News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:26AM (#18112307)
The question has political import but there is, of course, no way to write those in without someone skimming the article finding a way to call it a hatchet-job and refusing to consider it.

Perhaps we might call this another way facts don't change our minds: we can't be bothered to consider them if interspersed with even a mild statement of opinion that differs from our own.

Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by mrfredward on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:26AM (#18113486)
Without endorsing, titanix's view of the article, I have to say it's bothersome that all the political examples leaned the same way.

It's an article about confirmation bias, and while most examples were neutral, they only ventured into politics when it would confirm the biases of a left-leaning readership.

Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by klmr on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:50AM (#18113796)
> it's bothersome that all the political examples leaned the same way.

But they don’t: The article also cites the example of vaccine denialism which is much more pervasive on the political left (though they tie it back to Trump). As an aside I agree that it’s somewhat lazy that these kinds of articles always come back to politics. Then again, it’s hard not to discuss the Trump administration when talking about “post-truth”.

EDIT: apparently I was misinformed, vaccine denialism doesn’t seem to follow political leaning, though it does seem to follow political extremism (on both sides of the political spectrum), see [1]. But apparently my mistake is a somewhat widespread belief ([2]).

[1] https://theconversation.com/anti-vaccination-beliefs-dont-fo...

[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/20...

Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by Brockenstein on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:23PM (#18114141)
>The article also cites the example of vaccine denialism which is much more pervasive on the political left

Is it? Or is that how you perceive it? Because vaccine denialism as far as I've seen doesn't abide by political alignment. All it really takes is a poor understanding of science and history and living in a world where modern medicine has been so successful that vaccines are a victim of their own success. Where a lot of the people alive today, in the U.S., can't even comprehend even comprehend diseases being a real threat which makes vaccines seem kind of unnecessary.

Throw in some autism scares and any other BS you can manufacture and a plurality of people from all sorts of beliefs and backgrounds who buy into some wonkass bullshit out of fear and ignorance. And no political party has a lock on that demographic...

Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:47PM (#18114378)
I'd say it maps better to some political tendencies than others; by necessity American political parties are coalitions of a ton of tendencies with plenty of differences among them.
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:16PM (#18114056)
That stuff (and associated new-age health mumbo jumbo) has a lot more pull with hard-right guys than you'd think.
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by gravy on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:21PM (#18114113)
Well the article itself doesn't state that it's more pervasive on the left and just makes the link to Trump anyway. So it still actually does the lean the same way.
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by merpnderp on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:14PM (#18114037)
So you're saying they take an issue which is roundly described as wrong, vaccine denialism, state that it is much more pervasive on the political left, then without any irony, you state they didn't lean left even though they blamed this issue on Trump?

I'm going out on a limb and claiming that taking a left leaning fault in society and blaming it on Trump, does not count as a right leaning example.

Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by klmr on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:02PM (#18114535)
They don’t blame it on Trump though. And I’m not stating that they don’t lean left (and it’s likely that they do).
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:15PM (#18114044)
Lurking beneath the surface, I'm sure, is bewilderment at the Trump phenomenon by New Yorker readers. But nevertheless, the piece isn't a partisan screed.
Re:Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017) by marcosdumay on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:05PM (#18114564)
I read the GP as accusing the article of that old trick of making a point (that facts don't convince people) by dissertating about a different, just slightly related issue (how facts don't convince people). People do that a lot, even instinctively, as it saves both the labor of going out and gathering actual evidence and the risk of being called a liar.

Yet, after a quick dissertation on his point he goes out and does the same thing by arguing about the political views of the author...

Thus, I don't think your complaint is fair. You could complain about hypocrisy, but that's not productive. I do think he is correct in questioning the article premises...

Anyway, after seeing all the reaction to the GP, I'm inclined to think your point is also correct, about people turning things into identity politics too.