It also has the added benefit of moving the Overton window towards authoritarianism. This puts anyone who uses sophisticated encryption to hide their communications squarely in the radical camp, making them easier to marginalize.
But I think such a feature would better implemented at the OS level! :)
Using this mechanism to achieve a chilling effect on activism has a huge detrimental impact on democracy.
We must be careful whenever a politician attempts to trade liberty for security - for fools who agree will soon have neither.
https://web.archive.org/web/20020802214412/http://www.oreill...
;)
Domestic surveillance seems to be an example of where democracy is completely circumvented.
If it means a loss for the major parties by having, say, an independent taking over, then both sides will start to listen.
However, that kind of activism is very hard work and you have to be prepared for the rest of your electorate to be blaise about the subject matter.
This is definitely the root problem of democracy of today. Lives are comfortable enough for most that they don't really need to care for these issues (until it's too late).
If we as a society (quite reasonably) conclude that our government should have access to criminals' communications, allowing savvy criminals to make use of "non-electronic backdoors" is obviously out of the question.
Anyone want to propose an enforcement mechanism? Maybe listening devices implanted in everyone, or just everywhere in our homes?