Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by wp381640 on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:19PM
(#18186959)
Is South Africa's situation really that unique when most of the world isn't at war with a neighbour?
If anything, the situation in Pakistan, North Korea, India, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Israel etc. are the unique cases - that is essentially a whose-who of regional conflicts
Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by mandevil on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:55PM
(#18187324)
South Africa dismantled their program because the ruling white minority- watching de Klerk negotiate with Mandela to end Apartheid- didn't trust the ANC (read: Nelson Mandela) to have nuclear weapons. Absent that political handover, I'm not sure that they would ever have dismantled the program. It is hard to destroy military-industrial bureaucracies, once created and given resources.
Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by wp381640 on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @02:00PM
(#18187374)
I know - but that wasn't the argument being made
Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by sangnoir on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @03:29PM
(#18188092)
It is relevant though, because the political calculus between South Africa and its neighbors changed with the handover to the ANC. There were a lot of skirmishes between South Africa's apartheid government and its neighbors that supported/harbored the ANC military wing. Asking why South Africa developed nukes in the first place and why it voluntarily gave them up can provide a useful template for denuclearization.
Aside: the fissile material is still stockpiled and there was a break-in attempt at the storage facility a few years ago
Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by macintux on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:25PM
(#18187034)
I'll grant that most of the world is at relative peace, but as long as a few feel that their existence is at risk, it will be nearly impossible to get rid of nuclear weapons, which was the original point.
South Africa shows that a country can get rid of its weapons, but it's not a particularly relevant example to those that still have them, or are likely to add them.
Re:Declassified documents show why the US and the USSR came ...
by kosievdmerwe on Wednesday October 10, 2018 @01:36PM
(#18187149)
There's also the point that a lot of countries aren't at war precisely because they and/or their opponents have nukes. If the nukes disappeared then so would the reasons for the cease fire.
They're not technically at war with a nuclear-armed power (North Korea). They're not faced with a neighbor with incalculable manpower advantages (India, Pakistan) or nuclear weapons (same).
Anyway, I would characterize South Africa as a unique situation vs a reason for optimism, but I'm also deeply pessimistic about nearly everything.