Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017)
by marcosdumay on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:05PM
(#18114564)
I read the GP as accusing the article of that old trick of making a point (that facts don't convince people) by dissertating about a different, just slightly related issue (how facts don't convince people). People do that a lot, even instinctively, as it saves both the labor of going out and gathering actual evidence and the risk of being called a liar.
Yet, after a quick dissertation on his point he goes out and does the same thing by arguing about the political views of the author...
Thus, I don't think your complaint is fair. You could complain about hypocrisy, but that's not productive. I do think he is correct in questioning the article premises...
Anyway, after seeing all the reaction to the GP, I'm inclined to think your point is also correct, about people turning things into identity politics too.
Yet, after a quick dissertation on his point he goes out and does the same thing by arguing about the political views of the author...
Thus, I don't think your complaint is fair. You could complain about hypocrisy, but that's not productive. I do think he is correct in questioning the article premises...
Anyway, after seeing all the reaction to the GP, I'm inclined to think your point is also correct, about people turning things into identity politics too.