News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The down side to wind power by chki on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:16AM (#18147476)
>To estimate the impacts of wind power, Keith and Miller established a baseline for the 2012‒2014 U.S. climate using a standard weather-forecasting model. Then, they covered one-third of the continental U.S. with enough wind turbines to meet present-day U.S. electricity demand. The researchers found this scenario would warm the surface temperature of the continental U.S. by 0.24 degrees Celsius, with the largest changes occurring at night when surface temperatures increased by up to 1.5 degrees. This warming is the result of wind turbines actively mixing the atmosphere near the ground and aloft while simultaneously extracting from the atmosphere’s motion.

I am confused: How does the warming work exactly and is this actually a global climate effect? Because this part of the article makes it sound to me as if it's just a very localised change of temperature caused by the exchange of different air layers, which can't be right? Because you couldn't really compare that to climate change on a global scale.

Re:The down side to wind power by ams6110 on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:30AM (#18147560)
The example is clearly hypothetical only. We're never going to cover one third of the continental US with wind turbines.

The more important information to me is that neither wind nor solar have the power density that has been claimed.

For wind, we found that the average power density — meaning the rate of energy generation divided by the encompassing area of the wind plant — was up to 100 times lower than estimates by some leading energy experts

...

For solar energy, the average power density (measured in watts per meter squared) is 10 times higher than wind power, but also much lower than estimates by leading energy experts.

Then you have the separate problem that the wind doesn't always blow and the sun doesn't always shine, so you need a huge storage infrastructure (batteries, presumably) alongside the wind and solar generating infrastructure.

IMO nuclear is the only realistic alternative to coal to provide reliable, zero-emission "base load" power generation. Wind and solar could make sense in some use cases but not in general.

Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:53AM (#18147700)
>IMO nuclear is the only realistic alternative to coal to provide reliable, zero-emission "base load" power generation...

Yeah, but no one wants to pay for it. Which is why you'll see more wind and solar with hydro-storage, and even more geo-thermal energy plants in the future. Even with all the extra infrastructure, it still comes in at less than 2 or 3 cents a kwh long term. Whereas even if you take a very optimistic long term view on nuclear, it's just REALLY hard to get down below 3 cents. So for nuclear sources to get higher in the dispatch stack, government must take on more of the costs.

But then, of course, if government is taking on more of the costs, then you're still paying more than 3 cents. Probably a lot more. You'd just pay it in extra taxes instead of a utility bill. So, yeah, I guess that's why energy is a hard problem. No easy solutions really. Just hard to balance pros and cons to every known technology at this point.

(Maybe someday someone will figure out this whole fusion thing and we'll be able to consign all these other, less refined, technologies to history's dust bin?)

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:39AM (#18148461)
Time to build also matters. How long does it take to build a storage mechanism for a solar/wind farm, vs the time to build a nuclear plant? What are the reasonable regulatory requirements? (Lest anyone be complaining about the ignorant treehuggers stopping nuclear plants, I think we can all agree that a nuclear plant is potentially more hazardous than pile of batteries, and should be regulated proportionally.) What are the up-front capital requirements of nuclear vs solar/wind + storage?

Another thing people need to keep in mind is we don't need enough storage to run the entire grid indefinitely. We just need enough to smooth the curve out to four nines or whatever number is deemed necessary. And while "the sun isn't always shining and the wind isn't always blowing", the wind is always blowing somewhere.

Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:59AM (#18148654)
You wouldn't use batteries generally though.

For example, if you had hydro-storage, you'd use the power from the wind or solar to pump water into giant reservoirs. When wind or solar is unavailable, power is drawn from the hydro reservoirs by letting the stored water flow through turbines. (So a dam, basically.)

So, yeah, building reservoirs is pretty well defined. And would certainly take much less time than building a nuclear plant. (The cost would be orders of magnitude lower as well.)

Still has regulatory issues, just not nearly as many as dead batteries or nuclear power plants do.

Re:The down side to wind power by toomuchtodo on Saturday October 06, 2018 @01:42AM (#18153726)
"Solar With Batteries Cheaper Than Gas in Parts of U.S. Southwest"

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-09-17/solar-wit...

Tesla built the Hornsdale Power Reserve in under 90 days. Hydro storage is never going to be able to compete with that, and nuclear will never be able to compete with how quickly you can deploy wind and solar. Batteries are rapidly coming down in price, and will continue to do so as EV sales scale up (1 million EVs are sold every six months, and this cadence is increasing). There are no regulatory issues with batteries. You can ship them to a concrete pad and install them, no questions asked.

Re:The down side to wind power by pjc50 on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:28AM (#18148895)
There's not many geologically good locations for pumped storage, they tend to be a bit environmentally sensitive, and they're not that quick to build - the one nearest me, Cruachan, took 6 years to build in the 1950s at the reduced safety standards of the time.
Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:51AM (#18149087)
That's only one way that you would do hydro-storage these days though.

Think, for example, if you drill a hole deep into the ground, lower a cylinder into it, poke a hole in the bottom of the cylinder, then fill that cylinder with water. If I put a platform with a giant weight on top of it, the platform will press all of the water in the cylinder down through the hole in the bottom. That water will travel through a tube to the top of the cylinder and pour back into the cylinder on top of the weighted platform. In that tube, is where you capture the stored energy with turbines.

Then, when the wind picks back up, or the sun comes out, or power is just cheap even from the coal plant, you use that power to lift the platform back up and suck all the water back into the bottom of the cylinder.

Benefits of this are, as the HN User "beat" implied below, it's so cheap and simple to build that even a single, say, shopping mall might invest in it to lower their power draw from the grid. They would build one that only serves their mall for instance. You start to build out a truly distributed power storage infrastructure.

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:09AM (#18148719)
Oh, sure. There are all sorts of interesting ways to cache energy, besides batteries - hydro, gravity, compressed air, thermal, etc. Price, scale, and local constraints should create a rich market for a wide variety of solutions.

(As an aside, a sufficiently large hydro storage is its own regulatory problem.)

Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:22AM (#18148841)
>(As an aside, a sufficiently large hydro storage is its own regulatory problem.) ...

Yeah, but as I said in the comment, those regulatory issues are far less onerous than the regulatory issues with building a nuclear power plant. So the investment is less, the maintenance costs less, the kwh is less, and the time to market is less. Which technology do you think the big finance guys are gonna put their money into?

If you want money to go into nuclear plants, government has to agree to shoulder a lot of the risk. But there's drawbacks there too so...

yeah, just a hard problem.

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:38AM (#18148964)
That's why I think we'll see a lot of small-scale distributed storage, rather than giant industrial storage plants that match our current concept of the power grid. If you're running, say, a big box store, buying your own local storage for the store can make economic sense if it can pay for itself by buying dynamically priced energy. And then it doesn't need to be huge, because it's not trying to power a city, it's just trying to power your warehouse/store. A block of batteries, or a thermal system, or a water tower starts looking pretty attractive financially.
Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:54AM (#18149115)
I agree. A lot of these storage solutions are starting to be so cheap that it's not hard to see different sorts of players investing in them. The benefit being, as you rightly point out, distributed storage.

Such systems are "no-brainers" for entities like, say, hospitals.

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @12:06PM (#18149218)
As I mentioned elsewhere, electric cars turn into pretty good storage systems, too.

And with a smart distributed grid, it's not just storage that makes sense locally - it's generation. Put a solar roof on the big box store, attach a storage system, and have a mostly self-sufficient system. And if it's generating surplus, sell it! Buy only when it's needed.

Meanwhile, poor developing nations or rural areas that don't have the capital or the chops to build giant nuclear plants can easily invest in very small scale projects. Go to some remote village, put up a wind turbine and a compressed air tank you can just bring in on a truck. Now that village has power! It may not be as financially efficient long-term, but by increasing the potential productivity of remote areas, it can pay for itself easily at the local level.

It's an exciting thing to see.

Re:The down side to wind power by u320 on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:35AM (#18147961)
You're not going to be anywhere close to 3 cents in a 100% renewable system without hydro. Cheapest solar price in the US is 2.3 cents but that is in one of the sunniest places in the world, subsidised, and no storage.
Re:The down side to wind power by benjaminjackman on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:36AM (#18147975)
Whether or not fusion is possible (it seems like it is, just incredibly difficult and meticulous, unless the MIT-ARC project works out).

There is always the eventual option to harvest solar energy in space The primary limiting factor at the moment is obviously the insane price of rocketing stuff into space.

Perhaps even before that solar power could be harvested in the upper atmosphere on massive scale by being tethered to balloons, it might even have the benefit of counter-acting some of the effects of global heating.

Re:The down side to wind power by tremon on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:59AM (#18148647)
The primary limiting factor at the moment is obviously the insane price of rocketing stuff into space.

The people who are opposed to nuclear power because of the military proliferation risk might have something to say about the capability to transmit large amounts of power from space to the surface of this planet.

Re:The down side to wind power by bilbo0s on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:05AM (#18148693)
And you'd have to add to that objection the people who oppose nuclear power because of the costs. Those people would definitely be opposed to these ideas barring some new technological development that made space-based infrastructure several orders of magnitude less expensive.
Re:The down side to wind power by frgewut on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:24AM (#18147887)
I have started to view "baseload" generation more in a negative sense (as in "can't be easily turned on/off").

Also the daytime/nighttime power consumption differs almost twice, so almost any solar added only smoothens out the difference.

Also the new offshore wind turbines (>10MW) offer some extraordinary capacity factors (~60%). Makes me wonder what these capacity factors could be if we could get to 20MW turbines.

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:07AM (#18148705)
Traditional "baseload" plants are a product of cost and engineering. Nuclear and baseload coal plants are designed to deliver maximum power for minimum cost. Due to engineering constraints, this means that it's hard to scale the output up or down to meet changes in demand (hours? days?). So short-term demand is dealt with by "peaker" plants, which are very expensive. They're less efficient, and they aren't always in use, which means tying up capital in something you don't always need.

I think of solar/wind as a sort of weird baseload, with a wide variance in output that is not controllable and not always predictable in the short term.

Where I think we have a real opportunity is the application of modern software to this unpredictable power grid, by pricing power dynamically at a rate that matches the fluctuations in both supply and demand. At this point, building storage to stabilize the grid is arbitrage, a market imperative. Independent storage systems can buy power from the grid when it's cheap (sunny, windy days), and sell it when it's expensive (cloudy days with no wind and high demand). Then it's just a numbers game, and the market itself will provide the right amount of storage.

This gets more fun as electric cars become more and more common. Every electric car is just a big battery, right? Plug it into this smart grid, and you can make a few bucks using the same arbitrage as big power companies. Sell the power in your car!

Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:35AM (#18147965)
Why is nuclear capacity easier or less expensive to build than storage capacity for wind/solar?

Be sure you're not starting with a conclusion and working backwards to the data required to support it.

Re:The down side to wind power by KineticLensman on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:40AM (#18148983)
> so you need a huge storage infrastructure (batteries, presumably)

The approach in the UK is to build Combined Cycle Gas Turbine [0] stations rather than storage infrastructure, as CCGT can be spun up quickly if renewables aren't cooperating. When I checked this awesome dashboard [1] just now, 48% of the UK's power was CCGT compared with approx 12% wind solar, presumably partly today has been still foggy. On good days solar and wind get to 30%.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle

[1] http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/index.php

Re:The down side to wind power by westurner on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:37PM (#18151525)
> IMO nuclear is the only realistic alternative to coal to provide reliable, zero-emission "base load" power generation. Wind and solar could make sense in some use cases but not in general.

How much heat energy does a reactor with n meters of concrete around it, located on a water supply in order to use water in an open closed loop, protected with national security resources, waste into the environment?

I'd be interested to see which power sources the authors of this study would choose as a control for these just sensational stats.

From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17806589 :

> Canada (2030), France (2021), and the UK (2025) are all working to entirely phase out coal-fired power plants for very good reasons (such as neonatal health).

Would you burn a charcoal grill in an enclosed space like a garage? No.

Re:The down side to wind power by pjc50 on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:30AM (#18147558)
It is indeed a change in local surface temperature - that is, if you have a thermometer there, it will read 0.24 degrees higher (average across 24h) than it would if there wasn't a nearby wind farm. And yes it's apparently due to atmospheric mixing. I imagine it would have similar effects on crops, evaporation, etc as a global temperature rise.

The next question: should this be subtracted from the measurements of any weather station suitably close to a wind farm?

Re:The down side to wind power by qaq on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:23AM (#18147513)
Given climate fluctuations is 0.24 even meaningful? Also hard to imagine 100% being wind power.
Re:The down side to wind power by beat on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:41AM (#18148476)
It's good science to analyze the long tail, even if we will never be on the long tail, because those extreme questions can have meaning in less extreme conditions.