Within a couple of years the old sleazy alleyways were transformed into something that could easily compete with the Stanford shopping mall.
What structure are you talking about (that sits empty)? I have watched the evolution of downtown Palo Alto for 15 years - it's certainly not perfect, but I'm glad for the two new parking garages and generally feel the growth there has been handled ok.
My comment was more directed towards the process. Every plan is considered, reconsidered, viewed, and reviewed, many times by many people. And if a decision is actually reached, some group of concerned citizens will be formed to protest it.
My first example was Alma Plaza. My second example was the structure on the corner of High and University. I actually don't know the history behind the latter, other than that it has been an eyesore for years.
Perhaps a valid argument to my disheartened view would be that an area like Palo Alto is a finished painting -- every additional stroke requires careful consideration for the risk of making a wrong one. But I do wish that our city was able to innovate as quickly as the businesses that define this area. :)
As I referenced in my other comment, a great deal of China's ability to innovate in terms of real estate development comes at the cost of what we Westerner's would perceive as social rights. If Palo Alto decides that there are too many black or poor people hanging around a certain section of town, most of us would prefer (to put it, err, lightly) that the city not just kill them, boot them out of town, or snatch the property rights of the places they frequent and bulldoze them. But such behavior is precisely what permits the process to which you're referring.
There are some "tricks" to getting things done more efficiently in Palo Alto. For example if you ask every stakeholder their opinion ahead of proposing a change, you tend to get far less reviews, protest, etc. after the fact. There are folks here who really want to be included, but many more people who are satisfied knowing their concerns have been heard.
I think a lot of the developmental sclerosis affecting America comes down to the relative affluence of the people impacted by development. Poor Chinese may be just as unhappy about development, but the government can simply ignore them in a way the US government can't ignore its citizens. California is one of the most affluent states; it makes sense that development in CA is particularly difficult.
Where I live in Sunnyvale, the light rail system is barely quicker than bicycling. This slowness, along with a well-designed road network and free parking everywhere, makes public transit useless for anyone who owns a car.
(I've worked on systems that model land use in function of economics, demographics, transport and environmental factors for almost 10 years now, my wife has a PhD on it, and so do most of the people (in those fields) I work with daily. I in no way claim to understand these processes, nobody does, but claiming to know that public transport was deliberately destroyed by special interest groups is intellectually dishonest.)
-----------------------
Apparently, we've reached the threading limit and I can't reply to your comment.
I don't think it's far fetched at all to say that the most powerful industries in the US would do, could do and did their best to ensure that roads and cities were constructed in a way that favored them. So, whatever.
I hadn't heard about these streetcars; so I looked it up. Wikipedia had a fairly comprehensive (for an introduction) article on it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_streetcar_scanda... . There's a whole section in there debunking the effects of the 'conspiracy', most of which sounds like (as a whole) a much more convincing explanation. Note especially that, according to one author, "nationwide, the ultimate reach of the alleged conspirators extended to only about 10 percent of all transit systems - sixty-odd out of some six hundred - and yet virtually all the other 90 percent also got rid of trolleys (as happened with all the tramcar systems in the British Isles and France)."
I have been visiting China frequently in the past years. Economic aspects aside, I still find the functional high-speed trains and rise of stunning skyscrapers simply fascinating. Perhaps the engineer in me admires it.
Here in Palo Alto, it took the bickering of multiple committees 6 years to decide what to build on a dilapidated, abandoned parking lot. And in the downtown, it has taken nearly 4 years to build a short structure that now also sits empty. And high-speed rail? Forget about it.