Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by Tossrock on Thursday October 11, 2018 @05:38AM
(#18192057)
You're playing some weird games with numbers here. "100% if we subtract the failures" isn't 100%, and something that hasn't been tested yet doesn't really have a 0% success rate, it just doesn't have a success rate at all.
I'm not saying that Commercial Crew is "better" than the Soyuz program, but I am definitely saying that after two high profile incidents within a few weeks, I am concerned about the long term viability of relying on it for human access to space.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by gdhbcc on Thursday October 11, 2018 @06:57AM
(#18192396)
Its not unusual to remove the top and bottom outliers
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by village-idiot on Thursday October 11, 2018 @08:21AM
(#18192856)
Not a good habit in rocketry.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by ams6110 on Thursday October 11, 2018 @10:55AM
(#18194021)
We continued to fly the shuttle even after it killed 14 astronauts. By measure of total astronauts killed, it was the worst spacecraft design in history. Though not sure how it ranks in deaths per flight.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by village-idiot on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:35AM
(#18199458)
A good argument to not ignoring that outlier.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by zaarn on Thursday October 11, 2018 @08:47AM
(#18193016)
Even in rocketry, you just need to keep even more distance to the top and bottom of any ratings on any part than in normal engineering and put in a few redundancies in case it does fail.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by ceejayoz on Thursday October 11, 2018 @08:32AM
(#18192928)
> You mean the option with 0% success rate so far is better than the one with 100% (till this incident)?
If you're gonna play that sort of silly numbers game, Commercial Crew has a 0% failure rate to Soyuz's non-zero rate.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by Piskvorrr on Thursday October 11, 2018 @07:09AM
(#18192460)
Null is not zero, the comparison is meaningless.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by neuronic on Thursday October 11, 2018 @07:22AM
(#18192519)
Null is essentially a coin toss while zero is guaranteed failure. Both are questionable options compared to 100% success rate over years.
The comparison isn't meaningless at all.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by Symmetry on Thursday October 11, 2018 @09:52AM
(#18193511)
We've already done ground testing, launch abort tests, etc on the commercial crew vehicles plus a reference class of space vehicle first launches. So there's no cause to fall back on the Laplacian prior.
Re:Astronauts escape malfunctioning Soyuz rocket
by MauranKilom on Thursday October 11, 2018 @02:50PM
(#18196058)
"I haven't played the lottery yet, so it's a coin toss whether I win."
You mean the option with 0% success rate so far is better than the one with 100% (till this incident)?