Re:Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
by slivym on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:29AM
(#18129226)
>Yes (if by implausible you mean unconvincing). Reject and resubmit with more powerful statistics.
I should clarify here- I mean implausible by the standard of common sense, but backed up by the statistics presented in the paper, which was the case here.
Indeed there is nothing wrong with any concept. If they wanted to show some systemic bias they should also publish a study about how to train women like dogs to attack men.
> Reject studies that have implausible findings?
Yes (if by implausible you mean unconvincing). Reject and resubmit with more powerful statistics.
> or publish it and let people follow up and do their own studies
Indeed , like good software, you publish a barely functioning version and let others find the bugs /s
> authors are welcome to suggest anything that like as a result of their research
Not really, editors will often tone you down. Otherwise we might do away with peer and editorial review.
I think you are advocating for 'anything goes' publishing here. Sure but then these journals should not call themselves scientific, it's a travesty to co-opt that name to validate their existence. Which in the end proves the point the author makes.
The author clearly has an agenda here, that's why they re publishing a blog, not a "science journal"