News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by sgift on Monday October 01, 2018 @02:50PM (#18115642)
> He can afford the fines and does not care

That's the reason that a) fines should be a percentage of your net worth and b) escalating.

I'm pretty sure if the first 50 million go down the gutter he'll start to notice.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by aerophilic on Monday October 01, 2018 @05:14PM (#18116874)
While I don’t know I agree, thought I would mention Finland does this: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland...

It would be interesting to see how effective it might be...

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by jonny_eh on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:23PM (#18117324)
Even if it doesn't work, at least it would do a lot of good to take money away from such a jerk, and give it to the people.
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by gist on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:45PM (#18116116)
> a) fines should be a percentage of your net worth

Not an easy process to determine net worth of anyone let alone someone like Vinod. Most likely he does not even know his net worth.

For one, things that you own can vary greatly in value. Now multiply that by hundreds or even thousands of things that are owned by a wealthy person (I don't mean the furniture in the house either).

And it simply does and should not work that way. Because what that means is that someone who is poor and has nothing does not get dinged much because they are poor and have nothing (hence they have 'nothing to lose'). Sure you could adjust the penalties but just the same simply not the way it works.

Even Elon Musk, so big deal $20m fine for someone worth billions (non liquid of course). So what is the correct 'fine'? And what if he was in bankruptcy? Then what is the correct fine?

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by NeedMoreTea on Monday October 01, 2018 @05:21PM (#18116928)
Simply adopt the Finnish model - everyone's tax return is public, and fines are based on income in your last return. I think Sweden operates similarly.

$100,000 speeding fine anyone? http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/1759791.stm and that was in 2002!

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by charlesdm on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:14PM (#18117263)
Ridiculously flawed system in itself, as income can easily be faked. In this case, he's a well paid executive that receives most of his income as income.

However, the genuine wealthy will receive most of their income as capital gains and dividends, and will hold most assets through companies.

Income wise, they are often paupers in comparison to their (true) net worth.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by everdev on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:39PM (#18117413)
An entrepreneur might make a few million one year selling a company, then almost nothing for a few years after if they take a break. Maybe average the last ten years of income to get a better picture?

Either way, it's not perfect. Hundred dollar speeding tickets are brutal for low income families.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by NeedMoreTea on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:56PM (#18117499)
There are usually consequences like imprisonment, or additional higher fines, for lying to the tax authorities. So faking your income on a tax return may be considered high risk. It's perfectly possible to consider dividends income as the UK mostly does, and maybe include capital gains as well to arrive at an overall figure for the year after allowances and indexation.

No system is perfect, but seems far less flawed than prescribed fines that sees a millionaire barely notice a £100 parking fine, but someone on minimum wage almost getting wiped out by the same. To me it;s crazy not to reference income, ability to pay or worth when assessing penalty.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by gist on Monday October 01, 2018 @07:07PM (#18117558)
> everyone's tax return is public, and fines are based on income in your last return

Not unusual for business people or anyone to have varied income from year to year but also that does not relate to actual assets or (the original point 'net worth' which is ironically a better measure of what you can pay (assumes liquid of course..)) Also what about someone with an inheritance or trust money?

Once again with the speeding fine it seems oppressive for the same 'crime' to charge someone $100k because they have income or assets and have that money to pay.

Also from what I read the Finnish system is legacy and the way it has always been. There is a big difference in that as people grew up with it vs. in the US where it would be something newly done. Forget even the revolt that would happen. It would also (once again here, because not legacy) lead to inflation as people would all the sudden quite possibly think they are underpaid next to someone else.

Now in the US many pay checks are public but people aren't typically keyed into checking the data source because it's a bit obscure and not a regular stop (key point by the way 'out of sight'). So for example if you work in NYC and you find out a trash man makes $90k per year and you make $60k you are going to feel shortchanged possibly. Once again that info is public (and the amount with overtime can be that btw) but not usually something people are accustomed to thinking about.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by dagw on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @03:49AM (#18119536)
Not unusual for business people or anyone to have varied income from year to year but also that does not relate to actual assets or (the original point 'net worth' which is ironically a better measure of what you can pay (assumes liquid of course..)) Also what about someone with an inheritance or trust money?

The tax people already have methods for dealing with all those scenarios for tax purposes, so it's essentially a solved problem.

Once again with the speeding fine it seems oppressive for the same 'crime' to charge someone $100k because they have income or assets and have that money to pay.

At least the way it works in Sweden, many fines are defined essentially in days wages and not in money. So the judge doesn't sentence you to pay $100k, they sentence you to pay 45 days wages[0] and the judge neither knows nor cares what that works out to be in actual money. So as such the fines are exactly the same for everybody.

[0] The actual formula is slightly more complicated that literally your daily wage.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by gist on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @03:35PM (#18124967)
> the way it works in Sweden, many fines are defined essentially in days wages and not in money. So the judge doesn't sentence you to pay $100k, they sentence you to pay 45 days wages

So explain how that makes sense because it doesn't take into account the savings of the individual?

If I have a million in savings and I am retired or how do you determine 'wages' with a self employed person?

I am not saying there aren't ways to answer or address this. But it is not simple and not fair the way stated other than a revenue scheme for the government. If the idea is to create a disincentive that has not been done using daily wages.

(Some people live hand to mouth as well so they are particularly impacted)

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by int_19h on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @03:41AM (#18119507)
> Once again with the speeding fine it seems oppressive for the same 'crime' to charge someone $100k because they have income or assets and have that money to pay.

Of course it is, and that's by design. The fine is supposed to be punitive, to act as a deterrent. Punishing someone is oppressing them like by definition.

The flat fee system, conversely, is just setting a price sticker on violating the law. It's literally saying, "you can do this if you're rich enough".

The proportional fine system has its issues, but between the two, I think it's a no-brainer.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by tw04 on Monday October 01, 2018 @05:09PM (#18116835)
That all presumes there's no way around the fine. If he had no warning, sure all those things matter. For something that is extremely easy to comply with, and that he's intentionally not complying with: too bad? This isn't a one-time whupps. It's no different than a DUI - the first one sort of sucks, but not in a life-changing way. The 3rd one you're into some serious, serious shit. He should be at this point.
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by Eric_WVGG on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:50PM (#18116155)
All true, but lowballing would be effective enough.
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by 394549 on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:10PM (#18117243)
> Not an easy process to determine net worth of anyone let alone someone like Vinod. Most likely he does not even know his net worth.

Maybe it's not easy, but he definitely has the ability to figure out how much he's worth, even if it means he has to pay a team of accountants.

I think such a system would be workable if it mandated the offender provide a good-faith calculation of their net worth. They'd also be required to show their work, and be subject to harsh penalties if they were found to have deliberately cheated. This is basically how the tax system already works for income.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by charlesdm on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:43PM (#18117430)
This gets complex quickly. What if the property is owned by a company, which in turn is owned by a foreign foundation?

Does he actually own the property? Should he be personally liable for that fine because he lives in the property? Should the fine be assessed on the property value?

Plenty of questions unanswered, that likely require legislation at various levels in government.

I'm not saying it's not a good idea, but this requires more work than some people are assuming. Khosla will be dead before any proper legislation without viable loopholes gets enacted.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by jonny_eh on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:24PM (#18117330)
Fine, make it a percentage of the assessed value of his property.
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by throwaway5752 on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:15PM (#18116428)
You know if you really neglect your property and ignore fines long enough, a humble HOA can foreclose upon your house.

Given that this is clearly a pattern of illegal behavior not remedied by civil lawsuits, the state should use eminent domain and seize his property as necessary create the mandatory access and to prevent further illegal activity blocking access to public lands.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by fermienrico on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:15PM (#18117277)
I have a problem with HOA's. They're almost always run by the worst kind of people that you don't want to be around. They're almost always evil to the core and extend their powers beyond reason. I will never buy a house with a HOA.

There are countless stories on how they do more harm than good. I have so much disdain for them, I cannot express. Fuck HOAs.

Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by everdev on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:36PM (#18117397)
Why can't it be remedied by civil lawsuits? If this guy is restricting my access to a public beach I should be able to sue him, no?
Re:Khosla Rebuffed as Supreme Court Rejects Beach-Access Appeal by throwaway5752 on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:08PM (#18118532)
... this submission is about a civil lawsuit that has been appealed all the way to the Supreme Court. What you described has already happened, and he has lost and appealed up to the highest level possible under US law.