News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by pdonis on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:01AM (#18127539)
> if all the current mass of the universe was in a small volume wouldn’t it have promptly created a black hole?

No, because it was expanding too rapidly. The usual intuitions about how much mass in how small a volume it takes to make a black hole assume that the mass is stationary, or nearly so.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by cryptonector on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:28PM (#18131869)
I like u/Retric's comment on this too:

> A second issue is in Time 0.0001 seconds the observable universe is only a 0.0001 light seconds radius which limits how much mass could form a black hole.

That is, if you imagine all that mass-energy springing into existence in a vast universe (but with every point much closer to each other than today), there was not enough time for all that energy to notice the gravity of the surrounding mass-energy density and collapse into a black hole. Add to that the expansion rate (inflation), and the extreme uniformity of the young universe (which means gravity would have been pulling every thing in all directions rather than "inward" towards a soon-to-be-black-hole-center), and a collapse was impossible.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by pdonis on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:58PM (#18132252)
> if you imagine all that mass-energy springing into existence in a vast universe

You can't; this violates conservation laws. In other words, there is no solution of the equations of GR that describes mass-energy springing into existence in a universe that was empty up to that point.

At the end of inflation, matter and radiation in the form we know them today (the quantum fields described by the Standard Model of particle physics) got a huge amount of energy pumped into them; but that energy did not come from nowhere. It came from the inflaton field--the field that caused inflation up until that point--so that energy was already there and there had already been plenty of time for its gravitational effect to be "noticed".

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by sulam on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:20AM (#18127597)
This matches a description I was able to find online. What that seems to imply though is that expansion was literally faster than light. Yes? No?

[edit] and it seems this is true and can be explained by the space-time matrix not being bound by light speed limits.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by pdonis on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:24AM (#18127612)
> What that seems to imply though is that expansion was literally faster than light. Yes? No?

No. No particle of matter outruns a light ray at the same location and moving in the same direction. Or, to put it another way, all pieces of matter are moving within the light cones at their spacetime locations. "Moving within the light cones" is the correct General Relativity version of "nothing goes faster than light".

The coordinate speed of pieces of matter can be greater than c, but in a curved spacetime that, in itself, is not a problem.

Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by cryptonector on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:30PM (#18131898)
The expansion of space is always faster than the speed of light if you pick any two points far enough apart from each other, at least as long as space is expanding and the universe is infinite. Or if the universe is finite, some time after the bang there will be points which separate faster than the speed of light from each other. These points aren't moving, of course.
Re:Black holes ruled out as universe’s missing dark matter by HeadsUpHigh on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @04:52AM (#18128605)
Yes it was. I think it's called the inflation period and is used as a possible explanation of why there are big voids in the universe.