Re:Arguing against using protobuffers
by anothergoogler on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @08:25PM
(#18190104)
Brash on a personal blog is tricky. In this post's case, I'd worry that the blogger has a hard time separating technical deficiencies from professional incompetence. "Designed by amateurs" is an over-the-top and dubious claim.
As an experienced engineer I can hear the pain behind that dubiuos claim and no, I wouldn't want to work with someone who behaves like this all the time but I wouldn't mind someone who once in a while gets fed up show some emotions. It's all about how you handle the aftermath, ie. can you apologize to people you accidentally hurt along the way.
How about don't hurt people to begin with?
Re:Arguing against using protobuffers
by whateveracct on Thursday October 11, 2018 @12:17AM
(#18190932)
The Googlers who designed Protobuffers’ type system were undeniably amateurs in that realm without knowledge of the state-of-the-art.
Re:Arguing against using protobuffers
by anothergoogler on Thursday October 11, 2018 @02:15PM
(#18195798)
Their goals were not to create the most academically sound type system. They were focused on engineering challenges. Read the comments here ti understand the authors' priorities and obstacles.
- has opinions on interface design
- isn't afraid to be wrong publicly
- is brash on a personal blog
I dunno, this is mostly positive. I'd have to see how well they'd adapt to the much different context and goals of one of our design reviews, but this isn't an immediate red flag. There's a million ways to be bad at a job. I'll give them enough rope to hang themselves in a serious conversation rather than invent the idea that someone would be an unworkable perfectionist professionally just from being a type purist on the internet.