Re:I'm a Heart Doctor and Wary of the New Apple Watch
by toast0 on Saturday September 22, 2018 @06:10PM
(#18048276)
There has been a lot of recent research and recommendations for policy change around reducing the frequency of screenings for various things.
Time and data will surely tell if this type of ECG screening is helpful or harmful on a population level. Certainly, some people will get a secondary ECG indicating intervention is required, and the intervention will improve their lives. Others may have a negative result from the intervention, and may never have found their way into this intervention without this screening. For some, this screening indicating a problem but a full screening indicating nothing will drive persistent anxiety.
It is absolutely not the case that more medical intervention is an unqualified good, even ignoring the economic costs.
Time and data will surely tell if this type of ECG screening is helpful or harmful on a population level. Certainly, some people will get a secondary ECG indicating intervention is required, and the intervention will improve their lives. Others may have a negative result from the intervention, and may never have found their way into this intervention without this screening. For some, this screening indicating a problem but a full screening indicating nothing will drive persistent anxiety.
It is absolutely not the case that more medical intervention is an unqualified good, even ignoring the economic costs.