News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by kazinator on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @02:33PM (#18133285)
I see nothing wrong with: selling something if a paying market is found for that, instead of giving it away for free.

I do see something wrong with: creating that paying market by lying.

I suspect most of those conscientious people who think they are helping farmers and reducing food waste would not be paying for this produce if they knew that it was being taken away from poor people.

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by bunderbunder on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:36PM (#18133992)
That's roughly in line with my experience using one of these services.

It really wasn't much of a money saver for us, especially after factoring the delivery fee into account. Worse, it was a terribly inconvenient service. We'd need to place our order the better part of a week before our delivery date, which really threw a monkey wrench into our weekly meal planning. And, for anything that was sold by unit rather than by weight, we had no way of knowing how much food we were actually buying - sometimes you'd get a 2lb head of cabbage, sometimes you'd get a 1/2lb head of cabbage. Again, really threw a monkey wrench into our meal planning. The box wouldn't necessarily contain everything we ordered, either. Which really. . . you get the picture.

I wouldn't have considered it a service that was even the slightest bit compelling, if not for the whole pitch about saving food from the landfill. If that turns out to be inaccurate or exaggerated, that really does kill the whole value proposition as far as I'm concerned.

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by gowld on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @02:41PM (#18133382)
In that case, you should never buy anything, because anything manufactured might be donated if you hadn't bought it.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by kazinator on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:29PM (#18133924)
Anything manufactured, non-perishable that is donated will just be flipped online for a profit. If it still doesn't sell when being flipped, then that confirms that it absolutely is junk that nobody wanted.

I'm just opposed to the lying; don't tell me that unsold goods are going to the landfill if they are really being donated. I will still buy it; I'm not going to join some hand-out lineup to try to get it for free, which won't even happen if the stock moves.

The overriding problem with the analogy is that we can't compare manufactured goods for which there is a demand to stigmatized produce that is viewed as inferior and met with low demand.

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by azrael49 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:11PM (#18133742)
In the majority of cases, retailers trash their products (sometimes after physically destroying them) that go unsold. Even for used items, most people are too lazy to donate even things in perfect condition
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by grawprog on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:21PM (#18133850)
Yup. Canadian Tire does this. They have a fence around their returned product smashing area. Any product returned that's not resellable is smashed and thrown away. And their criteria for what's resellable is fairly strict. Most returns just end up smashed. Employees aren't allowed to take or even purchase at a discounted rate or anything. It's just obliterated and trashed. I know someone who used to work there. Employees had ways of taking things(however you feel about it...i understand it's to stop scamming and such but I still feel like it's better than just trashing perfectly good things.). But they still destroyed hundreds of perfectly good stuff while they worked there.

I gotta admit the grocery store I worked at back in the day was pretty good. They left their old produce for people with animals to take. Employees could take expired stuff that was still good but going to be thrown because it was past the date.

I dunno I don't like wasting things that are good. There's always a better solution than just throwing things away and destroying them.

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by kazinator on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:35PM (#18133982)
Problem with unsold stuff is that people don't want it at any price. Even poor people. Before stuff is unsold, it goes on sale for 50% off, or maybe 75% or more. Poorer people can afford it at those lower price points.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by GFischer on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:15PM (#18134412)
Not always true. Some companies will rather destroy product rather than undercut themselves (it's a conscious strategy, especially for luxury items).

https://theoutline.com/post/2602/clothing-companies-are-tras...

http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2010/01/07/why_hm_destr...

I guess that's why some of those startups that tried to create an "exclusive" outlet prospered (Gilt Groupe, Vente Privee).

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by baq on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:33PM (#18135008)
in my country, you need things destroyed and have a paper confirming that or there may be negative tax implications. it's stupid.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by ajkjk on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:14PM (#18133776)
That's hyperbolic and absurd. The objection is against the deceptive marketing.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by retsibsi on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:46PM (#18136459)
More like: if unsold X is given away to people who need it, don't buy X with the goal of reducing waste. And if your other possible motivation is to help the producers of X, bear in mind that there is another group with conflicting interests.

(But it doesn't sound silly if you summarise it accurately, does it?)

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by dwaltrip on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:10PM (#18134361)
This is a strawman. Not great for productive discussion.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by thinkloop on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:20PM (#18133840)
> conscientious people who think they are helping farmers

But they are helping farmers, they are giving them money they otherwise would not have gotten. Why should the burden of providing food for the needy solely come out of farmers' incomes?

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by bunderbunder on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:59PM (#18134257)
That one seems arguable to me. They are probably getting their food either from larger farmers, or from wholesalers.

The rate at which most people consume food is relatively constant, and it's a fair bet that people in these services' target market are more likely than most to get a lot of produce from smaller farmers at farmer's markets.

Meaning that it kind of depends on what you mean by "helping farmers". If you narrowly mean increasing the income of some set of farmers, yeah, sure. If you implicitly mean the small family farms many of us like to romantically think of when we use phrases like "helping farmers", nah, it's probably diverting money away from family farmers and toward bigger players in the industry. If you mean diverting more money toward farmers in general, that also seems doubtful - most people have a relatively fixed grocery budget, and these services are probably just shuffling around who gets a cut of it, and naturally keeping some of it for themselves. That suggests a good chance of a net decrease in the amount of money going to farmers of any size.

There's also an angle that's not-so-tacitly baked into the sales pitch: Less food wasted translates pretty directly into less economic demand for food to be grown.

Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by emiliobumachar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:51PM (#18134153)
Agreed. Also, the claims for environmental benefits were fake if those were never being thrown out in the first place.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by cwkoss on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:11PM (#18134371)
Also, 'throwing out' or turning under viable produce is a good way to replenish soil nutrients. Imperfect produce is also further incentivizing the destruction of American soil quality.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by macspoofing on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @02:45PM (#18133440)
Nothing is taken away from poor people and nobody is lying about anything.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by kazinator on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @03:04PM (#18133678)
This is in fact the accusation made in the article, rightly or wrongly, in its simplest form.
Re:The ugly truth about the ugly produce movement by mcrad on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:16PM (#18134422)
Most marketing is borderline deceptive. I'd venture a guess that most of IP customers are eduacted enough to know that, and are buying the service based on its more tangible benefits (ie. not to save the world)