News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by nir on Friday October 22, 2010 @02:06AM (#1818769)
I'm surprised at the generally positive approach in HN toward Apple's recent announcements. Apple is about to have control over the user's system no one since mainframe-era IBM ever came close to.

Not only they're about to move desktops/laptops into the App Store's walled garden, they are showing they can drop support for major technologies like Java or Flash if they feel like it. This is not good news for anyone but Apple, certainly not anyone calling themselves "Hacker".

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by cubicle67 on Friday October 22, 2010 @02:22AM (#1818800)
I think you may be overreacting a bit here, although we won't know until a few years down the track

Apple aren't about to "move desktops/laptops into the App Store's walled garden", but rather they're about to add an optional place to purchase apps. It's an addition that I think may have some benefit for some users and smaller indie developers. I can see it becoming the way most people purchase most of their apps in time, but I can never see it becoming the only way to do so on the mac.

They also haven't dropped support for either Flash or Java. The new MBAs aren't shipping with Flash installed; so what? OSX is the only OS I'm aware of that does ship with Flash. Java? Well, Java's not going anywhere either.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by kls on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:27AM (#1819412)
Right, I think Steve is smart enough to not follow so many others down that path in history. A completely closed system would cut developers off at the knees. Which would put Apple on the hook to develop every piece of software for their ecosystem. There is no way the could keep up with the idea factory that is the masses. I think rather Apple sees an opportunity to provide a sales channel where they get a cut of other people work by acting as the distributor and in turn do things like guarantee that the app if free of malicious actions and compatible with OSX systems.

As for Java, I knew this one was coming, Jobs and Ellison are good friends and Apple and Oracle are the only two companies that either are not at war with, they really don't compete in each other spaces. So I think Jobs is comfortable with Oracle providing the JVM for their platform.

I am sure that Steve has resigned any worry in his head that Java is going to achieve desktop dominance so it is not a Trojan horse to his platform where it will be used to provide OSX apps in preference over the native OSX development technologies.

Giving it back to Oracle means that the developers get the latest JVM at the same time as everyone else not waiting up to a year as the cycle comes around itself. I think it is a good move on both companies parts. I just wonder why Steve always has to be so vague. I think his showmanship has become so ingrained that he just can't come right out and say it everything has to be a big announcement. I guess I cant fault him, it's his trademark and has served him well.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by akmiller on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:31AM (#1819601)
I stated this in another thread, but I will restate here because it seems appropriate.

The App Store will most definitely become the most popular way to find and install applications. Therefore if your app is not in the app store it may as well not exist. The regular user is going to search for the best application within that garden to fulfill their needs which puts all developers at the mercy of Apple to get their app in the store.

I wonder that if this model gains popularity on the desktop, how long it will be before users click that app store icon to find an application they need vs. click the browser icon to find a service on the web that may fit that need.

With strong shift towards web based apps over the past few years it's interesting that a move like this may re-invigorate the desktop app!

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by protomyth on Friday October 22, 2010 @10:18AM (#1819758)
I think that is true for most indy apps, but stuff from Adobe or Microsoft will be fine. I also expect verticals to continue to do fine (dedicated sales staff and industry rep). If your an small developer then you probably should be in the app store.

People do want native apps (for a bit of humor http://daringfireball.net/linked/2010/10/21/beltzner )because connectivity is not 100% and the fit, finish, and speed of native apps are better. I don't think your wrong, I guess twitter clients kind of prove the point.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by alanh on Friday October 22, 2010 @02:30AM (#1818813)
When I read comments like yours, I just want to point at a Terminal.app prompt. Or Bootcamp. You can do anything you want to with a Mac, and there’s no actual indication that’s changing; just FUD.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by nir on Friday October 22, 2010 @03:25AM (#1818883)
I'm writing this on my 3rd Macbook. I don't have any reason to spread FUD against Apple. I think dropping Java (there isn't currently a real alternative to Apple's) is a strong indication. The App Store policies are a strong indicator, and restricting iPhone/iPad development environments is a strong indicator.

You may be able to do what you want on your own machine given enough knowledge/time. The issue arises when a business based on a Mac Java app becomes redundant when Apple feels like it, or when it will become very hard to make a living selling an app Apple doesn't feel is right for the Store.

Once upon a time there was a company called Microsoft who controlled a popular OS. People who called themselves "hackers" generally didn't like it, since they asserted this power to control the product space as well, changing APIs or bundling software to eliminate competition. Apple has gone beyond Microsoft's wildest dreams, and are on track become comparably widespread - I don't think they get a pass just because the standby light has the same frequency as a human heartbeat.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:22AM (#1818958)
Who is supposed to be interested in maintaining Java on OS X? Apple, if their platform were too weak to attract developers who develop specially for the platform.

Oracle, if the Apple's platform is attractive enough. Note that Sun fought Microsoft to effectively take over Java on Windows. I know, MSFT one was not "pure," still that was the result. And one has to wonder if Apple would be sued the same way, since they also have OSX specific bindings.

The current bet is: OSX just became interesting enough to let Oracle maintain Java on it, if they want and are capable.

As far as I understand, the Java applications that were not already using OSX specifics weren't by any measure successful, and the only famous one is that FTP client, which is actually not a "write once works everywhere" Java app, but an OSX app accidentally written in Java. And it's an open source app. Can you please name some examples for "business based on a Mac Java apps?" Especially those that don't use OSX specifics.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by geden on Friday October 22, 2010 @05:53AM (#1819127)
http://www.entertainmentpartners.com/

They have Java based apps for the Film industry. I have to support them on OS X. They are hideous to use, hideous to install and maintain. I don't know if they use OS X Java specifics, but some how I doubt it.

They were broken by Snow Leopard. Took them months to fix.

My experience, purely as a sysadmin and user, is that cheap and cheerful cross platform apps seem to be much nicer when written for Adobe Air.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:32AM (#1819168)
Their target was obviously not the users of OSX, I believe it was more an exception.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by nervechannel on Friday October 22, 2010 @05:09AM (#1819051)
Can you please name some examples for "business based on a Mac Java apps?" Especially those that don't use OSX specifics.

I don't understand this question.

Either it's a Java app (no platform specified), or it's a Mac Java app that does use OSX-specific code.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @05:35AM (#1819093)
Microsoft was sued by Sun because of "a deliberate course of conduct to fragment Java" and had to settle by removing their own Java implementation from the operating system.

http://www.javaworld.com/javaworld/jw-10-1997/jw-10-lawsuit....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Java_Virtual_Machine

As far as I understand Java license doesn't allow you to make a platform specific Java implementation.

So who's then to bet his business on Mac Java apps? The only potentially "safe" approach is not to depend on Mac specifics. But is there any example of a profitable Java app (which made profit by targeting OSX customers) applying the mentioned "safe" approach?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by pmjordan on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:23AM (#1819157)
They got sued for not adhering to the Java spec, not for their extensions. The latter would be ridiculous, it would mean you could never distribute the JRE together with any sort of extra libraries. Even the Sun/Oracle runtime ships with non-standard extensions (javax.* , com.sun.*).
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:36AM (#1819177)
> not adhering to the Java spec, not for their extensions.

And AFAIK specs are made for "write once run everywhere."

> it would mean you could never distribute the JRE together with any sort of extra libraries.

You can as long as you are using only what Sun (now Oracle) approves.

> Even the Sun/Oracle runtime ships with non-standard extensions

They make the rules, so what they do can't be used as an argument.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by flomo on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:45AM (#1819656)
Java certainly does not guarantee "write once run everywhere", although Sun had a "Pure Java" branding effort at one time.

What Microsoft did was extend the language to include an annotations feature (making it source-incompatible), and extending the JVM spec to include new opcodes (which crashed everyone else's JVM). Had they extended Java the conventional way there would not have been a problem.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by pmjordan on Friday October 22, 2010 @07:28AM (#1819268)
And AFAIK specs are made for "write once run everywhere."

Yes, my understanding was that the MS implementation did not pass all the compatibility requirements. Adding extra functionality is entirely orthogonal to that point.

IBM's, Azure's and all the J2ME implementations come with proprietary extensions and are blessed by Sun/Oracle. I don't follow your argument.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:58AM (#1819484)
> and are blessed by Sun/Oracle. I don't follow your argument

I don't have anything more to add than to quote you (the keyword is blessed) and also point to my previous posts. As long as you're forced to get the blessing before you introduce the interface to your own platform (or be forced to leave something out because you know it won't be blessed) why should it be in your interest to maintain the technology of others if you have your own technologies and a platform that's attractive even by itself?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by pmjordan on Friday October 22, 2010 @12:43PM (#1820341)
From my own experience with it:

- .class files compiled on Apple's JVM work fine on other JVMs

- Source code written for Apple's version of javac will compile fine on other Java compilers.

To my knowledge, Microsoft's JVM violated both of these requirements, which was Sun's bone of contention. (Android's Dalvik is in similar violation, but doesn't pretend to be "Java" - they're being sued based on patents IIRC)

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by acqq on Friday October 22, 2010 @01:16PM (#1820489)
> .class files compiled on Apple's JVM work fine on other JVMs

Technically, you don't need to compile "on JVM" but "for JVM." And it doesn't seem to be as you describe for most of the cases (in Sun's words, 98%).

> Microsoft's JVM violated both of these requirements

AFAI understand it was far more subtle: the language (the source form representation) was extended with the features which functioned only on Microsoft's implementation, and only such classes were affected. See

http://download.oracle.com/javase/1.4.2/docs/guide/deploymen...

for a list of issues of switching from Microsoft VM based upon Java 1.1 to Sun's 1.4.2. The list appears to be very unimpressive.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by com on Friday October 22, 2010 @03:35AM (#1818899)
The app store rules are a fairly smart move from a service and support perspective.

They don't want to have to manage complex dependencies in the app store.

Therefore no optional or deprecated packages.

This move doesn't really support the conspiracy theory of an Apple lockdown strategy, although it certainly doesn't give any confidence that such a strategy is not in the making.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by nir on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:31AM (#1818974)
The current App Store policies aren't a theory. The move to the App Store for laptop/desktop was just announced. Apple isn't Evil, it does what any company would do if it could. It's disappointing to see this discussion degrading to Apple fanboy/hater or "conspiracy theory".

I think App Store is a great solution for most users and developers. But not for the particular minority I define as hackers.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by cpr on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:16AM (#1819380)
Yes, but Apple has given no indication they ever plan to shut down non-App Store distribution of software.

That would be suicidal.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by jimbojohn on Friday October 22, 2010 @03:28AM (#1818886)
Oracle will provide the JVM, if steve's email is any indication.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by mironathetin on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:51AM (#1819015)
why should Oracle do that? Do you know any bank or company that runs Oracle on Macs??????? I don't see any reason for Oracle to maintain java on this platform. We understand that oracle only moves its butt, if moving the butt makes cash. Does anybody know whether they make cash out of java on Macs?

Even if Oracle would provide java, would anybody put so much trust into Oracle, to base the future of his/her software company onto this? Apple again has proven to be unreliable.

I think, this is a serious blow either for java or for Apple itself. Probably we may have to fall back to c, fortran or delphi?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by kls on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:43AM (#1819444)
Do you know any bank or company that runs Oracle on Macs

No, but I do know a lot of developers that write Java code that runs on banking infrastructure, that do.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by mithaler on Friday October 22, 2010 @10:04AM (#1819716)
That doesn't bode well. Isn't a large part of the appeal of a Mac that everything "just works"? How do you suppose sysadmins will now feel if banking infrastructure apps no longer "just work" and will now require an additional JVM to be installed from elsewhere and kept up to date through separate channels from Apple's?
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by jonhendry on Friday October 22, 2010 @12:06PM (#1820164)
I expect they'll get along just fine, the same way companies rely on, say, VPN software where updates are distributed from the vendor's website rather than the OS vendor's website.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by grhino on Friday October 22, 2010 @11:11AM (#1819954)
I'd actually be curious to know of any banks that use Mac servers.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by riffraff on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:10AM (#1819530)
it does sound more likely that a java dev on a mac gets a windows install as a second boot option than he changes the bank's infrastructure though :)
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by jonhendry on Friday October 22, 2010 @12:11PM (#1820183)
Or they could do their development on Windows or Linux in a VM. Or via VNC or the Windows equivalent.

At the last big Weblogic project I worked on, the (many) developers worked on Windows in VMs, on Windows boxes. One advantage being that we could use VM images pre-configured with Eclipse and whatnot set up just right.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by foljs on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:03AM (#1819502)
Even if Oracle would provide java, would anybody put so much trust into Oracle, to base the future of his/her software company onto this? Apple again has proven to be unreliable.

Yes, because as we all know, SUN has been a bright example of RELIABILITY in regards to Java et al...

The collapse of SUN, the Swing for the Desktop/JSF/Java FX fiascoes, the Oracle takeover and the recent JCP fights, totally inspire confidence in Java...

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by aufreak3 on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:41AM (#1819639)
Although a part of me thinks all this FUD, I can't help be concerned about this situation. Here is one more possibility - what if the dev tools now require you to pay an annual fee to even download them?

gcc is GPL, so they can at best make it difficult to get them free, but clang is racing ahead and it is BSD.

I just hope that my faith in Apple that they won't do something ugly like giving free dev tools when they needed developers and switch to charging for them when they got the app market they wanted.

I think there is now room in the market for a company with good design sense to make Ubuntu machines!

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by matwood on Friday October 22, 2010 @10:33AM (#1819817)
I'm surprised at the generally positive approach in HN toward Apple's recent announcements. Apple is about to have control over the user's system no one since mainframe-era IBM ever came close to.

Not only they're about to move desktops/laptops into the App Store's walled garden, they are showing they can drop support for major technologies like Java or Flash if they feel like it. This is not good news for anyone but Apple, certainly not anyone calling themselves "Hacker".

The problem is that you're jumping to some serious conclusions. Nothing about the mac app store demo showed banning of applications from a different source. You're assuming that's their plan, but I don't think it is. The app store makes perfect sense from an end user perspective. One of the great things about linux are the package managers. A central location with lots of software that I can install from AND get updates from.

There is no flash on the iPhone for many well document reasons, so I'll guess you're referring to no flash on the new MBA. Given that any version of flash is out of date and a huge security hole as soon as it's installed, it makes complete sense to force users to go get the latest version when they buy their machine. It wasn't long ago that the shipping version of flash on osx had a huge security hole that made Apple look bad.

What I would like to see if Apple let Adobe put their flash player into the new mac app store. This lets Adobe manage the updates like any other 3rd party developer.

As a 'hacker' I look at what is. Right now my MBP works great and has all the support I need. If Apple does end up going down the path of locking out all other software and/or the ability to hack and develop I'll switch back to linux. At this point though, it's much ado about nothing.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by pilom on Friday October 22, 2010 @07:38AM (#1819286)
How is the Mac app store any different from Ubuntu's? With both platforms, you can install other programs not in the store. Both of them automate the install and update process for applications. Both of them (now) allow you to pay for apps.

I'm confused by people being upset with the mac app store when FOSS has been doing the same thing for years with package management software. Heck, Cydia is even based off of a *nix package manager.

I don't want to call it fanboyism because I know you have other reasons for disliking their new app store but after seeing how well it works in Ubuntu, why could this possibly be a bad idea?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by mirkules on Friday October 22, 2010 @03:21PM (#1821085)
I never used Ubuntu's store, so my natural question is: do applications have to get approved in Ubuntu's store? If the answer is"no," it may be the biggest difference with the most impact on end-users and developers.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by pohl on Friday October 22, 2010 @07:42AM (#1819294)
What is it about your personal definition of the word "hacker" that leads you to believe that all such people would arrive at the same opinion about this? This is a popular, growing, and interesting platform. It has APIs, languages, and tools. It's Unix and has a CLI. There is money in them thar hills...why wouldn't there be room for more than one hackerly opinion on the matter?
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by DougBTX on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:02AM (#1819138)
If the forum was still called "Start-up News", I don't think you'd be able to point out a contradiction. The App Store has made it significantly easier to sell software made by small developers to iOS users, they are about to make it really easy to sell to Mac users too. It's a business opportunity. The worst you can say about it is that commercial software is catching up with ease of distribution of free software.

Hey, you've got 90 days to ship a competing app store for the Mac. Valve has already done so with Steam on Windows and Macs, it isn't insurmountable. What's going to make your one better than theirs?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by protomyth on Friday October 22, 2010 @10:05AM (#1819719)
From someone who works with a OS X software company, the announcement was great. I am really not worried about OS X being closed because of development needs and the server version.

Not shipping Flash on the MacBook Air was pretty understandable given the noise Adobe made about the OS X 10.6 release version of Flash. The whole build & release cycle seems to take longer than it takes Adobe to patch Flash. So, it is probably a good thing to train users to go to Adobe's site and get the newest Flash.

Dropping an Apple version of Java will probably be a good decision and actually help Java developers. If Oracle is actually taking over then OS X will most probably (given Oracle's catalog of OS X software) be at the same version as all the other platforms instead of the current delay.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by slantyyz on Friday October 22, 2010 @11:33AM (#1820023)
Another reason to not ship Flash is that by the time you install the OS, the version of Flash is usually outdated and you've got to install the update anyways.

Every time I reinstall an OS, Mac or otherwise, I find myself having to update Flash. If I've got to do that, I may as well install from scratch.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by roqetman on Friday October 22, 2010 @07:58AM (#1819331)
You can still install it yourself... both Windows and Linux don't come with it already installed. I think that that is Jobs's point - if they bundled it, it was out of date by ship-time.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by palewery on Friday October 22, 2010 @07:04AM (#1819221)
Have you used VMware Fusion 3.0. It is quite fast and integrates well with OS X and MBP hardware. I use a MBP as my workstation and a Fedora VM for development in the MBP.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by kls on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:46AM (#1819450)
I dumped it for Virtual Box. As good of a product and free.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by palewery on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:54AM (#1819474)
I wondered if they had some decent competition. The upgrade from fusion 2.0 to 3.0 was $10.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by kls on Friday October 22, 2010 @09:00AM (#1819491)
If the upgrade would have been $10 when I made the decision I would have staid, but it was not when I decided to make the switch. Oh well, I have moved on now.
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by j_baker on Friday October 22, 2010 @12:46PM (#1820356)
1. Unless the Mac app store takes away your ability to install apps that aren't in it, I wouldn't be too worried.

2. They're not dropping support for Java, they're just not making it anymore. If Oracle makes a version of Java for the Mac, then it will be supported. If not, then losing Java must not be that big a deal right?

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by robomc on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:44AM (#1819004)
I left OSX for Ubuntu earlier this year because I felt this was the direction things were going, and I didn't want to wake up on kid's computer in 3 years.

BUT you could argue that the announced OSX features are more or less Ubuntu Software Center + some bits of Gnome Shell.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by nir on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:49AM (#1819008)
Definitely - but watching Apple's current iPhone/iPad policies, which direction seems more likely?
Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by ugh on Friday October 22, 2010 @08:43AM (#1819445)
It is very unlikely that Photoshop will be available on the App Store and there is no way Apple is going to ditch Photoshop (or many other applications which are unlikely to ever end up on the App Store like Office and AutoCAD, both of which Apple lauded in their press event).

The status quo is powerful. There was no status quo on phones, that’s why Apple could just come up with one. It would not be in Apple’s best interest to change the rules so radically on the Mac.

It don’t know what Apple will do in a decade but I’m fairly confident that there will be no rapid change in what Apple allows you to install on your Mac. Steve Jobs already said that you will be able to install whatever you want on OS X Lion which keeps OS X safe at least until about summer 2013. I think it’s a bit premature to complain now.

Re:Email from Steve Jobs re: Java and OS X by shareme on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:44AM (#1819005)
I think yo are confusing desktop and mobile environments..

Steve Jobs did not outlaw manual installs of any software on desktop Macs..he just made the MacApp store feel Boutique or exclusive to consumers..