But then again, I'm HN's resident marketing ignoramus, so what do I know? ;-)
That's why it's a mistake. Existing users (the wrong people) hear the message much louder than potential users, and possibly in greater numbers.
These expectations are analogous to you being a paying member on some platform, and they announce a "30 days free" promotion for new members, and you demanding that you should get to participate in that promotion. Shenanigans.
And just because AWS is pay as you go doesn't make this any different.
It's a way of showing appreciation and that they don't take you for granted. Period. (sorry, I had to)
If you aren't negotiating better terms for recurring services, then you are giving money away. Promotions are just a nice bit of leverage in negotiations.
In comparison if you ask your internet provider to bump you up from 1mbps to 2mbps (or to lower the price from 50 bucks to 40) because they have a promotion for new users, and they give it to you, providing you sign a contract for another 12 months, is not equivalent to telling the internet provider that because they are offering a free year of service (up to lets say 5 gigs of downstream bandwidth) to new customers you should do to and without a contract specifying that you're staying with the company afterwards.
I think the most effective type of marketing will always be the personal recommendation from a current user.
It is not really alienation. They are investing money in converting people to their platform. Offering this to existing users makes no sense from that perspective. It is pretty standard across many industries to offer exclusive deals to new customers.