News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walmart Requires Lettuce, Spinach Suppliers to Join Block... by x2398dh1 on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @07:36AM (#18074838)
Where does anything in this article or anywhere in the title does it say the word, "Decentralized?" Where are you getting that from?
Re:Walmart Requires Lettuce, Spinach Suppliers to Join Block... by Slartie on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @07:55AM (#18074954)
If it's not intended to be a decentralized system in the first place, the "blockchain" aspect is useless and turns from being a clever hack that allows to generate a certain level of trust from distributed participants, thus enabling the decentralization in the first place, to a marketing ploy that, if not just being lip-service but actually implemented, is a huge resource hog and severely reduces scalability and maintainability of the system without offering any benefits whatsoever.

Because of this situation it is natural to assume that a blockchain-based system must either have a decentralization aspect to it, or that the architects of the system are incompetent. And we don't want to assume there's such gross incompetence at IBM, do we? ;-)

Re:Walmart Requires Lettuce, Spinach Suppliers to Join Block... by undersuit on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @04:14PM (#18079830)
What if the biggest feature about using the blockchain isn't that it's an open ledger that resists tampering from untrustworthy agents but that it has lots of hype?
Re:Walmart Requires Lettuce, Spinach Suppliers to Join Block... by gutnor on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @07:53AM (#18074940)
I guess the "Blockchain" part.

Blockchain is a decentralised way to create trusted record without a trusted counterparty, i.e. centralised.

In this case, there is nothing decentralised, you need to go through IBM as with a regular system. Blockchain is only mentioned as marketing to convince you they are reliable. A bit how some hosting service tell you their are using S3 to convince you they are not going to lose your data.

edit: The problem is the title of the article that let you imagine there is some interesting blockchain tech being developed. Instead that's about as interesting as "Walmart uses SAP"

Re:Walmart Requires Lettuce, Spinach Suppliers to Join Block... by lozf on Wednesday September 26, 2018 @08:23AM (#18075138)
Being "peer-to-peer distributed" (aka "decentralized") is a fundamental part of the definition of what a blockchain is.

This article explains it well: https://berk.es/2018/09/19/the-private-blockchain-fallacy