News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by mcargian on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:53PM (#1813659)
After several generations of netbooks, people are still pining for optical drives for the one or two times a year you wish you had one? I'd much rather the smaller form factor and a USB key for data transfer.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by pmjordan on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:11PM (#1813700)
Yeah, absolutely, the optical drive is a waste of space almost all the time.

With regard to slow networking, I wonder if a gigabit ethernet/USB adapter like the Belkin F5D5055 would help. Obviously USB 2.0 maxes out at around 30-35MB/s, but if the adapter can actually attain those speeds it should be fast enough when you need a bit more than Wifi.

Generally, I'm very tempted to go for the maxed-out version of the 13" MBA. I'll probably take a look at the screen at a retail store though, I'm not keen on the glossy finish, and my old 2006 MacBook has terrible angle dependent colour representation. Going to make this the motivator for launching my first product. :)

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by modeless on Thursday October 21, 2010 @02:57AM (#1814549)
If you have a quality 802.11n AP then WiFi is actually faster than 100 Mbps Ethernet, making a USB 10/100 Ethernet adapter pointless. That speed isn't theoretical; I'm in a high-rise apartment building and I can see 25 other SSIDs from my couch, but I still have no problems getting >100 Mbps from an AirPort to a MacBook.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by pmjordan on Thursday October 21, 2010 @04:19AM (#1814701)
Yep, if you manage to connect at a nominal 300Mbit/s on Wifi, you can just about scrape 100Mbit/s in practice. You basically need a 40MHz band of 5GHz Wifi, which is probably what you're using, and which is why it's not interfering much with the other APs, most of which probably only broadcast in the 2.4GHz band. Also, the number of available frequency slots in the 5GHz band is much bigger. Too bad the older iPhones don't support it, and most APs can't use both bands simultaneously (current Airport Extremes do!).

Still, that's 3-4 times slower than USB (in theory).

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by weaksauce on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:08PM (#1816407)
There is also the protocol overhead associated with each type of communication. USB and ethernet were created with different tradeoffs in mind. On a mildly contested network I believe that ethernet is about 60% efficient due to packet overhead and packet collisions.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by johnswamps on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:20PM (#1813729)
When I built my PC, I was having a problem hooking up my optical drive so I thought "I just want this to work now, I'll hook up the optical drive later". It's been over a year later and I still haven't connected it.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by andrewjshults on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:03PM (#1813828)
I had a very similar experience, although it ended up being that the only reason I didn't reconnect my PC's DVD drive is that I ended up using my macbook pro for ripping DVDs. If you live within the apple world (itunes) this becomes even less of a problem, but I still find having a DVD drive handy. Not to mention it was the only way I found to install the OS X version of diff.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by zmmmmm on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:41PM (#1813778)
The best thing about an optical drive in a laptop is that in many laptops it is a bay so you can easily rip it out and shove a hard drive in there. This is so much more convenient and fast for doing backups or migrating OSes, or just hedging your bets on disk size (small SSD + huge platter is a great combo). Of course, this wouldn't apply to a Mac ...
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by gbrindisi on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:58PM (#1813814)
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by PStamatiou on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:21PM (#1813870)
Yeah I used that optibay to put a second ssd in and raid it with my other ssd in my 17inch mbp. definitely worth it
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by stcredzero on Thursday October 21, 2010 @02:44AM (#1814536)
Someone needs to create a filesystem optimized for something like two heterogeneous drives, like a 64GB SSD and a 500GB HDD. It would try to put larger files on the HDD (where storage space and sequential read/write speed are useful and random-access less critical) and smaller files on the SSD (which has better random access). This would rock! You'd have a really zippy laptop with scads of space.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by pmjordan on Thursday October 21, 2010 @04:19AM (#1814703)
Working on a driver for this. Watch this space. :) (been trying to go fulltime on this, financial constraints have been holding me back; I have a partial prototype working on Linux, Mac OS X is the next target)

That said, there are existing solutions for this, they just suck, e.g.:

http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/products/laptops/laptop-hdd (only 4GB Flash, WTF?)

http://www.bit-tech.net/news/hardware/2010/02/03/silverstone... (this is just a dumb partial RAID)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReadyBoost (designed to work with USB sticks of all things, and isn't terribly smart about what to cache)

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by stcredzero on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:55PM (#1816643)
What about a daemon that migrates files over and symlinks them?
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by pmjordan on Friday October 22, 2010 @04:08AM (#1818948)
Brittle. Many apps will delete and replace a file when writing. Now you have 2 copies, 1 out of date. You'd be mildly better off with a union file system, but there aren't any good ones I can find.

Plus, that sort of file-based system doesn't cache file system structure/metadata, which is a major source of disk head movement.

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by Encosia on Thursday October 21, 2010 @06:41AM (#1814923)
I've found that it's beneficial to embrace the divide between a fast boot drive and a large data drive.

If you only store your OS and programs on the boot drive, space isn't a big concern and you gain a lot of flexibility. It's less hassle to repave the OS, migrating your data to new machines is simple, and it's easier to upgrade the boot drive as faster ones are available. That's especially nice with SSDs because you no longer have to care very much about the write limit. If my SSD boot drive wears out, I have 0 data recovery/restoration to worry about.

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by stcredzero on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:15PM (#1816443)
I've found that it's beneficial to embrace the divide between a fast boot drive and a large data drive.

I'm thinking of it myself, but I also thought it out further and concluded that it could be completely automated. In my case, if one just kept all files larger than 100MB on the HDD, that would be enough. Better still, I could specify certain directories to be kept on the HDD. I could do all of the above with symlinks, but setting that up once and getting the desired result automatically could be even better.

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by pyre on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:07AM (#1814566)
The issue being that by the time such a filesystem became stable enough for people to trust it with their data, SSDs may have already caught up to HDDs in terms of storage capacity.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by ryanpetrich on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:46AM (#1814634)
ZFS has the ability to use SSDs as cache for larger HDDs (which is close to what you've described)
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by stcredzero on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:25PM (#1816501)
I could accomplish much the same thing with a daemon that migrated the files for me.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by there on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:19PM (#1813868)
on my thinkpad x301, i have a second battery installed in place if the dvd drive.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by eddanger on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:38PM (#1813773)
Very true indeed. I can't remember the last time, if at all, I have used the optical drive on my computer. Over the last few years I've migrated all my music CD, and movie DVD to digital format. I no longer own a DVD player (attached to my TV), nor do I plan on getting a BluRay player. Ah, the age of digital media has arrived.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by jonsen on Thursday October 21, 2010 @05:26AM (#1814801)
CD and DVD are digital media.
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by eddanger on Thursday October 21, 2010 @07:36PM (#1817914)
True indeed. I suppose I should have said "non-physical media"... Don't get metaphysical on me now :)
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by ugh on Thursday October 21, 2010 @07:46AM (#1815037)
The big question is whether the next generation of MacBook Pros will also drop the optical drive or whether they will wait another year or so.

The optical drive has been very much neglected by Apple: there is no Blu-ray drive in any Mac they sell. Removing all optical drives in the next year or so certainly wouldn’t surprise me. (I actually hope that they will do just that. I’m going to buy a 15" MBP next year and I sure would like it to be a bit lighter and with a somewhat bigger battery.)

Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by sigzero on Thursday October 21, 2010 @08:24AM (#1815113)
Apple doesn't like Blu-ray (at this point in time) so I don't think they are neglecting anything (from their point of view).
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by ugh on Thursday October 21, 2010 @11:21AM (#1815802)
Let me put it this way: Apple doesn’t seem to believe that Blu-ray will be a standard storage medium for computer users in the next decade or so like DVDs and CDs were before. That might be the reason why they are not exactly eager to ship their computers with a Blu-ray drive. That assessment rings true to me. I might buy a Blu-ray player for my TV but I don’t think I really need it for my laptop. (I might want to watch something on a Blu-ray disc but I’m actually kind of tired of all that physical media. I bought my last CD 18 months ago and my last DVD something like two years ago. I don’t really know how true that is for the rest of the world, though.)
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by allwein on Thursday October 21, 2010 @10:19AM (#1815451)
My dream MBP is that they drop the optical drive completely, install 128GB of flash for a system drive like the new Airs, and then have an optional 500GB data drive for those who need the additional space. Then they can use all the saved space to either make it lighter or fill it with extra battery (or both!)
Re:Marco Arment: The new MacBook Air by stevenp on Thursday October 21, 2010 @12:26AM (#1814281)
It's interesting -- I got an OptiBay mounting kit for my 17" MacBook Pro, and now I've replaced the optical drive with a 1TB extra hard drive, in addition to the 256GB SSD I've already got. It's awesome to be able to carry my entire iTunes library with me wherever I go. The few times I've needed the optical drive, OptiBay includes an enclsoure for you to put the SuperDrive into, so I just plug it in via USB and I'm good to go. Never been happier with my super-fast machine.