News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by _ZeD_ on Friday October 05, 2018 @04:56AM (#18146691)
illegal?
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by scrollaway on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:04AM (#18146722)
The wall needs a clear and visible opt out, as readily-accessible as the accept button. Instead, Slate redirects you to their privacy page. Their privacy page itself redirects you to https://slate.com/thirdpartypartners ... which is behind the GDPR wall.

And once you get behind the wall, it's a list of dozens of links, with individual opt-out from each service, on separate pages, separate domains.

In other words, you are forced to give consent before you are graciously told how to withdraw it from each individual advertising partners. You don't have a way to not give Slate themselves consent.

Yeah, it's illegal.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by crysin on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:50AM (#18148575)
It's only illegal if the EU enforces it, really, and it seems that the EU has no motivation to act on these obvious violators. It's been 4 months, and this violation is one of the most obvious and easily fine-able violations and yet nothings changed. Companies aren't scared, no one is doing anything differently, so until the EU actually proves they're interested in enforcing the text of the GDPR companies are going to continue acting like they're not in danger.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by skrebbel on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:05AM (#18146723)
, in some parts of the world.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by scrollaway on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:06AM (#18146725)
Please do reply to every single post mentioning the word "illegal" with "in some parts of the world". After all, nearly anything goes in international waters.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by skrebbel on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:32AM (#18147020)
Fair enough, you're right.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:20AM (#18146985)
It's not illegal.

If you don't like their terms you navigate away from their site. They don't have to provide you access to their contents if you refuse their terms.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by mirimir on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:33AM (#18147025)
See mattlondon's comment:

> Yeah I am not an expert at all on this, but I believe that you canont ask for consent in order to gain access to a service/content - the consent must be opt-in and must be freely given.

> "This means people must be able to refuse consent without detriment .... The GDPR is clear that consent should not be bundled up as a condition of service unless it is necessary for that service"

> Source: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Friday October 05, 2018 @06:38AM (#18147045)
That's always misunderstood.

A company is not obliged to allow access to its free contents if you refuse their terms. End of. This does not put anyone at a detriment.

The GDPR does not change that at all.

What you quoted refers to specific contract terms as exemplified in the link provided.

Edit: I wish people understood GDPR instead of acting childishly by downvoting...

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by rcxdude on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:23AM (#18147874)
A specific example of when consent is not a valid reasoning for processing personal information under the UK's interpretation of GDPR: "consent was a precondition of a service, but the processing is not necessary for that service"

https://ico.org.uk/media/about-the-ico/consultations/2013551...

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:35AM (#18164977)
This is free contents. You misunderstand what 'contract' and 'service' mean. And, as already said, a website that provides free contents financed by ads has a legitimate claim that consent is necessary.
Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by akvadrako on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:02AM (#18147744)
You are wrong, as has been explained to you above. I laid out the argument in more detail a few weeks ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17808789

Basically, you need consent to use tracking and consent isn't legal unless it's optional and independent. So it can't be tied to access.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:36AM (#18148429)
No, I'm not wrong.

The GDPR does not say that consent cannot be tied to access.

What was 'explained' to me stems from people who haven't read the GDPR and/or who do not understand the terms used.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by scrollaway on Friday October 05, 2018 @11:43AM (#18149013)
You have a fundamental misunderstanding of what Slate is doing.

Slate is not saying "You can only access this if you give us consent". There's a few media sites that do that, and they're not breaking the law. No, Slate is saying "You can totally opt out... look...", and not following the proper opt-out rules.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:38AM (#18164999)
I understand what they are doing and it is fine.

The hard opt out is not to consent and to navigate away from the site. That's fine.

The second opt out is to withdraw consent. Obviously this means that you consent but are free to withdraw your consent as a later date. Which is what the GDPR requires, and that's also fine.

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by mirimir on Friday October 05, 2018 @09:24AM (#18147884)
The example in the page that I cited concerned Internet commerce sites. As I read it, you can't refuse to sell stuff if customers decline being tracked.

So are you arguing that providers of "free" content are allowed more leeway in refusing service for users who decline to be tracked? Do you have a cite for that?

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by ElBarto on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:37AM (#18148434)
> Do you have a cite for that?

The GDPR?

Re:In 1979, a chain email about science fiction spawned the ... by mirimir on Friday October 05, 2018 @05:37PM (#18151939)
Maybe a page or section number would help.