Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by colllectorof on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:04PM
(#18145192)
When people criticize post-structuralist academic studies in good faith, one of the most common counter-criticism is that they simply don't have sufficiently deep understanding of the subject, of its terminology, history and so on. At the very least these kinds of pranks demonstrate that no one has "sufficiently deep understanding" of this buzzword soup. People who think they have some secret knowledge or intellectual superpowers to parse the unparseable simply delude themselves.
Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by tptacek on Friday October 05, 2018 @12:03AM
(#18145667)
The papers that got accepted aren't "buzzword-soup". They're intelligible and in some cases include plausible methodological data. That's one of the things that's driving me so nuts about the prevailing narrative about this hoax: people think what these people did was "Sokal^2", but really it's log(Sokal).
Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by colllectorof on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:29AM
(#18147554)
The papers are exactly what one would expect from reading other types of postmodernist "critique". The whole reason reviewers missed the blatant absurdity of their thesis is because standard buzzwords of the field hide meaning. This is what Orwell warned us about in Politics and the English Language.
Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by tptacek on Friday October 05, 2018 @07:23PM
(#18152531)
Respectfully, I think what you're doing here is taking what you know about the Sokal hoax and applying it directly to this hoax. It's hard to blame you, since that's what the media did as well. But, while the papers we're talking about were fabricated and often did make ludicrous arguments, they weren't "postmodernist critique", and, as I said, many of them included data and plausible methodology. Orwell wouldn't have much to say about them.
Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by Tomte on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:33PM
(#18131942)
Matt Might.
Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by tptacek on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:41PM
(#18132041)
D'oh. Thanks. Too late to edit.
(Amusingly, they also print quotes from the same reviewer twice on that paper, creating the impression that multiple reviewers responded positively to it; I'm not going to take the time to audit all their peer quotes, but I'll bet that's a trick they applied repeatedly.)
Another example: Hypatia is apparently quite well known in feminist studies. The authors got a paper accepted in Hypatia. The authors also suggested that Hypatia was "surprisingly warm" to a paper (actually, it turns out, an essay) that suggested that white men be forced to sit on the floor in chains in classrooms. What the write-up doesn't tell you is that that's not the paper Hypatia accepted; they accepted a much more banal paper about the legitimacy of academic hoaxes.
Another example: they highlight (and so does their press coverage) a paper that spins a section of Mein Kampf into a critical race/gender theory argument. What they don't say up front is that they tried this three times, once with a relatively serious journal, once with a journal with an impact factor of 1.1, and finally with a 0.8. It's the 0.8 that accepted them; the others rejected. In fact, academic science --- STEM included --- is littered with bullshit journals, but generating that fact as the result of their "experiment" wouldn't have made for such an interesting story.
Kieran Healy makes an interesting point about this on Twitter: it's probably easier to get totally fake papers accepted than real ones. Recall Matt Might's cartoon essay about PhD theses and the tiny dent any one paper makes at the boundary of a science. If you aren't constrained by reality, it's easy to generate a paper that seems impactful. Meanwhile, the whole enterprise of peer review relies on good faith: reviewers are donating their time, and for every paper published, there are many many more that had to be read and rejected.