, but in Illinois it currently is; California doesn't allow non-competes for non-owner/non-highly-compensated employees, so it's a moot point in CA. [https://www.bna.com/continued-employment-sufficient-b5798208...]
I can't imagine any judge accepting this... but I can imagine it backfiring badly, adding bad faith into the interpretation.
Interesting. Couldn't you construct a similar argument against the "we've updated our ToS! You can accept it or leave our service and lose access to all your documents/games/devices/friends/etc" malpractice? Or is that a different legal basis?
I could swear that the SCOTUS had a similar case and decided that continued employment did count as consideration.
A while back, the startup I worked at was acquired by a large company known for its aggressive legal department. Everyone had to sign an agreement, including both intellectual property and non-compete clauses, or be fired. One guy actually did refuse, and was fired. A few years later, I left that big company to work for another startup. I was concerned about that non-compete, so I did a bit of checking and found that it was NOT A CONTRACT as far as the law was concerned. You see, a contract by definition requires consideration on both sides. The relevant courts had repeatedly found that an offer of initial employment counted as consideration, but an offer of continued employment did not. Thus, what I had signed was not a contract. Legally, it wasn't a non-binding or unenforceable contract. It was a non-entity. A piece of paper with some irrelevant squiggles on it.
I've heard that other ex-employees (and their lawyers and the courts) reaching the same conclusion is the reason that the big company in question adopted a policy of technically firing everyone from any startup they acquired, and then re-hiring them immediately under the same terms. The sole effect was to turn that continued employment into initial employment, non-consideration into consideration, validating the rest of the contract. It's now standard practice throughout the industry.