Re:Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company
by coldtea on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @06:55PM
(#18080952)
>You're comparing food and water to how a company does business in another country. These two things couldn't be more different.
How a company does business "in another country" reflects back on its own country (and can even have repercussions beyond image).
Google is always free to relocate their headquarters to another country and quit receiving the drawbacks of being a US company of course (along with any benefits that come with them)...
>If Google gets screwed for doing business in China while thousands of other companies get away with it, what kind of incentive does that show?
For one it shows that "doing business in China" is not a single, concrete thing, but there are tons of ways to do "business in China", some harmful and some not, and that might even depend on the industry.
E.g. selling Cokes to China: no big deal. Selling arms to China: might need some scrutiny. Selling Search technology to China catered to assist censorship: ditto.
So, the right question is not "why single out Google while other companies also do business with China", but rather "are these other companies in the SAME kind of business with China?".
And I'm not even against Google working in China, or following their local laws. Just want to point out obvious argument flaws.
How a company does business "in another country" reflects back on its own country (and can even have repercussions beyond image).
Google is always free to relocate their headquarters to another country and quit receiving the drawbacks of being a US company of course (along with any benefits that come with them)...
>If Google gets screwed for doing business in China while thousands of other companies get away with it, what kind of incentive does that show?
For one it shows that "doing business in China" is not a single, concrete thing, but there are tons of ways to do "business in China", some harmful and some not, and that might even depend on the industry.
E.g. selling Cokes to China: no big deal. Selling arms to China: might need some scrutiny. Selling Search technology to China catered to assist censorship: ditto.
So, the right question is not "why single out Google while other companies also do business with China", but rather "are these other companies in the SAME kind of business with China?".
And I'm not even against Google working in China, or following their local laws. Just want to point out obvious argument flaws.