> We'll get to them eventually.. but why shouldn't we go after the biggest business first? Wouldn't that provide the greatest reduction in harm?
There's actually a name for laws that target one individual while ignoring others guilty of the same behavior, and that's a "bill of attainder" [0]. They're banned by the US Constitution and also every state constitution, which might give you some idea that there are pretty good reasons "why not" (namely, that they're ripe for abuse, they violate someone's right to due process, and can be used by the legislature to take on judicial or executive functions, violating the separation of powers).
"It's a bill of attainder if you go after Google for violating people's privacy unless you simultaneously — not later, but simultaneously — go after everyone for violating people's privacy" is exactly the same as "It's a bill of attainder if you go after me for X unless you simultaneously — not later, but simultaneously — go after everyone for X."
Whether or not you think they should be able to go after anyone for what Google is doing is a different question, but it's definitely not a bill of attainder to go after one party before others, which was the thing that was called a bill of attainder here ("We'll get to them eventually.. but why shouldn't we go after the biggest business first?").
To curry favor, some kind of quid pro quo. Aka a bribe.
You're comparing food and water to how a company does business in another country. These two things couldn't be more different. Does the US government also manage food and water in China?
> The better question is whether Google is acting as a monopoly
That's an entirely different question. The letter seemed to target the china problem directly, which is more about censorship than monopoly. If anything, monopoly is just being used as an excuse here.
> but why shouldn't we go after the biggest business first?
Isn't Apple bigger by most metrics?
> you haven't made a sufficient case that "favorites" are being played
I think the point is, if favorites aren't being played now, this sort of move incentives companies to suck up even more to lawmakers. If Google gets screwed for doing business in China while thousands of other companies get away with it, what kind of incentive does that show?
How a company does business "in another country" reflects back on its own country (and can even have repercussions beyond image).
Google is always free to relocate their headquarters to another country and quit receiving the drawbacks of being a US company of course (along with any benefits that come with them)...
>If Google gets screwed for doing business in China while thousands of other companies get away with it, what kind of incentive does that show?
For one it shows that "doing business in China" is not a single, concrete thing, but there are tons of ways to do "business in China", some harmful and some not, and that might even depend on the industry.
E.g. selling Cokes to China: no big deal. Selling arms to China: might need some scrutiny. Selling Search technology to China catered to assist censorship: ditto.
So, the right question is not "why single out Google while other companies also do business with China", but rather "are these other companies in the SAME kind of business with China?".
And I'm not even against Google working in China, or following their local laws. Just want to point out obvious argument flaws.
No, but the US certainly does regulate how companies can act in other countries, e.g. the FCPA.
> If Google gets screwed for doing business in China while thousands of other companies get away with it, what kind of incentive does that show?
It shows that the government believes some principles should be above making a quick buck.
It shows that congress believes cheap PR for them is above somebody else making a quick buck.
Completely irrelevant. There are no US laws against private companies building censorship tools in the US, let alone in China.
With Google, it seems pretty fair to consider them a Monopoly in several areas. They also appear to be well down the path to abusing their Monopoly(ies?).
Isn't that generally where regulators should become involved?
You want to break them up with anti-trust because they're a monopoly? Sure. Go ahead and investigate and figure that out.
You want to ... punish/regulate/? them because they do business in China? You may not like it, but I don't see under what regulation or law you can do that?
The best analogy is US companies that contract with sweatshops. There's actually not a lot I'm aware of that can be done in the US court system, outside of utilizing trade treaties that require adherence to certain labor regulations.
this question is answered in the parent post to:
>>>There are no US laws against private companies building censorship tools in the US, let alone in China
>>Not yet. Maybe there should be [a new law -- DenisM]. ;)
If the problem is deemed severe a new law could be made that restricts participation in "oppressive activities", however they are defined. This would be similar to "trading with the enemy" act [1], or to COCOM [2], or to terrorism-related financial restrictions, or to Iran / N Korea / Russia sanctions.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trading_with_the_Enemy_Act_of_...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coordinating_Committee_for_Mul...
Let us all discuss.
You do realize that Google doesn't do search business in China, right?
Yea, but I'm a big fan of regulated food, clean water and pollution standards. Upholding your obligations is a requirement to receiving the protection of the government as you conduct your business. It's a two-way street.
> Especially when it looks like this whole thing is Google specific.
The better question is whether Google is acting as a monopoly in the regulated domain or not, if they are -- then this isn't a relevant factor.
> What about all the other American companies doing business in China?
We'll get to them eventually.. but why shouldn't we go after the biggest business first? Wouldn't that provide the greatest reduction in harm?
> Or would this be a government mandate of a broad based American pull out?
There are already plenty of laws which make transacting business in China more difficult for US based companies. It's not as if it's laissez faire except for Alphabet Inc.
> Once government gets involved and starts playing favorites
I don't disagree, but you haven't made a sufficient case that "favorites" are being played or that other factors aren't more prevalent.