Re:Rust RAII is better than the Haskell bracket pattern
by agumonkey on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @11:17AM
(#18176608)
Maybe a randomized sparse zeroing ?
Re:Rust RAII is better than the Haskell bracket pattern
by toast0 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @11:59AM
(#18177035)
I'm not sure what a randomized zeroing would get you from a security perspective. You shouldn't need to be concerned about other programs observing the memory, kernels are expected to give programs only zeroed pages. If you're concerned about kernel level memory dumping, randomized zeroing isn't good enough -- it may or may not have zeroed your secrets, so that's not very helpful. Background zeroing doesn't help much here either -- FreeBSD sets a target of zeroing half the free pages, so your secrets may not be zeroed for a long time.
It seems the jury is out on the benefits from a performance perspective (DragonflyBSD took out background zeroing, saying they were unable to observe a performance difference, so simpler code is better)
Re:Rust RAII is better than the Haskell bracket pattern
by agumonkey on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:10PM
(#18177138)
Not much indeed but it might deter some low hanging leak hacks..
Re:Rust RAII is better than the Haskell bracket pattern
by Franciscouzo on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:19PM
(#18177241)
Why? When taking into account the cpu cache, branch mispredictions, etc, I bet it would be slower than just zeroing it, besides it wouldn't be secure at all, imagine a process that stores a secret key, and then releases the memory, if another process can trigger the first to generate and release the key memory multiple times, they would be able to read it.
Zeroing on exit would be more secure, but significantly slower -- you want to exit quickly, so you can potentially start a replacement program, which would be expected to, at least sometimes, take time to allocate the same amount of memory. If it does allocate the whole amount immediately, it's not necessarily any slower in total time between zeroing at exit or on mapping; but it there's enough time for the pages to get zeroed in the background, that reduces the amount of time waiting for the kernel to do things.